Preliminary experiments on proposals for the spread of droplets due to tooth brushing in schools

Ji‐Young Son, Hyungrok Do, Seong-Ik Cha, Dong‐Hun HanJournal of Korean Academy of Oral Health 2021 · DOI

Abstract

This pilot study investigates the risk of respiratory droplet transmission during tooth brushing in school settings, a concern that led to the suspension of many dental hygiene programs during the COVID-19 pandemic. Using laser-based Mie Scattering visualization, researchers compared droplet dispersion during conversation, open-mouth brushing, and closed-mouth brushing. Results indicate that while open-mouth brushing significantly increases droplet spread compared to speech (exceeding 1.42 meters), the simple behavioral change of brushing with the mouth closed effectively contains emissions to near-zero levels. These findings suggest a safe protocol for resuming school-based hygiene programs through a combination of technique education and environmental controls.

Introduction

During the COVID-19 pandemic, school-based dental health programs were widely suspended due to fears of "droplet infection." This suspension is significant because school-based facilities are known to double the rate of tooth brushing practice among students compared to schools without such programs. However, the lack of empirical data on the actual risk of aerosol and droplet spread during brushing created a barrier to maintaining these essential health services. This study sought to determine if tooth brushing is inherently a high-risk activity and whether specific modifications could mitigate respiratory transmission risks.

Methods

The researchers employed a Mie Scattering technique to visualize droplets, an optical method where light is scattered by particles similar in size to the wavelength of the light source.

  • Hardware: A 532 nm continuous wave (CW) diode-pumped solid-state laser was expanded to an 800 mm diameter beam to illuminate the area in front of the subjects. Ejected droplets were captured using a high-speed camera (Photron FASTCAM Mini AX100) operating at 1,000 frames per second (FPS).
  • Experimental Setup: Two healthy adult volunteers performed three tasks: normal conversation (pronouncing plosive sounds like "Cha," "Pa," and "Ta"), open-mouth brushing of the upper front teeth (maxillary anterior), and closed-mouth brushing of the same area.
Experimental setup using laser-based Mie Scattering to observe droplet emissions from subjects A and B.

Key Results

The study quantified the maximum horizontal distance of droplet travel for each activity:

  • Conversation: Droplets produced during plosive speech traveled less than 0.5 meters.
  • Open-Mouth Brushing: This activity produced a significantly higher volume and velocity of droplets. The spray traveled beyond the edge of the experimental frame, exceeding 1.42 meters. The mechanical action of the bristles against the lingual (tongue-side) surfaces of the teeth, combined with oral airflow, created a notable "spray" effect.
  • Closed-Mouth Brushing: By simply maintaining a lip seal while moving the brush, the physical barrier of the lips contained almost all visible droplets. The high-speed camera system detected no significant droplet spread under this condition.
High-speed visualization comparing droplet dispersion during open-mouth (top) and closed-mouth (bottom) tooth brushing.

Discussion and Recommendations

The striking efficacy of the "closed-mouth" technique provides a practical path forward for school hygiene. While open-mouth brushing is indeed "messier" than talking, the risk is highly manageable through behavioral intervention.

Based on the 1.42m spread observed in open-mouth conditions, the authors conclude that environmental redundancies are also necessary. They recommend:

  1. Technique Education: Teaching students to keep their lips sealed while brushing.
  2. Environmental Controls: Installing transparent partitions at least 90cm high between sinks and maintaining at least 1 meter of distance between students.

Limitations and Future Work

As a pilot study, the sample size was limited to two adult participants. Future research should involve larger, more diverse demographics, particularly children who may have different motor skills. Additionally, further study is needed to characterize the distribution of droplet sizes (distinguishing between large droplets and fine aerosols) and to test different brushing techniques, such as the use of electric toothbrushes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objectives: Coronavirus (COVID-19) has recently emerged as a major public health problem around the world. There is a high demand for health promotion programs that allow schools and local children's centers to brush their teeth and wash their hands compared to others after lunch; and furthermore, the demand for schools with brushing facilities is twice that of schools without brushing facilities. However, students are returning home without brushing their teeth after lunch at kindergartens and schools, where face-to-face classes are conducted. This situation can be further understood by examining the education office's official letter that considers the risk of "droplet infection" at kindergartens and schools. Thus, this pilot study is interested in identifying the relationship between brushing teeth and the spread of droplets, and proposing proper brushing guidelines for students in schools. Methods: The droplet diffusion test was conducted in three ways: during conversation, when brushing teeth, and when brushing teeth with the mouth closed. A Mie Scattering technique using a continuous wave (CW) laser was performed to observe and compare the distribution of droplets ejected from the oral cavity in this experiment. Results: As a result, it was confirmed that the droplets that spread, while brushing the lingual surface of the maxillary anterior region, were significantly reduced when brushing the teeth with the mouth closed. Conclusions: Based on the results of this study, personal hygiene education such as the school group tooth brushing project and hand washing should be continuously conducted and monitored by installing transparent partitions, and the tooth brushing technique to prevent the spread of droplets in schools.
BibTeX
@article{son2021preliminary,
  author = {Ji‐Young Son and Hyungrok Do and Seong-Ik Cha and Dong‐Hun Han},
  title = {{Preliminary experiments on proposals for the spread of droplets due to tooth brushing in schools}},
  journal = {Journal of Korean Academy of Oral Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.11149/jkaoh.2021.45.3.161},
}
Figure