Preferential bond formation and interstitial/vacancy annihilation rate drive atomic clustering in gallium ion sputtered compound materials

Zhenyu Ma, Xin Zhang, Pu Liu, Yong Deng, Wenyu Hu, Longqing Chen, Jun Zhu, Sen Chen, Zhengshang Wang, Yuechun Shi, Jian Ma, Xiaoyi Wang, Yang Qiu, Kun Zhang, Xudong Cui, Thomas WaltherarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The investigation of chemical reactions during the ion irradiation is a frontier for the study of the ion-material interaction. In order to derive the contribution of bond formation to chemistry of ion produced nanoclusters, the valence electron energy loss spectroscopy (VEELS) was exploited to investigate the Ga$^+$ ion damage in Al$_2$O$_3$, InP and InGaAs, where each target material has been shown to yield different process for altering the clustering of recoil atoms: metallic Ga, metallic In and InGaP clusters in Al$_2$O$_3$, InP and InGaAs respectively. Supporting simulations based on Monte Carlo and crystal orbital Hamiltonian indicate that the chemical constitution of cascade induced nano-precipitates is a result of a competition between interstitial/vacancy consumption rate and preferential bond formation.

Introduction

When researchers use a Focused Ion Beam (FIB) to process materials at the nanoscale, the interaction is often viewed as a purely physical "knock-on" process, similar to high-tech sandblasting. However, recent research reveals that the formation of nanoclusters during gallium ion ($Ga^+$) sputtering is deeply influenced by chemical factors. What happens after the initial collision—the "self-annealing" phase—is a complex interplay between physical displacement and the chemical drive of atoms to form specific bonds.

This study addresses why different target materials produce distinct types of clusters under identical $Ga^+$ irradiation conditions. While physical models like Monte Carlo simulations predict atomic displacement, they often overlook the chemical preferences that dictate how atoms reorganize during the cooling phase of a collision cascade.

Methodology

The research team employed a multi-modal approach to analyze damage zones in three benchmark materials: $\alpha-Al_2O_3$ (sapphire), InP, and InGaAs.

  1. Valence Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (VEELS): This tool was used to identify "plasmons"—collective electron oscillations. Since metallic clusters exhibit different plasmon energies than their host lattices, VEELS can distinguish between integrated atoms and metallic precipitates.
  2. STEM Imaging (HAADF & EDX): High-resolution imaging and X-ray mapping provided structural and elemental context for the observed clusters.
  3. Theoretical Simulations: The team utilized SRIM (Stopping and Range of Ions in Matter) to model physical displacements and COHP (Crystal Orbital Hamilton Population) calculations to quantify chemical bond strengths. COHP is essential for predicting which atomic pairings are energetically favored during the cascade's recovery phase.

Results and Discussion

The study identifies two primary drivers for cluster formation: the recombination rate of defects and chemical bonding preferences.

The Recombination Race and Chemical Preference

Ion impacts create vacancies and interstitials. If these defects annihilate quickly (short-range recombination), the lattice remains relatively stable. If they do not, excess atoms migrate to form clusters. The nature of these clusters depends on bonding stability.

Simulated recoil distributions and target vacancies for Al2O3 (a, d), InP (b, e), and InGaAs (c, f).

In $Al_2O_3$, the Al-O bond is significantly stronger than the Ga-O bond. Consequently, oxygen atoms remain bonded to aluminum, forcing implanted gallium atoms to aggregate into metallic Ga nanoclusters, identified by a VEELS plasmon peak at 14.1 eV.

In InP, the Ga-P bond (24.2) is much more stable than the native In-P bond (0.1). This chemical advantage allows incoming gallium to displace indium and integrate into the lattice, forming a stable $InGaP$ ternary alloy rather than metallic droplets. This was confirmed by a "blue shift" in plasmon energy.

The InGaAs Paradox

In InGaAs, the situation is different. Despite chemical bonding options, the high production rate of indium interstitials overwhelms the material's recombination capacity. As shown in the simulation data, the sheer volume of displaced indium atoms leads to the precipitation of metallic indium clusters, detected as a shoulder peak at ~11.5 eV in VEELS.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that the chemical constitution of ion-induced precipitates is determined by the competition between interstitial/vacancy consumption rates and preferential bond formation. While the current model simplifies a highly non-equilibrium process, it provides a vital framework for "damage-aware" nanofabrication. Future efforts may extend these principles to high-entropy alloys and 2D materials to further refine our ability to predict and control nanoscale phase separations during ion beam processing.

Summary updated

Abstract

The investigation of chemical reactions during the ion irradiation is a frontier for the study of the ion-material interaction. In order to derive the contribution of bond formation to chemistry of ion produced nanoclusters, the valence electron energy loss spectroscopy (VEELS) was exploited to investigate the Ga$^+$ ion damage in Al$_2$O$_3$, InP and InGaAs, where each target material has been shown to yield different process for altering the clustering of recoil atoms: metallic Ga, metallic In and InGaP clusters in Al$_2$O$_3$, InP and InGaAs respectively. Supporting simulations based on Monte Carlo and crystal orbital Hamiltonianindicate that the chemical constitution of cascade induced nano-precipitates is a result of a competition between interstitial/vacancy consumption rate and preferential bond formation.
BibTeX
@misc{ma2023preferential,
  author = {Zhenyu Ma and Xin Zhang and Pu Liu and Yong Deng and Wenyu Hu and Longqing Chen and Jun Zhu and Sen Chen and Zhengshang Wang and Yuechun Shi and Jian Ma and Xiaoyi Wang and Yang Qiu and Kun Zhang and Xudong Cui and Thomas Walther},
  title = {{Preferential bond formation and interstitial/vacancy annihilation rate drive atomic clustering in gallium ion sputtered compound materials}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2305.13746},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13746},
}
Figure