Preferences for stop-based pooled automated vehicles in mode choice models across trip purposes in Flanders, Belgium

Lotte Notelaers, Mohammad Ali Arman, Pieter Vansteenwegen, Chris M.j. TampèreEuropean 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Since regulation will be essential to steer the implementation of vehicle automation in a sustainable direction and automated vehicle services are now being commercially rolled out, urgency increases for governments to gain knowledge of potential user profiles, and insights into mode choice behavior that could guide policy-making. For this purpose, this study conducted an online stated choice survey in Flanders, Belgium, collecting a sample of 645 completed questionnaires. Respondents choose between their current mode of transport and a new hypothetical service with stop-based pooled automated vehicles (AVs) that would operate on-demand and pick-up and drop-off travelers at designated stops for trips they did for work or school, leisure activities and doing groceries. Discrete choice models with different nesting structures were estimated and compared. The results show that for work/school and leisure trips, the stop-based pooled AV service is perceived most resembling to the bus, but also shares substantial similarities with the car, whereas for grocery trips the resemblance is predominantly with bus with little association to the car. Interestingly, accessing the pick-up point and waiting for the pooled AVs is more acceptable than for the bus. Further, the value of travel time of stop-based pooled AV service appears to be less than half of the private car, and almost twice as large as for the bus, across all three different trip purposes: work/school, leisure and groceries.

Introduction: The Challenge of Vehicle Automation

As automated vehicles (AVs) transition from conceptual designs to commercial reality, urban planners face a critical question: will AVs foster a sustainable transport revolution or exacerbate urban congestion? While much research focuses on "door-to-door" services, this study investigates stop-based pooled AVs. These services represent a "middle ground"—more flexible than fixed-route buses but more efficient than private cars by bundling passengers and using designated pick-up points. The researchers aim to understand how travelers value this service across different trip purposes (work/school, leisure, and groceries) and how it might substitute for existing modes.

Methodology: Stated Choice and Advanced Modeling

The study employed an online Stated Preference (SP) survey in Flanders, Belgium. Participants were presented with binary choice scenarios: maintaining their current mode of transport or switching to a hypothetical pooled AV service. The experimental design varied travel times, costs, and wait times to elicit preferences.

Experimental design for the stated choice scenarios, detailing attributes and levels for current modes and the pooled AV option.

To analyze the data, the authors utilized advanced discrete choice models:

  • Nested Logit (NL): Grouping similar modes (e.g., AV and Bus) to capture shared unobserved characteristics.
  • Cross-Nested Logit (CNL): This sophisticated approach allows the AV service to belong to both "car" and "bus" nests simultaneously, capturing its nuanced perception as a hybrid mode.

Data and Representativeness

The primary dataset consists of 645 completed questionnaires, yielding 4,948 choice scenarios. To ensure the sample's validity, the researchers compared it against the Onderzoek Verplaatsingsgedrag 6 (OVG 6), the official Flemish regional travel survey.

Comparison of mode split between the study sample and the OVG 6 population across different trip purposes.

Key Insights: The Hybrid Identity of Pooled AVs

  • The Hybrid Identity: For work, school, and leisure trips, travelers perceive pooled AVs as a hybrid. The CNL models indicated that AVs share characteristics with both cars (flexibility, on-demand nature) and buses (shared space, stop-based).
  • The Grocery Gap: For grocery trips, the "car-like" association largely disappears. The service is viewed almost entirely as a bus, likely due to the "last mile" burden of carrying heavy bags from a designated stop.
  • The "Patience" Premium: Interestingly, respondents were more tolerant of walking to a stop and waiting for a pooled AV than for a traditional bus, suggesting the high-tech, on-demand nature of the service reduces the perceived disutility of waiting.

Key Results: Value of Travel Time (VTT)

The Value of Travel Time (VTT)—the amount a person is willing to pay to save an hour of travel—for AVs consistently sits between traditional modes:

  • Work/School: AV (€11.70/h) vs. Car (€26.52/h) vs. Bus (€6.51/h).
  • Leisure: AV (€8.52/h) vs. Car (€17.31/h) vs. Bus (€5.24/h).

The Cross-Nested Logit (CNL) model provided the best fit for work and leisure trips, confirming that travelers view AVs as a distinct category overlapping private and public transit. Additionally, high-income individuals and families were more likely to favor pooled AVs for leisure trips, seeing them as a comfortable alternative to buses.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While insightful, the study acknowledges several limitations:

  • Hypothetical Bias: Stated preferences may not perfectly predict actual behavior upon service launch.
  • Omitted Variables: Factors like travel time reliability and the onboard environment (e.g., productivity potential) were not explicitly modeled.
  • Vehicle Ownership: The study focused on trip-specific mode choice rather than long-term impacts on car ownership.

Future research should integrate travel time reliability and explore how these services fit into broader "Mobility-as-a-Service" (MaaS) platforms to guide sustainable policy-making.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Since regulation will be essential to steer the implementation of vehicle automation in a sustainable direction and automated vehicle services are now being commercially rolled out, urgency increases for governments to gain knowledge of potential user profiles, and insights into mode choice behavior that could guide policy-making. For this purpose, this study conducted an online stated choice survey in Flanders, Belgium, collecting a sample of 645 completed questionnaires. Respondents choose between their current mode of transport and a new hypothetical service with stop-based pooled automated vehicles (AVs) that would operate on-demand and pick-up and drop-off travelers at designated stops for trips they did for work or school, leisure activities and doing groceries. Discrete choice models with different nesting structures were estimated and compared. The results show that for work/school and leisure trips, the stop-based pooled AV service is perceived most resembling to the bus, but also shares substantial similarities with the car, whereas for grocery trips the resemblance is predominantly with bus with little association to the car. Interestingly, accessing the pick-up point and waiting for the pooled AVs is more acceptable than for the bus. Further, the value of travel time of stop-based pooled AV service appears to be less than half of the private car, and almost twice as large as for the bus, across all three different trip purposes: work/school, leisure and groceries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{notelaers2025preferences,
  author = {Lotte Notelaers and Mohammad Ali Arman and Pieter Vansteenwegen and Chris M.J. Tampère},
  title = {{Preferences for stop-based pooled automated vehicles in mode choice models across trip purposes in Flanders, Belgium}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s12544-025-00756-3},
}
Figure