Preferences for mHealth Technology and Text Messaging Communication in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes: Qualitative Interview Study

Julie C Lauffenburger, Renee A Barlev, Ellen S Sears, Punam A Keller, Marie E McDonnell, Elad Yom-Tov, Constance P Fontanet, Kaitlin Hanken, Nancy Haff, Niteesh K ChoudhryJournal of Medical Internet Research 2021 · OpenReview

Abstract

Background: Individuals with diabetes need regular support to help them manage their diabetes on their own, ideally delivered via mechanisms that they already use, such as their mobile phones. One reason for the modest effectiveness of prior technology-based interventions may be that the patient perspective has been insufficiently incorporated.

Objective: This study aims to understand patients’ preferences for mobile health (mHealth) technology and how that technology can be integrated into patients’ routines, especially with regard to medication use.

Methods: We conducted semistructured qualitative individual interviews with patients with type 2 diabetes from an urban health care system to elicit and explore their perspectives on diabetes medication–taking behaviors, daily patterns of using mobile technology, use of mHealth technology for diabetes care, acceptability of text messages to support medication adherence, and preferred framing of information within text messages to support diabetes care. The interviews were digitally recorded and transcribed. The data were analyzed using codes developed by the study team to generate themes, with representative quotations selected as illustrations.

Results: We conducted interviews with 20 participants, of whom 12 (60%) were female and 9 (45%) were White; in addition, the participants’ mean glycated hemoglobin A1c control was 7.8 (SD 1.1). Overall, 5 key themes were identified: patients try to incorporate cues into their routines to help them with consistent medication taking; many patients leverage some form of technology as a cue to support adherence to medication taking and diabetes self-management behaviors; patients value simplicity and integration of technology solutions used for diabetes care, managing medications, and communicating with health care providers; some patients express reluctance to rely on mobile technology for these diabetes care behaviors; and patients believe they prefer positively framed communication, but communication preferences are highly individualized.

Conclusions: The participants expressed some hesitation about using mobile technology in supporting diabetes self-management but have largely incorporated it or are open to incorporating it as a cue to make medication taking more automatic and less burdensome. When using technology to support diabetes self-management, participants exhibited individualized preferences, but overall, they preferred simple and positively framed communication. mHealth interventions may be improved by focusing on integrating them easily into daily routines and increasing the customization of content.

Introduction

Managing Type 2 diabetes is a relentless, 24/7 task involving complex medication regimens, dietary monitoring, and physical activity. While mobile health (mHealth) interventions, such as automated text reminders, appear to be a logical solution for providing continuous support, their real-world effectiveness has historically been modest.

This study addresses the gap between clinical design and patient reality, arguing that the lack of effectiveness often stems from a failure to incorporate the patient’s perspective during the development phase. By exploring how patients integrate technology into their daily routines and identifying specific communication styles that resonate, this research aims to bridge the gap between engineering intent and patient environment.

Methods

The study employed a qualitative approach, conducting semistructured, one-on-one interviews with 20 patients diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes within an urban healthcare system in Boston.

Participant Cohort

The study cohort (n=20) was 60% female and 45% White, with a mean glycated hemoglobin (A1c) level of 7.8 (SD 1.1). Most participants were managing their condition primarily with oral medications.

Data Collection and Analysis

Interviews lasted between 30 and 75 minutes. Participants discussed their medication-taking behaviors, daily technology usage, and reactions to a set of 15 sample text messages designed to test different framing styles (e.g., positive vs. negative reinforcement). Data were managed using Dedoose (v8.3.10) and analyzed using the immersion-crystallization method. This iterative process involved researchers repeatedly reviewing transcripts to identify and validate emerging themes. The team reached thematic saturation by the 19th participant.

Results

The analysis revealed five primary themes regarding patient preferences and the integration of mHealth into diabetes self-management.

1. Routine Integration and Environmental Cues

Patients do not view their mobile devices as specialized medical tools but rather as general-purpose instruments. Successful medication adherence often relies on physical "sight cues" within the home environment, such as placing pill bottles next to a coffee pot or other daily essentials.

2. Technology as a Habit Cue

Approximately half of the participants already leverage mobile technology—specifically alarms and calendar reminders—as deliberate cues to make medication taking more automatic and less cognitively burdensome. The phone acts as a trigger for a habit rather than a source of medical instruction.

3. The Mandate for Simplicity

Participants expressed a strong preference for simplicity to avoid "digital exhaustion." Long, lecture-heavy messages are frequently ignored. Instead, patients favor direct, actionable, and brief interactions (e.g., "yes/no" confirmations) that do not disrupt their daily flow.

4. Reluctance and the "Obsession" with Data

While data can be helpful, some patients expressed reluctance to rely heavily on technology, fearing it leads to an unhealthy obsession with glucose numbers and constant disease monitoring. Some reported "shutting off" devices to escape the mental exhaustion of being perpetually connected to their condition.

5. Individualized Framing and Social Context

While there was a general preference for positively framed communication (focusing on encouragement rather than fear-based consequences), preferences remained highly individualized. For instance, while some apps attempt to leverage social support from family, many patients found this intrusive or "judgmental," preferring the objective, non-judgmental nature of automated systems over "micro-watching" by family members.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings suggest that while patients are open to using mHealth as a "habit cue," they demand high levels of customization and extreme simplicity. Interventions must fit into existing cognitive and physical environments rather than imposing new burdens.

Limitations

The study's primary limitations include its small sample size (n=20) and its focus on a single urban region, which may limit generalizability to rural or younger populations. Additionally, the cohort primarily used oral medications; those requiring insulin injections may have different management needs and technology preferences.

Future Directions

Future mHealth interventions should prioritize seamless integration into Electronic Health Records (EHRs) and patient portals. The authors recommend applying tailored behavioral science theories to ensure that message content remains relevant and engaging over the long term, moving away from "one-size-fits-all" automated messaging toward highly personalized digital support.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Individuals with diabetes need regular support to help them manage their diabetes on their own, ideally delivered via mechanisms that they already use, such as their mobile phones. One reason for the modest effectiveness of prior technology-based interventions may be that the patient perspective has been insufficiently incorporated.Objective: This study aims to understand patients’ preferences for mobile health (mHealth) technology and how that technology can be integrated into patients’ routines, especially with regard to medication use.Methods: We conducted semistructured qualitative individual interviews with patients with type 2 diabetes from an urban health care system to elicit and explore their perspectives on diabetes medication–taking behaviors, daily patterns of using mobile technology, use of mHealth technology for diabetes care, acceptability of text messages to support medication adherence, and preferred framing of information within text messages to support diabetes care. The interviews were digitally recorded and transcribed. The data were analyzed using codes developed by the study team to generate themes, with representative quotations selected as illustrations.Results: We conducted interviews with 20 participants, of whom 12 (60%) were female and 9 (45%) were White; in addition, the participants’ mean glycated hemoglobin A1c control was 7.8 (SD 1.1). Overall, 5 key themes were identified: patients try to incorporate cues into their routines to help them with consistent medication taking; many patients leverage some form of technology as a cue to support adherence to medication taking and diabetes self-management behaviors; patients value simplicity and integration of technology solutions used for diabetes care, managing medications, and communicating with health care providers; some patients express reluctance to rely on mobile technology for these diabetes care behaviors; and patients believe they prefer positively framed communication, but communication preferences are highly individualized.Conclusions: The participants expressed some hesitation about using mobile technology in supporting diabetes self-management but have largely incorporated it or are open to incorporating it as a cue to make medication taking more automatic and less burdensome. When using technology to support diabetes self-management, participants exhibited individualized preferences, but overall, they preferred simple and positively framed communication. mHealth interventions may be improved by focusing on integrating them easily into daily routines and increasing the customization of content.J Med Internet Res 2021;23(6):e25958doi:10.2196/25958
BibTeX
@article{lauffenburger2021preferences,
  author = {Julie C Lauffenburger and Renee A Barlev and Ellen S Sears and Punam A Keller and Marie E McDonnell and Elad Yom-Tov and Constance P Fontanet and Kaitlin Hanken and Nancy Haff and Niteesh K Choudhry},
  title = {{Preferences for mHealth Technology and Text Messaging Communication in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes: Qualitative Interview Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=XuyMMwcpVR},
}
Figure