Preference between Individual Products and Bundles: Effects of Complementary, Price, and Discount Level in Portugal

Paulo Martins, Paula Rodrigues, Carlos Eduardo Martíns, Teresa Barros, Nelson Duarte, Rebecca Kechen Dong, Yiyi Liao, Ubaldo Comite, Xiao‐Guang YueJournal of Risk and Financial Management 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how consumers in Portugal prefer bundled products versus individual items, focusing on the impact of complementarity, price, and discount levels. The key takeaway is that while complementary products in a bundle are generally preferred, significant discounts (45%) are crucial for bundles to outperform individual items, especially for non-complementary products.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's market, product bundling is a ubiquitous sales strategy. Companies use it to increase sales and profits, but the underlying consumer psychology driving its effectiveness isn't always clear. This paper addresses the question of why bundling works and under what conditions it's most effective. Specifically, it aims to understand if consumers generally prefer bundles over individual products and how factors like how well products "go together" (complementarity), their price, and any offered discounts influence this preference. This knowledge is vital for businesses to design effective marketing strategies and customer value propositions.

Methods

The researchers employed an empirical approach using an online survey distributed to a representative sample of the Portuguese population. To test their hypotheses, they utilized Student's t-tests, a standard statistical method for comparing the means of two groups. The survey collected data on consumer preferences for individual products and various bundle configurations, measured using seven-point Likert scales for quality, attractiveness, and purchase intention. The study systematically varied bundle characteristics, including complementarity (whether products naturally fit together), price level (high vs. low), and discount levels (0%, 20%, and 45%).

Datasets

The study used a custom-designed online questionnaire administered to 375 Portuguese consumers. The sample was designed to be representative of the target population, with respondents being decision-makers aged 20 or older. The data collected focused on consumer evaluations of specific product bundles and individual products. No pre-existing datasets were used for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complementarity is King (Mostly): Bundles where products are complementary (e.g., a laptop and a printer) consistently received higher valuations than non-complementary bundles. This suggests that consumers perceive greater value and convenience when bundled items work together.
  • Discounts Drive Bundle Adoption: Without any discount, individual products are generally preferred. Even a 20% discount isn't enough to sway preferences towards bundles for most scenarios. It takes a substantial discount (45%) for bundles to consistently outperform individual items.
  • Price Matters, But Not Always as Expected: While higher-priced bundles were rated more attractive and of higher quality, this didn't always translate into higher purchase intention. Consumers seem to weigh the perceived value against the cost, indicating a rational economic consideration.
  • The "Gain" Perception: The study hints that consumers are more likely to favor bundles when they perceive them as a "gain," which is strongly linked to complementarity and significant discounts.

Key Results

  • No Discount: Bundles were generally not preferred over individual products when no discount was offered.
  • 20% Discount: Individual products still held a preference. However, high-price complementary bundles showed a slight advantage in quality and attractiveness.
  • 45% Discount: This discount level was the tipping point. Bundles, especially complementary ones, were preferred over individual products across quality, attractiveness, and purchase intention.
  • Complementarity: Complementary bundles were consistently preferred over non-complementary bundles across all scales (quality, attractiveness, purchase intention), with statistically significant differences.
  • Price Level: High-price bundles were rated higher in quality and attractiveness than low-price bundles, but purchase intention was similar, suggesting price sensitivity.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Arbitrary Discount/Price Levels: The specific discount percentages (20%, 45%) and price levels (high/low) were chosen without extensive prior justification and could be subject to criticism.
  • Two-Item Bundles Only: The study focused exclusively on two-item bundles, which is common but doesn't represent the complexity of multi-item bundles found in the market. Generalizing these findings to larger bundles requires further research.
  • Durable Goods Focus: The products evaluated were durable goods. The findings might differ for non-durable goods, suggesting a need for broader product category analysis.
  • Cultural Specificity: The study was conducted in Portugal. Comparing these results with data from other countries could reveal cultural nuances in consumer bundling preferences.

Future research could explore these limitations by investigating multi-item bundles, different product categories, and cross-cultural comparisons.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper aims to (1) compare consumers’ preferences between individual products and bundles as well as (2) investigate some of the factors involved in bundle characteristics that may affect consumer’s preferences. Those factors are complementarity, price level, and discount level. An online survey developed by means of questionnaires were collected from the Portuguese population. Student’s t-tests were used to test the hypothesis formulated and to analyze the consumers’ preferences. The findings corroborate that in a scenario where the bundle does not offer any discounts, preference of individual products is higher. When a 20% discount is assigned to bundles, the overall preference for individual products is still superior. By offering a discount level of 45%, the overall preference for bundles becomes higher. The positive effect of complementarity bundles valuation is confirmed. This is the first approach to evaluate the preferences between bundles and individual products in the Portuguese market. The findings contribute to clarify the customer map within a Business Model Canvas. Furthermore, this paper analyzes the bundle complementarity and discount level effects simultaneously.
BibTeX
@article{martins2021preference,
  author = {Paulo Martins and Paula Rodrigues and Carlos Eduardo Martíns and Teresa Barros and Nelson Duarte and Rebecca Kechen Dong and Yiyi Liao and Ubaldo Comite and Xiao‐Guang Yue},
  title = {{Preference between Individual Products and Bundles: Effects of Complementary, Price, and Discount Level in Portugal}},
  journal = {Journal of Risk and Financial Management},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jrfm14050192},
}
Figure