Preface

IJCAI 2009

The Twenty-first International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI-09) marked a significant milestone: the fortieth anniversary of the conference series since its inception in 1969. In his preface to the proceedings, Program Chair Craig Boutilier reflects on the evolution of the field, characterizing AI not merely as a sub-discipline of computer science, but as a vibrant, interdisciplinary enterprise with a reach extending into the social sciences, medicine, engineering, and the arts.

The Interdisciplinary Mandate

A primary theme of IJCAI-09 was the "outward-looking" nature of artificial intelligence. By 2009, the field had moved beyond foundational algorithmic development to engage deeply with other complex systems. This was reflected in the invited speaker program, which featured experts discussing the intersection of AI with economics, the origins of language, and music. The preface argues that this interdisciplinarity is a core value, demonstrating that AI provides essential tools for understanding and modeling human endeavors across diverse domains.

Rigor in Peer Review

To maintain the high academic standards expected of a premier venue, IJCAI-09 employed a rigorous, multi-tiered peer-review process. The methodology was designed to ensure both quality and fairness through several layers of validation:

  • Triple-Tier Review: Each submission was evaluated by at least three program committee members, overseen by a senior program committee member and an area chair.
  • Author Feedback Loop: A rebuttal phase allowed authors to address specific concerns or misunderstandings in the initial reviews, providing a crucial dialogue before final decisions were reached.
  • Face-to-Face Deliberation: In an era of increasing digitization, the conference maintained the practice of in-person meetings for area chairs to finalize selections, ensuring nuanced discussion of borderline cases.

Quantitative Outcomes and Distinguished Research

The scale of the conference reflected the health of the AI community. Out of 1,291 submissions, only 331 papers were accepted, representing a competitive acceptance rate of 25.6%. This selectivity served as a signal of research quality and helped define the trajectory of the field.

Two papers were specifically recognized for their outstanding contributions to the state-of-the-art:

  1. "Learning Conditional Preference Networks with Queries" by Frédéric Koriche and Bruno Zanuttini, which advanced the field of preference elicitation.
  2. "Consequence-Driven Reasoning for Horn SHIQ Ontologies" by Yevgeny Kazakov, which provided significant insights into efficient reasoning within complex ontologies.

Beyond the main technical track, the conference integrated 35 workshops and 19 tutorials, providing a comprehensive environment for deep dives into specialized topics and emerging trends.

Conclusion

The IJCAI-09 Preface serves as a historical snapshot of a field in transition. Forty years after its founding, the AI community was neither in a "winter" nor isolated; instead, it was expanding its influence. By balancing rigorous internal standards with an open, interdisciplinary outlook, the conference reaffirmed AI's role as a foundational pillar of modern scientific inquiry.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{2009preface,
  title = {{Preface}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2009},
}
Figure