Predictors of Adherence to Treatment in Behavioral Health Therapy for Latino Immigrants: The Importance of Trust

Irene Falgas‐Bagué, Ye Wang, Souvik Banerjee, Naomi Ali, Karissa DiMarzio, Diego Palao, Margarita Alegrı́aFrontiers in Psychiatry 2019 · DOI

Introduction

Latino immigrants in the United States and Europe often face a "double jeopardy" regarding behavioral health. While they experience high rates of co-occurring mental health and substance use disorders (COD), they access specialized treatment at significantly lower rates than non-Latino Whites. Furthermore, even when they do enter care, they are more likely to drop out prematurely. Understanding the barriers to care is critical to ensuring patients receive a sufficient "dosage" of treatment. This study investigated how perceived barriers, sociodemographic factors, and clinical characteristics predict treatment adherence among Latino immigrants participating in a clinical trial.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a multisite analysis as part of the International Latino Research Partnership, utilizing data from a randomized clinical trial testing the Integrated Intervention for Dual problems and Early Action (IIDEA). The sample consisted of 172 Latino immigrants (ages 18–70) recruited from community settings in Boston (USA), Madrid (Spain), and Barcelona (Spain).

The IIDEA intervention is a 10-session program combining Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), psychoeducation, and mindfulness, specifically adapted for Latino immigrants. Key features included linguistic matching (all clinicians were fluent Spanish speakers) and flexible delivery (e.g., phone sessions, weekend availability).

Participants were categorized into three "terciles" based on their attendance:

  • Tercile 1: 0–1 sessions (low adherence/early dropout)
  • Tercile 2: 2–9 sessions (moderate adherence)
  • Tercile 3: 10–12 sessions (high adherence/completion)

The team used multinomial logistic regression models to examine the association between baseline barriers, psychosocial factors, clinical factors, and treatment adherence.

Results: The "Mistrust Paradox"

The study's most significant finding was a counterintuitive relationship between initial mistrust and eventual program completion. Participants who reported "mistrust in previous treatment" or "thinking treatment wouldn't work" at baseline were significantly more likely to complete the full program.

Table 3: Reported barriers to care by treatment adherence tercile. Note the higher percentage of 'Yes' responses for 'Think the previous treatment would not work' in the high-adherence group (Tercile 3).

As shown in the regression analysis, those expressing mistrust in previous treatments had nearly four times the odds of completing the program compared to those who did not report this barrier, after adjusting for other factors.

Table 4: Multinomial logistic regression results showing that mistrust in previous treatment (OR = 3.79) was the only barrier significantly associated with program completion.

Other key results included:

  • Completion Rates: 37.2% of participants completed the full 10+ session program.
  • Site Variance: Adherence was significantly lower in Barcelona compared to Boston or Madrid, suggesting regional differences in healthcare infrastructure or immigrant integration.
  • Clinical Severity: Baseline clinical severity (e.g., levels of depression or anxiety) did not independently predict adherence once barriers and demographics were factored in.

Discussion

The "Mistrust Paradox" suggests that individuals with high levels of mistrust may have had negative experiences with inflexible, culturally insensitive standard care in the past. When presented with the IIDEA model—which utilized ethnically matched providers, Spanish-language services, and flexible scheduling—these high-risk patients may have experienced a stronger therapeutic alliance, leading to higher engagement.

Furthermore, reporting multiple barriers (three or more) was associated with higher adherence. This suggests that patients who are vocal about their obstacles might possess higher "problem recognition" and a greater underlying motivation to seek help if those specific obstacles are addressed by the provider.

Conclusion

Evidence-based and culturally tailored interventions provided by ethnically matched providers can effectively overcome cultural mistrust and increase adherence among Latino immigrants. The findings highlight that access and trust are often more decisive factors in treatment retention than symptom severity. Future work should continue to explore how to replicate these high levels of cultural and linguistic matching within standard public health systems to better serve immigrant populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

A complex array of barriers to care influence patients' adherence to behavioral healthcare services. Understanding barriers to care is critical to ensure sufficient dosage of treatment. This study assessed the influence of perceived barriers on Latino migrants' prospective adherence to treatment for co-occurring mental health and substance use disorders as part of a clinical trial. Eligible participants (18-70 years-old) were recruited from community-based settings and classified according to their intervention session attendance. Baseline assessments included socio-demographic factors, clinical characteristics (i.e., depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, substance use), psychosocial and cultural factors (i.e., ethnic identity, health literacy, discrimination), and perceived attitudinal and structural barriers to care. Treatment involved 10-sessions of cognitive-behavioral therapy, psychoeducation, and mindfulness (Integrated Intervention for Dual problems and Early Action) and emphasized participant's engagement in treatment. We used multinomial logistic regression models to examine the association between barriers to care reported at baseline, sociodemographic characteristics, psychosocial and cultural factors, clinical factors, and treatment adherence. Mistrust in previous behavioral health treatment(s) was the reported barrier significantly associated with completion of the program after adjusting for clinical, psychosocial, and cultural factors, with those expressing mistrust in previous treatment(s) showing higher rates of completion compared to those who did not report this barrier. Evidence-based and culturally-tailored interventions provided by ethnically matched providers may overcome cultural mistrust and increase adherence to behavioral health care among Latino immigrants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{falgasbague2019predictors,
  author = {Irene Falgas‐Bagué and Ye Wang and Souvik Banerjee and Naomi Ali and Karissa DiMarzio and Diego Palao and Margarita Alegrı́a},
  title = {{Predictors of Adherence to Treatment in Behavioral Health Therapy for Latino Immigrants: The Importance of Trust}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00817},
}
Figure