Predictive State Observer-Based Aircraft Distributed Formation Tracking Considering Input Delay and Saturations

Liguo Sun, Xiaoyu Liu, Wenqian Tan, Yi Deng, Junkai Jiao, Mengjie ZhaoDrones 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the complex challenge of coordinating multiple fixed-wing aircraft in formation, specifically addressing the critical issues of input delays and actuator saturation. They propose a novel "Predictive Extended State Observer-Based Fully Distributed Time-Varying Formation Tracking Control" (PESO-TVFTC) protocol that effectively handles these real-world constraints, enabling more robust and accurate formation flight.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coordinating a group of aircraft to fly in a precise formation is a significant engineering feat. Fixed-wing aircraft, unlike their multirotor counterparts, have inherent limitations that make this even harder. These include:

  • Input Delays: The time it takes for an engine command to translate into actual thrust, or for control surface movements to affect flight, introduces delays. These delays can destabilize a formation, causing oscillations or even loss of control.
  • Model Uncertainties: Aircraft dynamics aren't perfectly known and can change due to factors like atmospheric conditions or payload variations.
  • Actuator Saturation: Aircraft control surfaces and engines have physical limits on how much they can move or how much thrust they can generate. Exceeding these limits (saturation) can lead to unexpected behavior.
  • Distributed Control: Ideally, each aircraft should only need information from its neighbors, not a central controller, for robustness and scalability.

Previous research has addressed some of these issues, but simultaneously handling time-varying input delays, actuator saturation, and ensuring a fully distributed control strategy for fixed-wing aircraft formations remained an open problem.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of the Predictive Extended State Observer-Based Fully Distributed Time-Varying Formation Tracking Control (PESO-TVFTC) protocol. Here's a breakdown of the key components:

  • Predictive Extended State Observer (PESO): This is the heart of the solution. It's an advanced observer that not only estimates the current state of the aircraft but also predicts future states. This predictive capability is crucial for compensating for the input time delays. It's built upon the concept of Extended State Observers (ESOs), which are known for their ability to estimate and compensate for disturbances and uncertainties.
  • Fully Distributed Control: The proposed protocol ensures that each aircraft only relies on information from its immediate neighbors and its own state. This avoids the need for a global information center, making the system more resilient to individual component failures.
  • Low Gain Feedback (LGF): To address the actuator saturation problem, the authors incorporate a Low Gain Feedback technique. This method helps to ensure that the control commands generated by the system remain within the physical limits of the aircraft's actuators, preventing stalls or spins.
  • Time-Varying Formation Tracking: The control strategy is designed to handle formations that can change their shape or relative positions over time, which is essential for dynamic missions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on a simulated model of F-18 carrier aircraft and its parameters, rather than real-world datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Prediction is Key for Delays: The paper strongly demonstrates that actively predicting future states (via the PESO) is a highly effective way to counteract the negative effects of input time delays in formation control.
  • LGF for Saturation: Integrating Low Gain Feedback is shown to be a practical and effective way to manage actuator saturation without compromising formation stability.
  • Synergy of PESO and LGF: The combination of PESO and LGF provides a powerful framework for addressing both input delays and saturation simultaneously in a distributed manner.
  • Time-Delay Bounds for Performance: The research provides a theoretical link between the time delay and the achievable performance of the formation tracking system, offering practical guidance for controller tuning.

Key Results

The paper presents theoretical stability analysis and simulation results.

  • Theoretical Guarantees: The authors provide mathematical proofs demonstrating that their PESO-TVFTC protocol can achieve time-varying formation tracking consensus under specific initial conditions and feasibility constraints.
  • Simulation Performance:
    • The proposed PESO-TVFTC method significantly reduces formation tracking errors compared to a classical ESO-TVFTC approach, especially in the presence of input delays.
  • In simulations, formation tracking errors converged to a sufficiently small positive constant, and aircraft velocities stabilized effectively.
  • The control inputs were shown to remain within the defined saturation constraints, validating the effectiveness of the LGF technique.
  • The simulation included scenarios of formation assembly, change, and flight through a challenging valley slit, showcasing the protocol's versatility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Initial Conditions: The stability guarantees are semi-global, meaning they require specific bounded initial conditions for the aircraft states. While the authors argue this is reasonable for practical mission areas, it's a theoretical limitation.
  • Known Time-Delay: The current PESO design assumes that the time delay information is known. The paper notes that the method is theoretically applicable even if time-varying delay derivatives are known, but this is still a significant assumption.
  • Parameter Drift: The authors suggest that future work could focus on improving the method to handle parameter drift caused by measurement noise.
  • Obstacle Avoidance: Combining their control law with potential field or geometric methods is proposed as a future direction to address obstacle avoidance and inter-aircraft collision avoidance.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper investigates a fully distributed time-varying formation tracking problem for a group of fixed-wing aircraft. The fixed-wing aircraft formation control system consists of an outer-loop trajectory control subsystem and an inner-loop attitude control subsystem. For fixed-wing aircraft, it is crucial to consider the time delay of the engine response, the model uncertainties, the tracking capability of the attitude commands in the inner loop, and other agility performances of the aircraft. To address the problems related to the input time delay and model uncertainties, a predictive extended state observer-based fully distributed time-varying formation tracking control (PESO-TVFTC) protocol is proposed. To satisfy the constraints set by the attitude tracking quickness and the trajectory tracking smoothness, the low gain feedback technique is introduced in the protocol to keep the control inputs for the outer loop within the desired saturation constraints. Through theoretical analysis, it is proved that the multiple aircraft systems can achieve time-varying formation tracking consensus under specific initial conditions and feasibility conditions, and it is shown that the upper bounds of the PESO gains are restricted by the time delay. Numerical simulations are used to demonstrate the effectiveness of and the improvements in the proposed method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2024predictive,
  author = {Liguo Sun and Xiaoyu Liu and Wenqian Tan and Yi Deng and Junkai Jiao and Mengjie Zhao},
  title = {{Predictive State Observer-Based Aircraft Distributed Formation Tracking Considering Input Delay and Saturations}},
  booktitle = {Drones},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/drones8010023},
}
Figure