Predictive markers of depression in hypertension

Xiuli Song, Zhong Zhang, Rui Zhang, Miye Wang, Dongtao Lin, Tao Li, Junming Shao, Xiaohong MaMedicine 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages machine learning (specifically Support Vector Machines) to identify blood test and vital sign markers that can distinguish hypertensive patients who also have depression from those with hypertension alone. The findings suggest that a combination of common clinical measurements can aid in the early detection of depression in this vulnerable patient population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hypertension and depression are two prevalent public health issues that frequently co-occur. For individuals with hypertension, depression is not just a comorbid condition but a significant risk factor for mortality and reduced quality of life. A major challenge in clinical practice is the timely and accurate identification of depression in hypertensive patients, as it often goes undiagnosed. This delay can lead to poorer health outcomes. The authors aim to bridge this gap by exploring whether readily available clinical data – blood tests and vital signs – can be used to develop a predictive model for depression in hypertensive individuals.

Methods

The core of this study lies in the application of Support Vector Machine (SVM) learning. SVM is a powerful supervised machine learning algorithm used for classification. In this context, it was trained to differentiate between two groups of patients: those with hypertension and depression, and those with hypertension only.

The process involved:

  • Feature Selection: An information gain-based approach was used to identify the most relevant features (blood tests and vital signs) from a large initial set.
  • Classification: The selected features were then used to train an SVM model.
  • Validation: To ensure the robustness and generalizability of the model, a 10-fold cross-validation technique was employed. This method systematically splits the data into ten subsets, using nine for training and one for testing, repeating this process ten times to obtain a more reliable estimate of performance.

This approach is a standard yet effective method for building predictive models from complex datasets, and its application here is aimed at uncovering novel diagnostic markers.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the electronic medical records of patients admitted to West China Hospital of Sichuan University between January 1, 2011, and October 31, 2016.

  • Patient Cohorts:
    • Hypertension with Depression group: 147 patients (diagnosed using ICD-10 categories F32.x and F33.x for depression and I10.x for hypertension).
  • Hypertension Alone group: 147 patients (diagnosed using ICD-10 category I10.x for hypertension).
  • Data Points: The dataset included demographic information (age, sex, race, marital status), blood test results (e.g., glucose, albumin, creatinine, cholesterol, total protein), and vital signs (e.g., body temperature, pulse, respiration).
  • Matching: The two groups were matched for age and sex to minimize potential confounding factors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Clinical Data as Predictive Power: The study demonstrates that common, readily available clinical measurements (blood tests and vital signs) hold significant predictive power for identifying depression in hypertensive patients. This moves beyond solely relying on subjective clinical assessments or expensive imaging techniques.
  • SVM's Efficacy: SVM proved to be an effective tool for classifying these complex patient groups, highlighting its utility in medical diagnostics for identifying subtle patterns in physiological data.
  • Interconnectedness of Physiology and Mental Health: The identified markers (e.g., glucose, albumin, creatine kinase, body temperature) suggest a complex interplay between metabolic, enzymatic, and thermoregulatory systems and the pathophysiology of depression in the context of hypertension. This hints at underlying biological mechanisms that link these conditions.
  • Potential for Early Intervention: By identifying these markers, the research opens avenues for earlier screening and intervention, potentially improving patient outcomes and reducing the burden of undiagnosed depression.

Key Results

The SVM-based classification achieved an overall accuracy of 73.5% in distinguishing between patients with hypertension and depression versus those with hypertension alone, using a 10-fold cross-validation.

The study identified twelve key features that formed the optimal feature set for classification, ranked by importance:

  1. Body temperature (0.1084)
  2. Glucose (0.0773)
  3. Creatine Kinase (0.0671)
  4. Albumin (0.0594)
  5. Hydroxybutyrate Dehydrogenase (0.0528)
  6. Blood urea nitrogen (0.0527)
  7. Uric acid (0.0513)
  8. Creatinine (0.0491)
  9. Cholesterol (0.0468)
  10. Total protein (0.0438)
  11. Pulse rate (0.0370)
  12. Respiration rate (0.0333)

The confusion matrix showed that the model correctly recognized 115 out of 147 patients in the comorbidity group (hypertension and depression), resulting in a sensitivity of 78.2% and a precision of 71.4%.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size and Complexity: While the study used a matched sample, increasing the complexity of the patient data (e.g., including more diverse comorbidities or genetic information) could enhance SVM's adaptation and predictive power.
  • Retrospective Design: The study design was retrospective, which could introduce enrollment bias and affect the algorithm's classification accuracy. A prospective, consecutive design is recommended for future research.
  • Body Mass Index (BMI): The absence of BMI data limited the ability to draw firm conclusions about its influence on the screened markers, especially concerning nutrition. Future studies should incorporate BMI assessment.
  • Antidepressant Side Effects: The potential influence of antidepressant drug side effects on biochemical markers was noted. While efforts were made to control for this (e.g., using recommended dosages), it remains a factor. The study also lacked specific data on antidepressant use, which would be valuable for future analysis.

Future work should focus on:

  • Prospective Studies: Validating these findings in prospective studies with larger and more diverse cohorts.
  • Incorporating More Data: Exploring the inclusion of additional data types, such as genetic information, inflammatory markers, and detailed nutritional status (BMI), to refine the predictive model.
  • Investigating Causal Mechanisms: Further research is needed to elucidate the precise biological mechanisms linking the identified markers to the pathophysiology of depression in hypertensive patients.
  • Clinical Utility: Developing and testing the practical clinical utility of this SVM-based approach for routine screening and diagnosis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hypertension and depression, as 2 major public health issues, are closely related. For patients having hypertension, in particular, depression is a risk factor for mortality and jeopardizes their wellbeing. The aim of the study is to apply support vector machine (SVM) learning to blood tests and vital signs to classify patients having hypertension complicated by depression and patients having hypertension alone for the identification of novel markers.Data on patients having both hypertension and depression (n = 147) and patients having hypertension alone (n = 147) were obtained from electronic medical records of admissions containing the records on blood tests and vital signs. Using SVM, we distinguished patients having both hypertension and depression from gender- and age-matched patients having hypertension alone.SVM-based classification achieved 73.5% accuracy by 10-fold cross-validation between patients having both hypertension and depression and those having hypertension alone. Twelve features were selected to compose the optimal feature sets, including body temperature (T), glucose (GLU), creatine kinase (CK), albumin (ALB), hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase (HBDH), blood urea nitrogen (BUN), uric Acid (UA), creatinine (Crea), cholesterol (TC), total protein (TP), pulse (P), and respiration (R).SVM can be used to distinguish patients having both hypertension and depression from those having hypertension alone. A significant association was identified between depression and blood tests and vital signs. This approach can be helpful for clinical diagnosis of depression, but further studies are needed to verify the role of these candidate markers for depression diagnosis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2018predictive,
  author = {Xiuli Song and Zhong Zhang and Rui Zhang and Miye Wang and Dongtao Lin and Tao Li and Junming Shao and Xiaohong Ma},
  title = {{Predictive markers of depression in hypertension}},
  booktitle = {Medicine},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1097/md.0000000000011768},
}
Figure