Predictions of Binding of a Diverse Set of Ligands to Gelatinase-A by a Combination of Molecular Dynamics and Continuum Solvent Models

Tingjun Hou, Senli Guo, Xiaojie XuThe Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2002 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a computational approach, MM/PBSA, to accurately predict the binding affinities of small molecules (inhibitors) to a target protein (gelatinase-A). The method successfully ranks a diverse set of inhibitors and reproduces experimental binding energies, suggesting its utility for drug discovery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting how strongly a small molecule will bind to a protein is a fundamental challenge in drug discovery. This is crucial for identifying potential drug candidates. Traditional methods like FEP and TI are computationally expensive and difficult to apply to large-scale screening. Simpler docking methods often lack accuracy because they don't fully account for protein flexibility, desolvation effects, or entropic contributions. This paper aims to address this by evaluating a more advanced computational method, MM/PBSA, for its ability to accurately and efficiently predict protein-ligand binding affinities.

Methods

The core of this study involves using Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations to generate representative conformations of protein-ligand complexes. These trajectories are then used to calculate binding free energies using the MM/PBSA (Molecular Mechanics/Poisson-Boltzmann Surface Area) approach. This method breaks down the binding free energy into several components:

  • MM Energy (EMM): Standard molecular mechanics energy (van der Waals and electrostatic interactions within the complex).
  • Polar Solvation Energy (GPB): Calculated using the Poisson-Boltzmann equation, which models how polar solvent molecules interact with charged and polar parts of the complex.
  • Nonpolar Solvation Energy (GNP): Estimated from the solvent-accessible surface area (SAS), representing the energy cost of creating a cavity in the solvent for the molecule.
  • Entropy (TS): Estimated using normal-mode analysis, accounting for the vibrational, rotational, and translational contributions to the free energy.

For comparison, the authors also employed the Linear Interaction Energy (LIE) approximation, which relies on averaging interaction energies in both bound and unbound states.

A key methodological detail is the use of a nonbonded model for the catalytic zinc center in gelatinase-A, which is a departure from some previous studies that used bonded models. The construction of initial protein-ligand complex structures was based on homology modeling using a crystal structure of a related enzyme (MMP-3).

Datasets

The study utilizes a dataset of eight diverse hydroxamate inhibitors that are known to interact with gelatinase-A (MMP-2). These inhibitors were selected from the literature and are characterized by varying binding affinities. The experimental binding free energy data for these inhibitors were used for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MM/PBSA as a powerful tool: The study strongly suggests that MM/PBSA is a robust and accurate method for predicting protein-ligand binding affinities, capable of both ranking ligands and reproducing experimental values.
  • Dominance of van der Waals interactions: For the hydroxamate inhibitors studied, the binding to MMP-2 is primarily driven by favorable van der Waals and nonpolar interactions within the binding pocket, rather than electrostatic forces.
  • Importance of desolvation: The electrostatic interactions between the ligand and water molecules in solution are often stronger than those with the protein, making desolvation a critical factor that MM/PBSA effectively captures.
  • Nonbonded zinc model is viable: The use of a nonbonded model for the catalytic zinc center, while different from some prior work, yielded comparable and reliable results, suggesting flexibility in modeling such active sites.
  • Entropy estimation is challenging but crucial: While normal-mode analysis for entropy is computationally intensive and has limitations (e.g., harmonic approximation), it is a necessary component for accurate free energy calculations.

Key Results

  • Good correlation with experiment: The MM/PBSA predictions showed a good correlation with experimental binding free energies, with a regression coefficient (r) of 0.84 and a cross-validated coefficient (q) of 0.78.
  • Accurate ranking: The MM/PBSA approach successfully ranked the eight studied ligands according to their binding affinities.
  • LIE comparison: While LIE also provided reasonable results, the MM/PBSA method, particularly with a three-parameter fit, achieved a higher correlation (q² = 0.83) and a lower average unsigned error (0.58 kcal/mol) compared to some LIE models.
  • Energy decomposition: Analysis revealed that favorable van der Waals/nonpolar interactions contribute significantly to the binding, often compensating for less favorable electrostatic interactions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational cost of entropy: The authors acknowledge that the normal-mode analysis for entropy estimation is computationally very demanding, limiting the practical application of MM/PBSA for large-scale screening.
  • Water rearrangement entropy: The entropy change due to the rearrangement of water molecules near the binding site is not explicitly considered, which could be a source of error.
  • Harmonic approximation for entropy: Normal-mode analysis relies on a harmonic approximation, which may not fully capture anharmonic contributions to entropy.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest exploring faster methods for entropy estimation (e.g., covariance-matrix methods, empirical methods) and more efficient solvation models (e.g., generalized Born or WSAS) to reduce computational cost and improve the applicability of MM/PBSA for drug discovery. Further investigation into the optimal modeling of the catalytic zinc center is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

The free energies of binding, ΔGbind, between a diverse set of eight hydroxamate inhibitors with gelatinase-A (MMP-2) were computed by using the recently developed MM/PBSA approach. In this paper, a nonbonded model was used to represent the potentials of the catalytic zinc center. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were used to generate the thermally averaged ensemble of conformations of the ligand−protein complexes. On the basis of the trajectories from MD simulations, the free energies of binding were calculated using molecular mechanics, the continuum solvent model, surface area estimation, and normal-mode analysis. The results show that MM/PBSA not only can rank the studied ligands effectively but also can reproduce the experimental binding free energies successfully. The predicted binding free energies correlate well with the experimental values (r = 0.84, q = 0.78). As a comparison, the free energies of binding were also computed by using the linear interaction energy approximation (LIE). The overall agreement between the calculated and experimental values for the diverse set of ligands means that the MM/PBSA approach is a useful tool for the general evaluation of protein−ligand interactions. The analysis of the separate energy terms contributing to MM/PBSA free energy indicates that the association between hydroxamate and MMP-2 is mainly driven by more favorable van der Waals/nonpolar interactions in the complex than in solution.
BibTeX
@article{hou2002predictions,
  author = {Tingjun Hou and Senli Guo and Xiaojie Xu},
  title = {{Predictions of Binding of a Diverse Set of Ligands to Gelatinase-A by a Combination of Molecular Dynamics and Continuum Solvent Models}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry B},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1021/jp015516z},
}
Figure