Prediction of Traffic Vibration Environment of Ancient Wooden Structures Based on the Response Transfer Ratio Function

Cheng Zhang, Nan Zhang, Yunshi Zhang, Xiao Liu2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel vibration prediction method for ancient wooden structures, using the Response Transfer Ratio (RTR) function to accurately forecast traffic-induced vibrations. By validating this method with field tests on the Feiyun Pavilion, the study demonstrates its effectiveness in assessing structural safety and provides crucial recommendations for managing traffic to protect these historical buildings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traffic-induced vibrations are a growing concern, impacting not only daily life and precision instruments but also the structural integrity of buildings, especially ancient wooden structures. While existing methods for predicting such vibrations include theoretical analyses, numerical simulations, field tests, and empirical formulas, each has limitations. Theoretical methods often rely on oversimplified assumptions, numerical methods struggle with complex modeling and parameter determination, and empirical formulas require extensive data. Furthermore, existing field tests have primarily focused on high-rise structures, leaving a gap in understanding the long-term, low-amplitude vibrations from traffic on ancient wooden structures with diverse features. This paper aims to fill this gap by proposing and validating a more accurate and practical prediction method.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development and application of a Response Transfer Ratio (RTR) function for vibration prediction. Unlike traditional transfer functions that require input and output measurements, the RTR function utilizes the ratio of responses between subsystems, making it more practical when direct input excitation is difficult to measure.

The method involves:

  • Defining the RTR: The RTR is defined as the ratio of output responses between two points or subsystems. For complex systems, a multipoint RTR is used, which is the product of individual RTRs along the transfer path.
  • Frequency Domain Analysis: The RTR method operates in the frequency domain, allowing for accurate prediction of vibration spectral characteristics, which is crucial for identifying frequencies that could cause significant damage to ancient structures (e.g., natural frequencies).
  • Octave Time-History Data: Accelerations are processed into one-third octave bands to analyze specific frequency ranges.
  • Amplitude-RTR and RMS-RTR: Two types of RTR are calculated: one based on the maximum acceleration values and another based on the root-mean-square (RMS) values within each frequency band.
  • Hammer Excitation for Calibration: To obtain the RTR function, artificial excitation using a drop-weight hammer is employed. This method is chosen because it's assumed that the RTR is an inherent property of the structure and is independent of the excitation source's energy or spectral characteristics, allowing hammer excitation results to represent traffic-induced vibration transfer.
  • Prediction and Evaluation: The measured traffic-induced vibration at a source replacement point is used as input, and the calibrated RTR is applied to predict the vibration at the target prediction point. The accuracy is then evaluated by comparing predicted and measured values.

Datasets

The study utilizes data collected from:

  • Field tests on the Feiyun Pavilion: This includes measurements of traffic-induced vibrations and controlled hammer excitations.
  • Heavy-duty truck tests: Data from trucks of varying speeds (30, 40, 50 km/h) were collected to simulate extreme traffic loading scenarios.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the paper focuses on applying the developed method to a specific historical structure.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RTR as an Inherent Structural Property: A key finding is that the RTR function is largely independent of the excitation energy and spectral characteristics. This means that a calibrated RTR using artificial excitation (like hammer drops) can reliably predict vibrations from different sources, such as traffic.
  • Frequency Domain is Crucial for Ancient Structures: The ability of the RTR method to operate in the frequency domain is vital. It allows for the identification of specific frequency bands that are most damaging to ancient wooden structures, enabling more targeted safety assessments.
  • Multipoint RTR for Complex Systems: For structures like the Feiyun Pavilion, which can be viewed as a system of multiple interconnected parts, the multipoint RTR approach is essential for accurately capturing vibration transmission through the entire structure.
  • Traffic Vibration Exceeds Limits: The study's prediction for extreme traffic loading scenarios indicates that even at moderate speeds, vibrations can exceed established safety limits for historical buildings, highlighting the urgent need for traffic management.

Key Results

  • High Prediction Accuracy: The proposed RTR-based prediction method demonstrated good accuracy in both time and frequency domains when compared to measured data.
  • For amplitude-RTR prediction, the error in maximum acceleration was 1.8%, and the RMS error was 6.1%.
  • For RMS-RTR prediction, the error in maximum acceleration was 4.5%, and the RMS error was 3.1%.
  • Structural Safety Concerns: Predictions for heavy-duty truck traffic showed that vibration levels at the highest point of the Feiyun Pavilion exceeded the allowable limit of 0.18 mm/s even at the lowest tested speed (30 km/h).
  • Frequency Band Analysis: The analysis confirmed that traffic vibrations are primarily low-frequency (5-60 Hz), with significant attenuation above 40 Hz as they transmit through the structure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Signal-to-Noise Ratio: The authors acknowledge that the signal-to-noise ratio of traffic-induced vibration data can be poor, potentially affecting prediction accuracy.
  • Complex On-Site Environment: The complexity of the testing environment can lead to signal disturbances.
  • Frequency Band Limitation: The prediction primarily focuses on an "excellent frequency band," potentially overlooking vibration energy in other bands.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further research could explore the influence of different types of ancient wooden structures and refine the prediction model to account for more complex vibration phenomena. The findings strongly recommend limiting vehicle types and speeds in the vicinity of ancient wooden structures to ensure their preservation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhang2022prediction,
  author = {Cheng Zhang and Nan Zhang and Yunshi Zhang and Xiao Liu},
  title = {{Prediction of Traffic Vibration Environment of Ancient Wooden Structures Based on the Response Transfer Ratio Function}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22218414},
}

Loading related content...

Figure