Prediction of the COVID-19 outbreak in China based on a new stochastic dynamic model

Yuan Zhang, Chong You, Zhenhao Cai, Jiarui Sun, Wenjie Hu, Xiao‐Hua ZhouScientific 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel stochastic dynamic model to better capture the unique transmission characteristics of COVID-19, including asymptomatic carriers and the impact of control measures. The model provides predictions for epidemic containment and highlights the significant contribution of contact tracing to controlling the spread.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid global spread of COVID-19 necessitates accurate models for understanding and predicting its dynamics to inform effective control strategies. Existing deterministic models often struggle to account for the inherent randomness of disease transmission and specific features of COVID-19, such as a significant proportion of asymptomatic carriers and the latency involved in medical tracking and quarantine. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a stochastic model that incorporates these unique aspects, providing a more realistic representation of the epidemic's progression and the effectiveness of interventions.

Methods

The core of this paper is a novel stochastic compartmental model. Unlike traditional deterministic models (like SIR or SEIR), this model accounts for the probabilistic nature of disease transmission. Key features incorporated include:

  • Infectious Incubation Period: The model acknowledges that individuals can be infectious before showing symptoms.
  • Asymptomatic Carriers: A significant portion of infected individuals are asymptomatic, and the model quantifies their contribution to transmission.
  • Contact Tracing and Quarantine Latency: The model explicitly includes the time lag between identifying a contact and implementing quarantine or hospitalization, reflecting real-world medical tracking processes.

The model uses a continuous-time Markov process with states representing Susceptible (S), Exposed (E), Quarantined (Q), Symptomatic (IN), Hospitalized (IH), Recovered (R), and Dead (D) populations. Parameter estimation was performed using data from selected Chinese provinces and cities, with a focus on fitting observed confirmed cases and recoveries. For parameter estimation, a state-collapsed version of the model was used to simplify the process. Time-varying parameters were introduced to reflect the impact of evolving intervention measures.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available daily data on confirmed diagnoses, recoveries, and fatalities from the Health Commissions of Beijing, Shanghai, Chongqing, Guangdong, Zhejiang, and Hunan provinces/cities in China. Population data for these regions were sourced from the China National Bureau of Statistics. The authors explicitly excluded Hubei province due to its unique circumstances (overburdened medical resources, changing diagnostic criteria, and higher fatality rate) which they felt would require a distinct modeling approach.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Significant Asymptomatic Transmission: The model estimates that approximately 30% of infections are asymptomatic, a finding consistent with other studies but crucial for understanding the virus's stealthy spread.
  • Symptomatic vs. Asymptomatic Infectivity: Individuals with symptoms are estimated to be roughly twice as likely to transmit the virus as asymptomatic carriers. This highlights the importance of both symptom-based and asymptomatic case detection.
  • Effectiveness of Control Measures: The study demonstrates that transmission rates significantly decreased following the implementation of control measures in Mainland China.
  • Contact Tracing is Crucial: The model's analysis, particularly the hypothetical scenario where contact tracing probability (q) is set to zero, reveals that current medical tracking policies contribute significantly to epidemic containment by reducing the time to quarantine.
  • Early Containment Prediction: The model predicted that the epidemic would be contained by early March in the selected provinces and cities, a prediction that aligns reasonably well with observed trends.

Key Results

  • The model successfully predicted the observed accumulated confirmed cases within its confidence intervals for the studied regions.
  • Containment time predictions varied by region, with Shanghai predicted to be contained by February 28 and Guangdong around March 15.
  • The estimated reproduction number ($R_0$) dropped rapidly from around 2-3 before control measures to approximately 0.2 between late January and early February across all regions.
  • Simulations showed that relaxing containment measures after three weeks of containment could lead to a resurgence probability of 0.415 in Beijing.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Limitations: Parameter estimates, especially for states not directly observable, may be sensitive to data availability and quality.
  • Model Rigidity: The model assumes fixed control/treatment measures. Significant future changes could impact its predictive accuracy.
  • Asymptomatic Infectivity Post-Quarantine: The model assumes asymptomatic individuals are no longer infectious after quarantine, which might need refinement if prolonged infectiousness is discovered.
  • Simplification of Stochastic Model: The use of a state-collapsed model for parameter estimation might introduce inaccuracies if the full stochastic model differs significantly.

Future work proposed includes:

  • Improved Medical Tracking Dynamics: Developing an individual-based model that more realistically triggers quarantine based on contact history.
  • Incorporating Medical Service Capacity: Modeling the impact of healthcare system capacity, especially its potential overload during massive outbreaks, inspired by the situation in Wuhan.
  • Modeling Population Flows: Incorporating inter-city migration patterns and their influence on epidemic spread, particularly around holiday periods.

Summary updated

Abstract

The current outbreak of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has become a global crisis due to its quick and wide spread over the world. A good understanding of the dynamic of the disease would greatly enhance the control and prevention of COVID19. However, to the best of our knowledge, the unique features of the outbreak have limited the applications of all existing dynamic models. In this paper, a novel stochastic model was proposed aiming to account for the unique transmission dynamics of COVID-19 and capture the effects of intervention measures implemented in Mainland China. We found that: (1) instead of aberration, there was a remarkable amount of asymptomatic virus carriers, (2) a virus carrier with symptoms was approximately twice more likely to pass the disease to others than that of an asymptomatic virus carrier, (3) the transmission rate reduced significantly since the implementation of control measures in Mainland China, and (4) it was expected that the epidemic outbreak would be contained by early March in the selected provinces and cities in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2020prediction,
  author = {Yuan Zhang and Chong You and Zhenhao Cai and Jiarui Sun and Wenjie Hu and Xiao‐Hua Zhou},
  title = {{Prediction of the COVID-19 outbreak in China based on a new stochastic dynamic model}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-76630-0},
}
Figure