Prediction of Subsequent Contralateral Patellar Dislocation after First-Time Dislocation Based on Patellofemoral Morphologies

Jiaxing Chen, Qiaochu Li, Sizhu Liu, Lin Fan, Baoshan Yin, Xinyu Yang, Linbang Wang, Zijie Xu, Jian Zhang, Zhengxue Quan, Aiguo ZhouJournal of Clinical Medicine 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies specific anatomical features of the contralateral knee that predict a higher risk of subsequent patellar dislocation after an initial event. Key predictors include increased tibial tubercle-Roman arch distance and excessive valgus alignment, suggesting that pre-existing subtle abnormalities can predispose individuals to future dislocations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lateral patellar dislocation (LPD) is a common injury, particularly in young females. While many patients experience a single dislocation, a significant subset (around 5.4-5.8%) go on to dislocate the patella in the contralateral knee. The problem is that the anatomical risk factors predisposing individuals to this subsequent contralateral dislocation are not well understood. This lack of understanding hinders effective prevention strategies. This paper aims to identify specific morphological differences in the contralateral knee that are present even before a second dislocation occurs, thereby providing predictive markers.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective case-control study. They analyzed CT scans and weight-bearing radiographs of patients who had experienced a first-time lateral patellar dislocation. The study group consisted of 17 patients who later suffered a contralateral dislocation, matched with 34 control patients who did not experience a contralateral dislocation.

Key anatomical parameters of the contralateral patellofemoral joint were meticulously measured from these imaging studies. These included:

  • Trochlear Dysplasia: Assessed using the Dejour classification and measurements like lateral trochlea inclination (LTI) and trochlear depth.
  • Tibial Tubercle Lateralization: Measured by the novel tibial tubercle-Roman arch (TT-RA) distance.
  • Femoral Anteversion: Evaluated through segmental femoral torsion parameters.
  • Knee Joint Rotation and Tibial Torsion: Standardized measurements were used.
  • Patellar Height and HKA Angle: Assessed using the Insall-Salvati index and the hip-knee-ankle (HKA) angle for coronal alignment.
  • Patellar Position: Measured by patellar tilt, congruence angle, and patellar displacement.

Statistical analysis involved the Wilcoxon rank-sum test to compare parameters between groups and binary logistic regression to identify risk factors. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and area under the curve (AUC) were used to evaluate the diagnostic ability of these parameters.

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective data from 185 patients admitted to the First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University between January 2015 and December 2020. The final dataset comprised 17 patients in the study group (contralateral LPD) and 34 in the control group (no contralateral LPD). No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Contralateral Knee Matters: Even in asymptomatic knees, subtle anatomical differences can significantly increase the risk of future patellar dislocations. This shifts the focus from just the injured knee to a more holistic assessment.
  • Tibial Tubercle-Roman Arch (TT-RA) as a Novel Predictor: The TT-RA distance, a measurement of tibial tubercle alignment relative to the femoral trochlear groove, emerged as a significant predictor. This suggests that the outward positioning of the tibial tubercle is a key factor in patellar instability.
  • Valgus Alignment is Crucial: The hip-knee-ankle (HKA) angle, a measure of overall leg alignment, proved to be a strong indicator. Increased valgus (knock-kneed appearance) in the contralateral limb predisposes to contralateral LPD.
  • Patellar Position is Key: Beyond gross structural issues, the precise positioning of the patella within the trochlea (patellar tilt, congruence angle, and displacement) at the time of the first dislocation is also predictive. This highlights the importance of how the patella tracks even before a major event.

Key Results

  • Significant Anatomical Differences: Patients with subsequent contralateral LPD showed significantly different contralateral patellofemoral anatomy compared to controls.
  • Increased TT-RA Distance: The study group had a significantly larger TT-RA distance (24.1 mm vs. 19.5 mm, p < 0.001). This parameter had an Odds Ratio (OR) of 1.35 and an AUC of 0.727 for predicting contralateral LPD.
  • Increased Valgus Deformity: The HKA angle was significantly greater in the study group (1.9° vs. 0.8°, p < 0.001). The HKA angle had an OR of 1.74 and an AUC of 0.797.
  • Patellar Position Predictors: Patellar tilt, congruence angle, and patellar displacement also showed significant predictive power with AUCs of 0.703, 0.725, and 0.817, respectively. Patellar displacement had the highest AUC.
  • Trochlear Dysplasia: While severe trochlear dysplasia was more prevalent in the study group (94.1% vs. 88.2%), its predictive value (AUC < 0.7) was limited.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Anatomical Focus: The study only considered anatomical parameters, neglecting clinical factors like injury mechanism, exercise intensity, and ligamentous laxity.
  • Small Sample Size: The study group was small (n=17) due to the relatively low incidence of contralateral LPD, which may limit generalizability.
  • Potential Bias: Patients in the control group might still develop contralateral LPD in the future.
  • Skeletal Maturity: Patients with skeletal maturity and immaturity were not fully separated, and age/gender at first dislocation were not analyzed for their impact on contralateral LPD.
  • Ipsilateral vs. Contralateral Comparison: The anatomical parameters of the ipsilateral patellofemoral joints at the time of the first dislocation were not compared between the two groups.
  • Timing of Dislocation: The study did not investigate whether abnormal anatomical parameters influence the time to suffering subsequent contralateral LPD.

Future work could involve larger, prospective studies incorporating clinical data, exploring the influence of skeletal maturity, and comparing ipsilateral and contralateral findings more directly. Further investigation into how these anatomical parameters influence the timing of subsequent dislocations is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

The subsequent dislocation of a contralateral patellofemoral joint sometimes occurs after a first-time lateral patellar dislocation (LPD). However, the anatomic risk factors for subsequent contralateral LPD remain elusive. This study included 17 patients with contralateral LPD and 34 unilateral patellar dislocators. The anatomic parameters of the contralateral patellofemoral joints were measured using CT images and radiographs that were obtained at the time of the first dislocation. The Wilcoxon rank-sum test was performed, and a binary regression model was established to identify the risk factors. The receiver operating characteristic curves and the area under the curve (AUC) were analyzed. The tibial tubercle-Roman arch (TT-RA) distance was significantly different between patients with and without contralateral LPD (24.1 vs. 19.5 mm, p < 0.001). The hip−knee−ankle (HKA) angle, patellar tilt, congruence angle, and patellar displacement were greater in the study group than in the control group (p < 0.05). The TT-RA distance revealed an OR of 1.35 (95% CI (1.26−1.44]), p < 0.001) and an AUC of 0.727 for predicting contralateral LPD. The HKA angle revealed an OR of 1.74 (95% CI (1.51−2.00), p < 0.001) and an AUC of 0.797. The Patellar tilt, congruence angle, and patellar displacement had AUC values of 0.703, 0.725, and 0.817 for predicting contralateral LPD, respectively. In conclusion, the contralateral patellofemoral anatomic parameters were significantly different between patients with and without subsequent contralateral LPD. Increased TT-RA distance and excessive valgus deformity were risk factors and could serve as predictors for contralateral LPD. At first-time dislocation, the abnormal position of the patella relative to the trochlea may also be an important cause of subsequent LPD.
BibTeX
@article{chen2022prediction,
  author = {Jiaxing Chen and Qiaochu Li and Sizhu Liu and Lin Fan and Baoshan Yin and Xinyu Yang and Linbang Wang and Zijie Xu and Jian Zhang and Zhengxue Quan and Aiguo Zhou},
  title = {{Prediction of Subsequent Contralateral Patellar Dislocation after First-Time Dislocation Based on Patellofemoral Morphologies}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm12010180},
}
Figure