Abstract
Perceptual decision making is an active process where animals move their sense organs to extract task-relevant information. To investigate how the brain translates sensory input into decisions during active sensation, we developed a mouse active touch task where mechanosensory input can be precisely measured and that challenges animals to use multiple mechanosensory cues. Mice were trained to localize a pole using a single whisker and to report their decision by selecting one of three choices. Using high-speed imaging and machine vision, we estimated whisker-object mechanical forces at millisecond resolution. Mice solved the task by a sensory-motor strategy where both the strength and direction of whisker bending were informative cues to pole location. We found competing influences of immediate sensory input and choice memory on mouse choice. On correct trials, choice could be predicted from the direction and strength of whisker bending, but not from previous choice. In contrast, on error trials, choice could be predicted from previous choice but not from whisker bending. This study shows that animal choices during active tactile decision making can be predicted from mechanosensory and choice-memory signals, providing a new task well-suited for future study of the neural basis of active perceptual decisions.
Introduction: The Challenge of Active Sensation
Perceptual decision-making is rarely a passive experience. In the natural world, animals actively manipulate their environment and move their sense organs—such as eyes, fingers, or whiskers—to gather information. This active process is fundamental to how organisms interact with their surroundings, yet it presents a significant technical challenge for researchers: measuring the exact sensory input an animal receives while it is in motion is notoriously difficult.
Previous research into tactile perception often utilized simplified "two-choice" tasks (e.g., determining if an object is in a "front" or "back" position). In these paradigms, animals could often succeed using relatively simple strategies, such as counting the number of times a whisker contacted an object. To better understand the complexity of active sensation, this study introduces a more demanding behavioral model that requires mice to utilize "rich" mechanosensory cues—specifically the direction and force of touch—and examines how these signals compete with internal biases like choice memory.
Methodology: A Three-Choice Paradigm
To probe these dynamics, researchers developed a novel three-choice object localization task for head-fixed mice.
The Task
A vertical pole was presented in one of three possible positions: posterior, middle, or anterior. Mice were required to report the location by licking a right port for the posterior position, a left port for the middle position, or by refraining from licking (a "no-go" response) for the anterior position. To ensure precise measurement of the sensory input, the mice’s whiskers were trimmed until only a single whisker (C1 or C2) remained.
High-Speed Quantification
The researchers employed high-speed video (1,000 frames per second) and machine vision to track whisker kinematics and mechanics. The primary metric of interest was the bending moment—the torque at the base of the whisker. This is considered the fundamental signal transmitted from the whisker follicle to the brain. By analyzing approximately 300 million video frames across five male C57 mice, the team was able to reconstruct the mechanical experience of each touch with millisecond resolution.
Predictive Modeling
To determine what drove the mice's decisions, the team used Maximum a Posteriori (MAP) probabilistic classifiers. These models were designed to predict the mouse's choice based on two distinct data sources: the physical sensory data (whisker bending) and the mouse's behavioral history (the choice made in the previous trial).
Key Insights: The Double Dissociation of Choice
The study revealed that mice did not rely on a simple "touch vs. no-touch" binary. Instead, they adopted a stereotyped whisking strategy where the direction of bending—whether the whisker bent forward during protraction or backward during retraction—served as a critical cue to distinguish between the posterior and middle locations.
Most significantly, the researchers discovered a "double dissociation" between sensory input and internal memory:
- Sensory-Driven Decisions: On correct trials, the mouse's choice was highly predictable based on the physical whisker-bending data. The classifier, using both the direction and magnitude of bending ($\Delta\kappa_{95}$), predicted pole location with 72% accuracy, nearly matching the mice's actual performance of 74%.
- Memory-Driven Errors: On error trials, the physical sensory data failed to predict the mouse's choice. Instead, the choice was predicted by perseveration—the tendency to repeat the choice that resulted in a reward in the previous trial. On these trials, the probability of the mouse repeating its previous choice was 0.63, while consistency with sensory input dropped to 0.35.
Discussion and Future Directions
These findings suggest that the brain constantly balances immediate evidence from the external world against internal expectations derived from history. When sensory signals are perhaps weak, ambiguous, or ignored, the "choice-memory" system appears to take over, leading to predictable errors.
While this study provides a rigorous mapping of behavior to mechanical input, it opens the door for future neural investigations. The authors hypothesize that the sensory-guided system likely involves the primary somatosensory cortex (S1), whereas the choice-memory system may be mediated by regions like the posterior parietal cortex (PPC). Future research combining this three-choice task with optogenetics or cellular-resolution imaging will be essential to observe these two systems competing in real-time within the brain.
Summary updated