Predicting the vulnerability of birds to trophic threat posed by phenological mismatch based on nutritional and physiological status of nestlings

Shuping Zhang, Lidan Zhao, Xinjie Zhang, Wei LiangConservation 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Climate change is causing a mismatch between when birds' young hatch and when their food is most abundant, threatening their survival. This study introduces a novel method to predict which bird species are most vulnerable by analyzing nestlings' blood nutrient levels and physiological status, not just their diets. The findings reveal that alternative food sources often fail to provide adequate nutrition, leading to reduced growth and survival, highlighting the need for a more holistic approach to assessing vulnerability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many bird species rely on a narrow window of peak insect abundance to feed their nestlings. Climate change is disrupting this synchrony, leading to "phenological mismatches" where nestlings hatch when food is scarce. While observing what birds eat is a starting point, it's insufficient to determine if alternative food sources are nutritionally adequate. This leaves a critical gap in our ability to predict which species are truly vulnerable to extinction due to these mismatches. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a more reliable method to assess vulnerability, focusing on the internal physiological state of the nestlings rather than just external dietary observations.

Methods

The researchers focused on the Asian short-toed lark, a species with a well-defined optimal food source: grasshopper nymphs. They collected data over two breeding seasons, categorizing nestlings into three groups based on the abundance of grasshopper nymphs available during their critical early development period: high (NBP > 5%), medium (2% < NBP ≤ 5%), and low (NBP ≤ 2%).

The core of their approach involved:

  • Dietary Analysis: Using neck-collars on 4-day-old nestlings to collect and quantify food items.
  • Metabolomic Profiling: Analyzing plasma metabolites using Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS) to get a detailed picture of the nutrients absorbed by the nestlings. This is a powerful technique for comprehensive blood nutrient analysis.
  • Hormone Analysis: Measuring plasma Insulin-like Growth Factor-1 (IGF-1) levels, a key indicator of growth and nutrient utilization.
  • Physiological Measurements: Recording nestling body mass and survival rates.

They then used statistical methods, including Partial Least-Squares Discriminant Analysis (PLS-DA) and ANOVA, to compare these indicators across the different NBP groups and identify significant differences.

Datasets

The study utilized field data collected from the Hulun Lake National Nature Reserve in Inner Mongolia, China, over two breeding seasons (2016 and 2017). The primary "dataset" consists of:

  • Nestling Data: Information from 84 nestlings in 2016 and 72 in 2017, including hatching dates, diet composition, body mass, plasma metabolite levels, plasma IGF-1 concentrations, and survival rates.
  • Environmental Data: Daily measurements of grasshopper nymph biomass collected from sampling transects.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing ecological and biochemical measurement techniques were applied to a specific research question.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Diet Observation: The most significant insight is that simply observing what alternative foods birds feed their young is insufficient. The nutritional quality of these alternatives, as reflected in the nestlings' internal physiology, is the crucial factor.
  • The "Nutritional Deficit" of Alternatives: The study strongly suggests that when grasshopper nymphs are scarce, the alternative foods (beetles and grass seeds) do not provide the same level of essential nutrients, particularly amino acids, glucides, and TCA cycle metabolites.
  • IGF-1 as a Biomarker: Plasma IGF-1 levels serve as a reliable indicator of how well nestlings are utilizing nutrients. Lower IGF-1 levels in nestlings fed alternative diets directly correlate with reduced body mass and survival.
  • Vulnerability is Multifaceted: The research highlights that vulnerability to phenological mismatch is not just about diet composition but also about the physiological capacity of the nestlings to absorb and utilize nutrients from those diets.

Key Results

  • Nestlings hatched during periods of low grasshopper nymph abundance (low NBP) had significantly lower levels of plasma glucides, amino acids, TCA cycle metabolites, and certain fatty acids compared to those hatched during high nymph abundance.
  • Plasma IGF-1 levels and nestling body mass were significantly lower in the low and medium NBP groups compared to the high NBP group.
  • Plasma IGF-1 levels were positively correlated with nestling body mass, and both were positively correlated with the abundance of essential plasma metabolites.
  • Nestling survival rates were notably lower in the low NBP group (66.7% in 2016, 75% in 2017) compared to the high NBP group (92.0% in 2016, 96.6% in 2017).
  • The study found that while birds attempt to compensate for low nymph availability by offering alternative foods, these alternatives are nutritionally inferior, leading to inhibited growth and reduced survival.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Species Specificity: The study focused on the Asian short-toed lark. While the methodology is proposed as a generalizable approach, its direct applicability to other species with different diets and physiological responses needs further investigation.
  • Environmental Variability: The study was conducted in a specific region over two years. Long-term studies across diverse environmental conditions would strengthen the conclusions.
  • Predation Exclusion: The study excluded nestlings lost to predation from the survival rate calculations, which is a standard practice but means the reported survival rates reflect only those lost due to non-predatory factors (likely related to nutrition).

The authors suggest that predicting species vulnerability to phenological mismatches requires a comprehensive assessment of nestling nutritional status and body condition, not just diet observation. Future work could involve applying this integrated approach to a wider range of bird species to build a more robust understanding of climate change impacts on avian populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Climate change induced phenological mismatches between nestlings and their optimal food resources have been found to negatively influence the survival of many bird species. Discriminating which species is vulnerable to such threat is difficult only based on the diet observation, and therefore it is necessary to establish a more reliable method to predict the vulnerability of bird species. In the case of Asian short-toed lark (<i>Calandrella cheleensis</i>), we predicted such vulnerability by evaluating whether nestlings can absorb equal level of nutrients from different diets and maintain equal physiological status. We compared the diet, plasma nutrients, plasma insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1), body mass and survival rate of nestlings hatched under different optimal food (grasshopper nymph) abundance conditions in two breeding seasons. Plasma glucides, amino acids, tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle metabolites, some fatty acids, IGF-1, body mass and survival rate of the nestlings hatched under medium or low nymph abundance conditions were significantly lower than those of nestlings hatched under high nymph abundance condition. The relative abundance of plasma amino acids, glucides, TCA cycle metabolites and fatty acids were significantly, and positively, correlated with IGF-1 levels, which, in turn, was positively correlated with nestling body mass. These results indicate that the diet with low optimal food proportion was nutritionally inferior to the diet with high optimal food proportion and inhibited the growth of nestlings. Species like Asian short-toed lark is vulnerable to the trophic threat induced by phenological mismatch because the alternative food is insufficient to satisfy the nutritional requirement of nestlings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019predicting,
  author = {Shuping Zhang and Lidan Zhao and Xinjie Zhang and Wei Liang},
  title = {{Predicting the vulnerability of birds to trophic threat posed by phenological mismatch based on nutritional and physiological status of nestlings}},
  booktitle = {Conservation},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1093/conphys/coz096},
}
Figure