Predicting protein ligand binding motions with the Conformation Explorer

Samuel Flores, Mark B. GersteinBMC Bioinformatics 2011 · DOI · OpenReview

Introduction

Proteins are dynamic molecular machines that frequently undergo large-scale structural changes to facilitate biological functions, such as "embracing" a ligand during binding. One of the most prevalent types of motion is domain hinge bending, where two rigid sections of a protein move relative to each other, much like a closing book.

Accurately predicting these motions is a significant challenge in computational biology. Standard Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations often struggle to observe these transitions within reasonable timeframes, as they can become trapped in local energy minima. Conversely, traditional docking algorithms often treat proteins as rigid structures, failing when significant conformational changes are required for binding. The Conformation Explorer (CE) framework was developed to bridge this gap, offering a physically realistic yet computationally efficient method for predicting bound (holo) structures from their unbound (apo) starting points.

The Conformation Explorer Framework

The CE framework utilizes an iterative four-step cycle to navigate a protein's conformational space and identify the most likely bound state:

  1. Hinge Prediction: The process begins by identifying the "hinge" residues that connect the protein's domains. This is achieved using specialized tools like HingeMaster or FlexOracle.
  2. Euler Rotation: Once the hinge is identified, the system applies trial rotations (pitch, yaw, and roll) to one domain relative to the other about the hinge point, generating a new candidate structure.
  3. Equilibration: To ensure physical realism, a very short (6 ps) MD simulation is performed using GROMACS. This step is not intended to simulate the entire motion but rather to "relax" the structure, resolving any unphysical atomic overlaps or bond length distortions introduced by the rotation.
  4. Scoring: Each candidate structure is evaluated using a multi-component fitness function.
Assignment of residues to S, L, and M. The hinge residues are highlighted in red on the left.

Scoring and Fitness Function

The success of the Conformation Explorer relies on a weighted fitness function ($f$) that balances three critical metrics:

  • Docked Energy ($G_D$): Calculated via AutoDock, this measures how well the ligand fits into the newly formed pocket.
  • Stability/Folding Energy ($E_F$): Calculated via FoldX, this ensures the protein's new conformation remains energetically favorable and physically feasible.
  • Radius of Gyration ($R_G$): This metric favors more compact structures, effectively driving the protein toward a "closed" state.

By minimizing this function through a line-search algorithm, the CE framework evolves the apo structure toward the predicted holo state.

Key Results and Validation

The method was validated using five proteins known for significant hinge-bending motions: GlnBP, Biotin Carboxylase (BC), Ribose Binding Protein (RBP), Adenylate Kinase (ADK), and MurA. The results demonstrated significant improvements in structural accuracy:

  • Adenylate Kinase (ADK): The initial apo structure had a distance (sRMSD) of 17.0 Å from the target holo state. CE reduced this to 5.3 Å.
  • Ribose Binding Protein (RBP): The sRMSD improved from 12.1 Å to 7.0 Å (and reached as low as 3.5 Å when using specialized "proxy" ligands).

In four out of the five test cases, the algorithm successfully closed the protein pocket to a state that closely resembled the experimentally determined holo structure.

Discussion and Insights

A notable discovery during development was the "Proxy Ligand" Strategy. For small, highly polar ligands, standard docking scores often fail to account for the energy cost of desolvation. The authors found that using a larger, more complex molecule like ATP as a proxy—even if it was not the natural binder—often provided a better energy signal to drive the protein into the correct closed conformation.

Furthermore, the multi-term fitness function proved essential. While $R_G$ drives compactness, the FoldX stability term ($E_F$) acts as a vital "sanity check," preventing the algorithm from selecting impossible structures where domains overlap.

Conclusion and Future Work

The Conformation Explorer offers a significant efficiency advantage, running in just 6 to 12 hours on a single processor, compared to the weeks of cluster time required for traditional MD. While currently limited to single protein chains and dependent on accurate initial hinge predictions, the framework represents a powerful new tool for high-throughput structural biology and drug design.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background Knowledge of the structure of proteins bound to known or potential ligands is crucial for biological understanding and drug design. Often the 3D structure of the protein is available in some conformation, but binding the ligand of interest may involve a large scale conformational change which is difficult to predict with existing methods. Results We describe how to generate ligand binding conformations of proteins that move by hinge bending, the largest class of motions. First, we predict the location of the hinge between domains. Second, we apply an Euler rotation to one of the domains about the hinge point. Third, we compute a short-time dynamical trajectory using Molecular Dynamics to equilibrate the protein and ligand and correct unnatural atomic positions. Fourth, we score the generated structures using a novel fitness function which favors closed or holo structures. By iterating the second through fourth steps we systematically minimize the fitness function, thus predicting the conformational change required for small ligand binding for five well studied proteins. Conclusions We demonstrate that the method in most cases successfully predicts the holo conformation given only an apo structure.
BibTeX
@article{flores2011predicting,
  author = {Samuel Flores and Mark B. Gerstein},
  title = {{Predicting protein ligand binding motions with the Conformation Explorer}},
  journal = {BMC Bioinformatics},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1186/1471-2105-12-417},
}
Figure