Predicting Brain Amyloid Using Multivariate Morphometry Statistics, Sparse Coding, and Correntropy: Validation in 1,101 Individuals From the ADNI and OASIS Databases

Jianfeng Wu, Qunxi Dong, Jie Gui, Jie Zhang, Yi Su, Kewei Chen, Paul M. Thompson, Richard J. Caselli, Eric M. Reiman, Jieping Ye, Yalin WangFrontiers in Neuroscience 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel machine learning framework, PASCS-MP, that uses MRI-based hippocampal shape features to predict amyloid-beta (Aβ) plaque accumulation in the brain. This method achieves high accuracy in identifying individuals with preclinical Alzheimer's disease, offering a less invasive and more accessible alternative to current PET or CSF-based diagnostics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a growing public health crisis, and early detection is crucial for effective intervention. A key early sign of AD is the buildup of amyloid-beta (Aβ) plaques in the brain. However, current methods for detecting Aβ pathology, such as PET scans or cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) analysis, are either invasive, costly, or not widely available. This creates a need for more accessible and less burdensome methods to identify individuals at risk, particularly in the preclinical stages when interventions are most likely to be effective. The paper aims to leverage structural MRI, a widely available and cost-effective imaging modality, to predict Aβ burden at an individual level.

Methods

The core of the proposed method lies in a novel sparse coding algorithm called Patch Analysis-based Surface Correntropy-induced Sparse-coding and Max-Pooling (PASCS-MP). Here's a breakdown:

  1. Multivariate Morphometry Statistics (MMS): The researchers first extract detailed shape information from the hippocampus using MMS. This goes beyond simple volume or surface area measurements by capturing local shape variations along the surface (radial distance) and within the surface (tensor-based morphometry). This results in a high-dimensional feature set for each hippocampus.
  2. Sparse Coding (PASCS-MP): To handle the high dimensionality of MMS and the "high-dimensional, small sample size" problem, PASCS-MP is introduced.
  3. Patch Extraction: The hippocampal surface is divided into small, overlapping patches.
  4. Sparse Coding: A novel sparse coding approach is used to learn a low-dimensional representation (sparse codes) for each patch. This method incorporates a correntropy loss function, which is more robust to non-Gaussian noise often present in imaging data, leading to improved prediction accuracy compared to previous methods.
  5. Max-Pooling: After obtaining sparse codes for all patches of a subject's hippocampus, a max-pooling operation is applied. This aggregates the information from the patches into a single, lower-dimensional vector representation for each individual.
  6. Classification: A binary random forest classifier is then trained on these low-dimensional representations to predict Aβ positivity (i.e., whether an individual has significant Aβ accumulation).

Datasets

The study utilizes two well-established, publicly available neuroimaging datasets:

  • Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI): This dataset provided 841 subjects for the primary analysis.
  • Open Access Series of Imaging Studies (OASIS): This dataset served as an independent cohort for external validation, including 260 subjects.

Both datasets contain T1-weighted MRI scans and florbetapir PET data (used to determine Aβ positivity via centiloid measures).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hippocampal Shape as a Biomarker: The study strongly suggests that detailed hippocampal shape features (MMS) are more informative for predicting Aβ burden than traditional measures like overall volume or surface area. This highlights the importance of capturing subtle, localized geometric changes.
  • Correntropy for Robustness: The incorporation of correntropy into the sparse coding loss function is a key innovation. It makes the method more resilient to noise in the MRI data, which is a common challenge in neuroimaging, leading to more reliable predictions.
  • PASCS-MP Outperforms Previous Methods: The proposed PASCS-MP algorithm demonstrates superior performance compared to the authors' prior sparse coding method (PASS-MP), indicating the benefit of the correntropy-based approach.
  • Potential for Preclinical Detection: The ability to predict Aβ positivity in both cognitively unimpaired (CU) individuals and those with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is crucial. This suggests the method can identify individuals in the very early stages of AD pathology, before significant cognitive decline.

Key Results

The PASCS-MP method, when applied to hippocampal MMS, achieved impressive classification accuracies:

  • Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) Cohort (ADNI): Accuracy (ACC) of 0.89.
  • Cognitively Unimpaired (CU) Cohort (ADNI): Accuracy (ACC) of 0.79.
  • Cognitively Unimpaired (CU) Cohort (OASIS - external validation): Accuracy (ACC) of 0.81.

These results were consistently better than those obtained using traditional methods like hippocampal volume, surface area, and spherical harmonics (SPHARM), as well as the authors' previous PASS-MP method. Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves also showed superior performance for PASCS-MP across all tested contrasts.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Interpretability of Sparse Codes: While PASCS-MP effectively reduces dimensionality, visualizing the specific features learned by the sparse coding can be challenging. Future work aims to improve interpretability by incorporating feature selection methods to identify and visualize the most significant hippocampal regions contributing to the classification.
  • Expanding to Other AD Regions and Risk Factors: This study focused solely on hippocampal MMS. The authors plan to integrate additional AD risk factors (e.g., demographic, genetic, clinical data) and explore other brain regions of interest (ROIs) to further enhance prediction accuracy.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The study notes that the accuracy can be sensitive to parameter choices in sparse coding (e.g., patch size, dimensionality, regularization parameter). While grid search was used, further research is warranted to better understand and optimize these relationships, especially given the observed erratic effects of some parameters.

Summary updated

Abstract

Biomarker assisted preclinical/early detection and intervention in Alzheimer's disease (AD) may be the key to therapeutic breakthroughs. One of the presymptomatic hallmarks of AD is the accumulation of beta-amyloid (Aβ) plaques in the human brain. However, current methods to detect Aβ pathology are either invasive (lumbar puncture) or quite costly and not widely available (amyloid PET). Our prior studies show that magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-based hippocampal multivariate morphometry statistics (MMS) are an effective neurodegenerative biomarker for preclinical AD. Here we attempt to use MRI-MMS to make inferences regarding brain Aβ burden at the individual subject level. As MMS data has a larger dimension than the sample size, we propose a sparse coding algorithm, Patch Analysis-based Surface Correntropy-induced Sparse-coding and Max-Pooling (PASCS-MP), to generate a low-dimensional representation of hippocampal morphometry for each individual subject. Then we apply these individual representations and a binary random forest classifier to predict brain Aβ positivity for each person. We test our method in two independent cohorts, 841 subjects from the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) and 260 subjects from the Open Access Series of Imaging Studies (OASIS). Experimental results suggest that our proposed PASCS-MP method and MMS can discriminate Aβ positivity in people with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) [Accuracy (ACC) = 0.89 (ADNI)] and in cognitively unimpaired (CU) individuals [ACC = 0.79 (ADNI) and ACC = 0.81 (OASIS)]. These results compare favorably relative to measures derived from traditional algorithms, including hippocampal volume and surface area, shape measures based on spherical harmonics (SPHARM) and our prior Patch Analysis-based Surface Sparse-coding and Max-Pooling (PASS-MP) methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2021predicting,
  author = {Jianfeng Wu and Qunxi Dong and Jie Gui and Jie Zhang and Yi Su and Kewei Chen and Paul M. Thompson and Richard J. Caselli and Eric M. Reiman and Jieping Ye and Yalin Wang},
  title = {{Predicting Brain Amyloid Using Multivariate Morphometry Statistics, Sparse Coding, and Correntropy: Validation in 1,101 Individuals From the ADNI and OASIS Databases}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2021.669595},
}
Figure