Predicting Adversarial Examples with High Confidence

Angus Galloway, Graham W. Taylor, Medhat MoussaarXiv 2018 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper challenges the conventional wisdom that adversarial examples are a consequence of models being overly confident in their incorrect predictions. Instead, the authors propose that overly confident models are actually more vulnerable to adversarial attacks. They demonstrate that by reducing model capacity and employing strong regularization, particularly through low-precision representations, models can become more robust without relying on data augmentation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep learning models, particularly in image classification, have achieved remarkable accuracy on standard benchmarks. However, they are notoriously susceptible to adversarial examples – subtly perturbed inputs that cause misclassification, often with high confidence. The prevailing hypothesis has been that these adversarial examples exploit "low-probability pockets" in the data manifold, and that models become vulnerable when they are overly confident in these incorrect predictions. This paper questions this assumption, suggesting that the problem might be rooted in how models generalize and the inherent limitations of current datasets and training paradigms. The authors aim to find a more proactive and robust defense against adversarial attacks, moving beyond data augmentation.

Methods

The core of the paper's approach lies in exploring the relationship between model capacity, regularization, and robustness. Key methods include:

  • Challenging the Confidence Hypothesis: The authors directly counter the idea that high confidence in incorrect predictions is the primary driver of adversarial vulnerability. They propose that high confidence in correct predictions might be a better indicator of robustness.
  • Low-Precision Representations: A significant focus is placed on using low-precision (e.g., 1-bit, 2-bit, 8-bit) weights and activations. This is presented as a form of strong regularization that inherently limits model capacity and can confer robustness.
  • Weight Decay: The paper extensively uses L2 weight decay as a regularization technique, demonstrating its effectiveness, especially when combined with low-precision representations.
  • Data Augmentation-Free Defense: A key contribution is showing that robustness can be achieved without relying on adversarial training or other data augmentation techniques, which they argue have limitations.
  • Gradient Ascent Attacks: To evaluate robustness, the authors employ gradient ascent attacks, including a "Constant Pixel Intensity Attack" and a "Non-Example Gradient Ascent Attack," to probe model behavior in unexplored regions of the representation space.

Datasets

The paper uses the following datasets:

  • MNIST: For binary classification (threes vs. sevens) and generating MNIST examples.
  • CIFAR-10: For image classification and generating CIFAR-10 examples.
  • Synthetic Spheres Dataset: A simplified, synthetic dataset from Gilmer et al. (2018) used to gain intuition about decision boundaries and sparsity.
  • ImageNet: Used for evaluating ResNet-18 models under various precision settings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Overconfidence is a Symptom, Not the Cause: The paper argues that high confidence in incorrect predictions is a result of a poorly regularized or overly capacious model, rather than the root cause of adversarial vulnerability.
  • Simplicity and Regularization Lead to Robustness: Models with reduced capacity, achieved through low-precision representations and strong weight decay, are shown to be more robust. This suggests that simpler models are less prone to memorizing spurious correlations or exploiting "blind spots."
  • Data Augmentation is Not a Silver Bullet: The authors critique data augmentation-based defenses, arguing they can be brittle and vulnerable to slightly stronger attacks than those used during training.
  • Unexplored Space Matters: The paper emphasizes that adversarial examples often reside in regions of the representation space that are not well-represented by the training data. Reducing this unexplored space through regularization is key.
  • Low-Precision Models Mimic "Good" Hypotheses: In toy experiments, low-precision models on the Spheres dataset were observed to maintain simpler, more "sphere-like" decision boundaries when faced with sparse data, aligning with Occam's razor.

Key Results

  • Improved Robustness with Low Precision: Experiments on MNIST and CIFAR-10 show that models using low-precision weights and activations (e.g., 1-bit, 8-bit) achieve significantly better robustness against adversarial attacks compared to their full-precision counterparts, often outperforming models trained with adversarial data augmentation.
  • Weight Decay Effectiveness: Strong L2 weight decay, especially when combined with low-precision representations, proved to be a powerful regularization technique for enhancing robustness.
  • ImageNet Performance: For ImageNet, ResNet-18 models with reduced precision (e.g., 2-bit, 3-bit weights) showed improved robustness against FGSM attacks, with some configurations achieving competitive or better performance than full-precision models, despite lower clean accuracy.
  • Generated Natural-Looking Adversarial Examples: The paper demonstrates that by using gradient ascent on noise, they can generate plausible, natural-looking adversarial examples for MNIST and CIFAR-10, classified with lower confidence than previous "fooling images."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Threat Models: The paper acknowledges that their robustness claims are based on specific threat models (e.g., L∞ norm, FGSM, PGD). They note that different attack types might reveal different vulnerabilities.
  • Trade-off Between Accuracy and Robustness: While robustness is improved, there is often a trade-off with clean test accuracy, especially in higher-dimensional datasets like ImageNet. The authors suggest that finding the right balance is crucial.
  • Future Work: The authors advocate for a "start small" approach to model design, progressively adding capacity only after demonstrating meaningful features and robustness. They suggest further research into how to iteratively build capacity while maintaining robustness, and exploring the fundamental geometry of decision boundaries. They also highlight the need for better understanding of model confidence and uncertainty estimation.

Summary updated

Abstract

It has been suggested that adversarial examples cause deep learning models to make incorrect predictions with high confidence. In this work, we take the opposite stance: an overly confident model is more likely to be vulnerable to adversarial examples. This work is one of the most proactive approaches taken to date, as we link robustness with non-calibrated model confidence on noisy images, providing a data-augmentation-free path forward. The adversarial examples phenomenon is most easily explained by the trend of increasing non-regularized model capacity, while the diversity and number of samples in common datasets has remained flat. Test accuracy has incorrectly been associated with true generalization performance, ignoring that training and test splits are often extremely similar in terms of the overall representation space. The transferability property of adversarial examples was previously used as evidence against overfitting arguments, a perceived random effect, but overfitting is not always random.
BibTeX
@misc{galloway2018predicting,
  author = {Angus Galloway and Graham W. Taylor and Medhat Moussa},
  title = {{Predicting Adversarial Examples with High Confidence}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1802.04457},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.04457},
}
Figure