Predicting accuracy of extracting information from unstructured text collections

Eugene Agichtein, Silviu CucerzanCIKM 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for predicting how accurately information extraction (IE) tasks like Named Entity Recognition (NER) and Relation Extraction (RE) will perform on a given text collection. By building context-specific language models and comparing them to a general background model, they can quantify extraction difficulty, enabling more efficient deployment and tuning of IE systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Unstructured text collections, like the vast amount of information on the internet, are incredibly valuable but difficult to access beyond simple keyword searches. Extracting structured information, such as identifying people, organizations, or relationships between them, is crucial for advanced applications like question answering and knowledge management. However, the success of these extraction tasks varies greatly depending on the specific text collection, domain, and language. Manually tuning or porting IE systems to new collections is time-consuming and computationally expensive. Therefore, predicting the difficulty of an extraction task before investing significant resources is a critical challenge for scalable information management.

Methods

The core of this paper's approach lies in using language modeling to quantify extraction difficulty. They propose building two types of unigram language models:

  • Task-Specific Context Language Model (LMc): This model is built by analyzing the words that appear in the local context (a window of K words) surrounding known entities or relation tuples within the target collection.
  • Background Language Model (LMBG): This model represents the general language of the entire document collection.

The key idea is that if the context surrounding the entities/relations of interest (LMc) is very similar to the general language of the collection (LMBG), then the extraction task is likely to be difficult because there are no strong "clues" in the text to help identify them. Conversely, if LMc is significantly different from LMBG, it suggests that the contexts provide useful signals, making the task easier.

They quantify this difference using Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence or cosine distance, with higher divergence indicating an easier task. To make their predictions robust, they also introduce a reference context language model (LMR) built from random word samples, which helps normalize the divergence measures against variations in sample size and collection size.

For practical application, they show that a small sample (10-40) of known entities or relation tuples is sufficient to build a representative LMc, making the prediction approach scalable.

Datasets

The paper evaluates their method on several real-world datasets:

  • Reuters RCV1: Used for Named Entity Recognition (NER) experiments, with subsets of varying sizes (3.5 million and 35 million words).
  • EFE newswire articles (Spanish): Used for NER evaluation in a non-English language.
  • De Morgen newspaper articles (Dutch): Also used for NER evaluation in another non-English language.
  • Encarta encyclopedia documents: Used for Relation Extraction (RE) experiments.

These datasets are standard benchmarks in the field, and the paper leverages existing shared task evaluations (like CoNLL) for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Context is King (for Prediction): The paper strongly emphasizes that the local textual context surrounding entities and relations is the primary indicator of extraction difficulty.
  • Language Models as Difficulty Predictors: Using language models to capture this contextual information and comparing it to a general collection model is an effective way to predict extraction performance.
  • Small Samples Suffice: A surprisingly small number of example entities or relations (as few as 10-20) can yield accurate predictions, making the approach practical for large collections.
  • Language and Domain Independence: The core methodology is general and language-independent, as demonstrated by successful application to English, Spanish, and Dutch.
  • Stopwords Matter (but not critically): While including or excluding stopwords can affect the absolute divergence values, the relative ranking of difficulty for different entity types or relations remains consistent.
  • N-gram Size is Less Critical: For predicting difficulty, simple unigram language models appear to be as effective as bigram or trigram models, simplifying the process.

Key Results

  • NER Prediction: The model successfully predicted that Person (PER) and Location (LOC) entities are generally easier to extract than Miscellaneous (MISC) and Organization (ORG) entities in English, aligning with human intuition and existing system performance.
  • RE Prediction: The model correctly identified "BORN" and "DIED" relations as easier to extract than "INVENT" and "WROTE" relations, with higher predicted divergence correlating with higher actual precision.
  • Cross-Lingual Consistency: The prediction method showed similar effectiveness for Spanish and Dutch NER tasks, predicting PER entities as easier to extract.
  • Robustness to Collection Size: Predictions made on a smaller subset of Reuters RCV1 were remarkably similar to those made on a much larger subset, indicating scalability.
  • Context Size Impact: For Relation Extraction, a context window of at least two words was found to be necessary for accurate difficulty prediction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Intrinsic Entity Properties: The current approach doesn't account for intrinsic properties of entities (e.g., morphology, capitalization patterns) that can make them easier or harder to identify independent of context. This is noted as a reason why LOC entities might be predicted as harder than they actually are in some cases.
  • Fine-Grained Predictions: While the model distinguishes between "easy" and "hard" relations, it struggles to differentiate between two "hard" relations (e.g., INVENT vs. WROTE).
  • Sophisticated Language Models: The authors suggest extending the method to use more advanced language models that incorporate syntactic features, co-reference resolution, or gazetteer lists for potentially improved predictions.
  • Interactive IE: The prediction method could be used to build interactive IE systems that intelligently request more examples for tasks predicted to be difficult, focusing human effort where it's most needed.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{agichtein2005predicting,
  author = {Eugene Agichtein and Silviu Cucerzan},
  title = {{Predicting accuracy of extracting information from unstructured text collections}},
  booktitle = {ACM International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1145/1099554.1099678},
}
Figure