Abstract
Purpose: To assess the precision (repeatability and reproducibility) and agreement of central corneal thickness (CCT) measurements by E-pach, Pentacam, Corvis ST and A-scan devices in healthy eyes.
Methods: Instrument diagnostic test study. A total of 100 patients were enrolled to measure right-eye CCT by E-pach, Pentacam, Corvis ST, and A-scan devices. To assess repeatability and reproducibility, the test-retest repeatability (TRT) and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were calculated. The agreement among the four devices was evaluated with Bland-Altman plots.
Results: The E-pach showed repeatability (ICC=0.9981), interobserver reproducibility (ICC=0.9971) and intersession reproducibility (ICC=0.9825); the Pentacam, Corvis ST and A-scan also showed similar repeatability (all ICC≥0.9679), interobserver reproducibility (all ICC≥0.9730) and intersession reproducibility (all ICC≥0.9647). However, the E-pach yielded CCT values that were obviously lower than those of the A-scan and Pentacam (P<0.001) but higher than those of the Corvis ST (P<0.001). The 95% limits of agreement (LoA) in the Bland-Altman plots were 44.5 µm (E-pach vs. A-scan), 34.9 µm (E-pach vs. Corvis CT) and 32.5 µm (E-pach vs. Pentacam).
Conclusions: The E-pach is a portable, reliable and inexpensive pachymeter. However, the CCT values obtained from the E-pach are not interchangeable with those from Pentacam, Corvis ST and A-scan devices.
Introduction
Measuring Central Corneal Thickness (CCT) is a cornerstone of clinical ophthalmology. It is essential for screening refractive surgery candidates (such as those for LASIK), diagnosing glaucoma, and managing various corneal diseases. While ultrasound pachymetry (USP) has long been considered the "gold standard," clinicians today have access to a wide range of technologies, from contact-based ultrasonic probes to non-contact optical systems like Scheimpflug imaging.
A significant challenge in clinical practice is that different devices often yield different measurements for the same eye. The E-pach, a new high-frequency (50 MHz), portable ultrasonic pachymeter, has recently entered the market. This study sought to validate the E-pach by determining its precision—how consistent it is when used by different observers or at different times—and its agreement with established clinical standards: the A-scan, Pentacam, and Corvis ST.
Methods
The researchers conducted an instrument diagnostic test study involving 100 healthy volunteers (42 males, 58 females) with a mean age of approximately 28.8 years. To ensure data integrity, the study followed a rigorous measurement protocol:
- Measurement Sequence: Non-contact devices (Pentacam and Corvis ST) were used before contact-based devices (E-pach and A-scan) to prevent topical anesthesia or probe contact from temporarily altering the corneal thickness.
- Precision Testing: To assess repeatability, one observer took three consecutive scans. To assess interobserver reproducibility, a second observer took independent measurements. Finally, intersession reproducibility was tested by repeating the process one week later.
- Statistical Analysis: Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICC) were used to measure consistency, while Bland-Altman plots were employed to visualize the agreement between the different machines.
Results
High Precision and Reliability
The study found that all four devices were highly reliable, with all ICCs exceeding 0.96. The E-pach demonstrated exceptional precision, leading the group with a repeatability ICC of 0.9981 and the lowest test-retest repeatability (TRT) value of 3.7 µm. It also remained highly stable across different observers (ICC 0.9971) and across sessions separated by one week (ICC 0.9825).
The Interchangeability Gap
While the E-pach proved to be highly consistent with itself, its measurements did not align perfectly with other devices. The study identified statistically significant differences between all four machines. Specifically, the E-pach consistently produced CCT values that were:
- Lower than those of the A-scan and Pentacam (P < 0.001).
- Higher than those of the Corvis ST (P < 0.001).
The 95% Limits of Agreement (LoA) were quite wide, such as the 44.5 µm difference observed between the E-pach and the A-scan. Given that a difference of 10 µm is often considered clinically significant, the authors concluded that these devices are not interchangeable.
Discussion and Conclusion
The E-pach is a portable, reliable, and cost-effective tool for measuring corneal thickness. Its high-frequency transducer likely "sees" the boundaries of the cornea differently than lower-frequency ultrasonic probes or optical imaging systems, which explains the systematic bias compared to other devices.
Clinical Implications
The primary takeaway for practitioners is the "Precision Paradox": a device can be incredibly precise yet still yield results that differ from other reliable tools. Because the differences between the E-pach, A-scan, Pentacam, and Corvis ST exceed clinical significance thresholds, clinicians should avoid swapping between these tools when monitoring a patient over time. For longitudinal care, it is best to stick to a single device to ensure that any measured changes reflect actual physiological shifts rather than technological variance.
Limitations
This study focused on healthy eyes. Future research is needed to determine if the E-pach maintains its high precision in pathological conditions, such as keratoconus, corneal edema, or in eyes that have undergone refractive surgery, where corneal anatomy is significantly altered.
Summary updated