Precise calibration of LIGO test mass actuators using photon radiation pressure

E. Goetz, P. Kalmus, Sarah J. Erickson, R. L. Savage, G. González, K. Kawabe, M. Landry, Szabolcs Márka, B. O’Reilly, K. Riles, D. Sigg, P. A. WillemsClassical 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Precise calibration of kilometer-scale interferometric gravitational wave detectors is crucial for source localization and waveform reconstruction. A technique that uses the radiation pressure of a power-modulated auxiliary laser to induce calibrated displacements of one of the ~10 kg arm cavity mirrors, a so-called photon calibrator, has been demonstrated previously and has recently been implemented on the LIGO detectors. In this paper, we discuss the inherent precision and accuracy of the LIGO photon calibrators and several improvements that have been developed to reduce the estimated voice coil actuator calibration uncertainties to less than 2% (1σ). These improvements include accounting for rotation-induced apparent length variations caused by interferometer and photon calibrator beam centering offsets, absolute laser power measurement using temperature-controlled InGaAs photodetectors mounted on integrating spheres and calibrated by NIST, minimizing errors induced by localized elastic deformation of the mirror surface by using a two-beam configuration with the photon calibrator beams symmetrically displaced about the center of the optic and simultaneously actuating the test mass with voice coil actuators and the photon calibrator to minimize fluctuations caused by the changing interferometer response.

Introduction: The Challenge of Sub-Proton Precision

To detect gravitational waves, LIGO must measure changes in its 4-kilometer arm lengths that are smaller than the diameter of a proton (approximately $10^{-18}$ meters). This extraordinary sensitivity requires a complex control loop, known as the DARM loop, which utilizes magnetic "voice coil" actuators to maintain the mirrors' positions. However, converting raw electrical signals into physical measurements of gravitational waves requires an exact understanding of the mirror's displacement per unit of electrical input.

Previous calibration methods often required taking the interferometer out of its most sensitive "science mode" or were plagued by systematic errors. The challenge lies in applying a known, infinitesimal force to a 10 kg mirror while the detector is operational, without physical contact or the introduction of noise.

The Photon Calibrator: Force Without Contact

The researchers address this challenge using a photon calibrator. This device directs a power-modulated auxiliary laser onto the rear surface of a LIGO end test mass (ETM). Because photons carry momentum, they exert radiation pressure upon reflection. By sinusoidally varying the laser's power, researchers can induce a known, periodic displacement in the mirror.

Schematic of the photon calibrator setup, illustrating the auxiliary laser beam path to the End Test Mass (ETM) located ~5.7 meters away.

Key technical improvements introduced in this work include:

  • Two-Beam Configuration: Instead of a single central beam, two beams are displaced symmetrically from the center. This cancels torques that would cause mirror rotation—leading to "apparent" length changes—and minimizes errors from local surface deformation.
  • NIST-Traceable Power Calibration: Force is directly proportional to laser power. The team utilized temperature-controlled InGaAs photodetectors mounted on integrating spheres, calibrated by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), to ensure absolute power accuracy.
  • Simultaneous Actuation: By driving the mirror with both voice coils and the photon calibrator at slightly different frequencies, the systems can be cross-calibrated in real-time, effectively canceling fluctuations in the interferometer's response.

Addressing Elastic Deformation: The "Denting" Problem

A critical insight in high-precision calibration is recognizing that at frequencies in the kilohertz range, the laser does not merely move the mirror as a rigid body; it locally deforms the surface. If the interferometer beam and the calibration beam overlap, the detector measures this local "denting" rather than the bulk center-of-mass motion.

Frequency dependence of the mirror displacement, illustrating the crossover where local elastic deformation ('denting') begins to dominate over center-of-mass motion.

As shown in the figure above, this local deformation can lead to calibration errors as high as 60% at 2 kHz if not properly modeled or mitigated. The two-beam configuration is specifically designed to minimize this effect by moving the calibration beams away from the central interferometer beam.

Results and Performance

The implementation of these refinements led to significant improvements in LIGO's calibration accuracy:

  • Reduced Uncertainty: The overall $1\sigma$ uncertainty of the voice coil actuator calibration was reduced to just 1.3%.
  • Broad Frequency Range: Precise calibration was demonstrated across a wide band, from 90 Hz to 2.1 kHz.
  • Consistency: The measured actuation function adhered to the expected $f^{-2}$ frequency dependence of a free mass, with only 3.7% peak-to-peak variation.
  • Error Budget: The remaining uncertainty is dominated by the rotation factor (1.0%) and absolute power calibration (0.7%).

Limitations and Future Work

The primary remaining limitation is bulk elastic deformation at very high frequencies. As modulation frequencies approach the mirror's internal resonance modes (approximately 6 kHz), the mirror no longer behaves as a simple free mass. While the two-beam setup mitigates local "denting," future detectors will require more complex finite-element modeling to account for bulk flexing. Additionally, as LIGO transitions to "Advanced LIGO" with more sophisticated suspension systems, the photon calibrator must be adapted to even more complex actuation chains.

Summary updated

Abstract

Precise calibration of kilometer-scale interferometric gravitational wave detectors is crucial for source localization and waveform reconstruction. A technique that uses the radiation pressure of a power-modulated auxiliary laser to induce calibrated displacements of one of the ~10 kg arm cavity mirrors, a so-called photon calibrator, has been demonstrated previously and has recently been implemented on the LIGO detectors. In this paper, we discuss the inherent precision and accuracy of the LIGO photon calibrators and several improvements that have been developed to reduce the estimated voice coil actuator calibration uncertainties to less than 2% (1σ). These improvements include accounting for rotation-induced apparent length variations caused by interferometer and photon calibrator beam centering offsets, absolute laser power measurement using temperature-controlled InGaAs photodetectors mounted on integrating spheres and calibrated by NIST, minimizing errors induced by localized elastic deformation of the mirror surface by using a two-beam configuration with the photon calibrator beams symmetrically displaced about the center of the optic and simultaneously actuating the test mass with voice coil actuators and the photon calibrator to minimize fluctuations caused by the changing interferometer response. The photon calibrator is able to operate in the most sensitive interferometer configuration, and is expected to become a primary calibration method for future gravitational wave searches.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{goetz2009precise,
  author = {E. Goetz and P. Kalmus and Sarah J. Erickson and R. L. Savage and G. González and K. Kawabe and M. Landry and Szabolcs Márka and B. O’Reilly and K. Riles and D. Sigg and P. A. Willems},
  title = {{Precise calibration of LIGO test mass actuators using photon radiation pressure}},
  booktitle = {Classical},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1088/0264-9381/26/24/245011},
}

Loading related content...

Figure