Precise and Robust Sidewalk Detection: Leveraging Ensemble Learning to Surpass LLM Limitations in Urban Environments

Ibne Farabi Shihab, Benjir Islam Alvee, Sudesh Ramesh Bhagat, Anuj SharmaarXiv 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a robust ensemble learning approach for precise sidewalk detection in urban environments, outperforming individual models and a state-of-the-art Large Language Model (LLM) in noisy conditions. The ensemble model achieves high accuracy across multiple datasets, demonstrating its reliability for critical applications like autonomous driving and urban planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate sidewalk detection is fundamental for improving road safety, enabling autonomous vehicle navigation, and facilitating effective urban planning. Traditional object detection methods often struggle with the precise localization of sidewalks, which have complex shapes and can be obscured by various environmental factors. While recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown promise in computer vision tasks, their performance can degrade significantly under noisy conditions, a common challenge in real-world urban settings. This paper addresses the need for a robust and reliable sidewalk detection system that can maintain high accuracy even in the presence of noise, outperforming existing LLM-based approaches.

Methods

The core of this research is an ensemble learning approach that combines the strengths of multiple segmentation models. Instead of relying on a single model, the authors integrate three distinct, state-of-the-art segmentation architectures: HAMM (Hierarchical Adaptive Mean Shift), DeepLabV3, and YOLACT.

  • HAMM is chosen for its hierarchical attention mechanisms, adept at isolating relevant features and discerning sidewalk boundaries.
  • DeepLabV3 is incorporated for its ability to handle scale variations and capture intricate details using atrous convolutions and spatial pyramid pooling.
  • YOLACT is included for its real-time instance segmentation capabilities, balancing speed and accuracy.

The ensemble model leverages these individual strengths through a majority voting mechanism to produce a more accurate and robust final prediction. The study also utilizes transfer learning to fine-tune the models, optimizing them for the specific task of sidewalk detection.

Datasets

The study uses three publicly available datasets for training and evaluation:

  • Cityscapes: A widely used dataset for semantic urban scene understanding.
  • Ade20k: Another comprehensive dataset for scene parsing.
  • Boston Dataset: A dataset specifically mentioned for benchmarking.

The paper details the number of training and testing images used from each dataset, with a standard 80/20 split for training/testing. Data augmentation techniques like rotations, flips, and scaling were applied to prevent overfitting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ensemble Power: Combining diverse segmentation models (HAMM, DeepLabV3, YOLACT) significantly boosts performance and robustness compared to individual models. This highlights the benefit of leveraging complementary strengths.
  • LLM Vulnerability to Noise: While the ONE-PEACE LLM performs well in ideal conditions, its performance degrades sharply under various noise types (Gaussian, salt-and-pepper, speckle). This is a critical limitation for real-world applications.
  • Robustness is Key: The ensemble model demonstrates remarkable resilience to noise, showing only a gradual decrease in performance. This makes it a more reliable choice for practical urban scenarios where data quality is often compromised.
  • Architectural Diversity Matters: The selection of models with different architectural designs (attention, atrous convolutions, instance segmentation) for the ensemble was crucial for achieving synergistic benefits.

Key Results

The ensemble model achieved impressive mean Intersection Over Union (mIOU) scores:

  • Cityscapes: 93.1%
  • Ade20k: 90.3%
  • Boston Dataset: 90.6%

Under noisy conditions (Gaussian, Salt-and-Pepper, Speckle), the ensemble model consistently outperformed the ONE-PEACE LLM. For instance, on the Cityscapes dataset with high Gaussian noise, the ensemble achieved an mIOU of 88.6%, while ONE-PEACE dropped to 86.5%. The paper also includes qualitative examples of segmentation, illustrating both successful detections and areas for improvement like over-segmentation and under-segmentation.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Over-segmentation and Under-segmentation: The paper acknowledges instances where the model over-segments sidewalks into unnecessary sections or under-segments by missing parts (e.g., grassy areas).
  • Exclusion of Adjacent Objects: The model sometimes struggles to exclude adjacent non-sidewalk elements like trees.
  • Corner Sections: Missed corner sections of sidewalks indicate a need for more comprehensive training on complex scenarios.
  • LLM's Ideal Scenario Performance: While the ensemble excels in noise, the ONE-PEACE LLM slightly outperforms it in ideal, noise-free conditions.

Future Work:

  • Broader Training: Incorporating a wider variety of sidewalk images and contexts, including tree areas, to improve capture of primary pathway features.
  • Model Refinement: Developing strategies to address over-segmentation and improve the model's ability to recognize sidewalk continuity.
  • Hybrid Approaches: Exploring the integration of LLMs with traditional computer vision techniques to leverage the contextual understanding of LLMs while maintaining robustness in noisy environments.
  • New Backbone Networks: Advancing backbone networks beyond current common architectures to further enhance performance.
  • Data Quality Improvement: Investigating methods to improve data quality, especially for datasets with poor lighting conditions, to enhance model performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aims to compare the effectiveness of a robust ensemble model with the state-of-the-art ONE-PEACE Large Language Model (LLM) for accurate detection of sidewalks. Accurate sidewalk detection is crucial in improving road safety and urban planning. The study evaluated the model's performance on Cityscapes, Ade20k, and the Boston Dataset. The results showed that the ensemble model performed better than the individual models, achieving mean Intersection Over Union (mIOU) scores of 93.1\%, 90.3\%, and 90.6\% on these datasets under ideal conditions. Additionally, the ensemble model maintained a consistent level of performance even in challenging conditions such as Salt-and-Pepper and Speckle noise, with only a gradual decrease in efficiency observed. On the other hand, the ONE-PEACE LLM performed slightly better than the ensemble model in ideal scenarios but experienced a significant decline in performance under noisy conditions. These findings demonstrate the robustness and reliability of the ensemble model, making it a valuable asset for improving urban infrastructure related to road safety and curb space management. This study contributes positively to the broader context of urban health and mobility.
BibTeX
@misc{shihab2024precise,
  author = {Ibne Farabi Shihab and Benjir Islam Alvee and Sudesh Ramesh Bhagat and Anuj Sharma},
  title = {{Precise and Robust Sidewalk Detection: Leveraging Ensemble Learning to Surpass LLM Limitations in Urban Environments}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2405.14876},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.14876},
}
Figure