Precipitation variation: a key factor regulating plant diversity in semi-arid livestock grazing lands

Yantao Wu, Hao Li, Jiahe Cui, Ying Han, Hangyu Li, Bailing Miao, Yongkang Tang, Zhiyong Li, Jinghui Zhang, Lixin Wang, Cunzhu LiangFrontiers in Plant Science 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Livestock presence impacts plant biodiversity (species richness) in grassland ecosystems, yet extent and direction of grazing impacts on biodiversity vary greatly across inter-annual periods. In this study, an 8-year (2014-2021) grazing gradient experiment with sheep was conducted in a semi-arid grassland to investigate the impact of grazing under different precipitation variability on biodiversity. The results suggest no direct impact of grazing on species richness in semi-arid Stipa grassland. However, increased grazing indirectly enhanced species richness by elevating community dominance (increasing the sheltering effect of Stipa grass). Importantly, intensified grazing also regulates excessive community biomass resulting from increased inter-annual wetness (SPEI), amplifying the positive influence of annual humidity index on species richness. Lastly, we emphasize that, in water-constrained grassland ecosystems, intra-annual precipitation variability (PCI) was the most crucial factor driving species richness. Therefore, the water-heat synchrony during the growing season may alleviate physiological constraints on plants, significantly enhancing species richness as a result of multifactorial interactions. Our study provides strong evidence for how to regulate grazing intensity to increase biodiversity under future variable climate patterns. We suggest adapting grazing intensity according to local climate variability to achieve grassland biodiversity conservation.

Introduction

The impact of livestock grazing on plant biodiversity remains a central debate in ecology. While some evidence suggests grazing promotes diversity by reducing competitive exclusion, other studies indicate declines due to overconsumption. These inconsistent findings suggest that the relationship between grazing and biodiversity is not direct but is mediated by environmental factors, particularly water availability in semi-arid regions. This study investigates how grazing intensity interacts with inter-annual wetness and intra-annual precipitation distribution to regulate species richness in the semi-arid grasslands of Inner Mongolia.

Materials and Methods

The study was conducted from 2014 to 2021 in Xilinhot, Inner Mongolia. The experimental design involved 12 paddocks subjected to four grazing intensities: No Grazing (NG), Low (LG), Medium (MG), and High (HG), using sheep as the primary livestock.

Figure 1: Study area location in Inner Mongolia and historical climate trends (1960-2021) for temperature and precipitation.

Researchers employed a "meta-community" approach, sampling species-level biomass and richness throughout the growing season (June–September). Climate metrics included the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) for annual wetness and the Precipitation Concentration Index (PCI) for intra-annual rainfall distribution. Piecewise Structural Equation Modeling (pSEM) was used to identify the direct and indirect pathways through which grazing and climate factors influence species richness.

Results and Discussion

Drivers of Species Richness

The most significant finding was that intra-annual precipitation variability (PCI) accounted for 70% of the variation in species richness. High water-heat synchrony—where rainfall is concentrated during the peak growing season—alleviates physiological constraints on plants, leading to spikes in diversity. Inter-annual wetness (SPEI) and shoot biomass accounted for 14% and 10% of the variation, respectively.

The Role of Grazing

The pSEM analysis revealed that grazing has no significant direct effect on species richness. Instead, its influence is mediated through changes in community structure. Increased grazing intensity was found to increase the dominance of the bunchgrass Stipa grandis. In this ecosystem, Stipa provides a "shelter effect," acting as a biological refuge that protects smaller, vulnerable species from environmental stress and foraging.

Furthermore, grazing acts as a "safety valve" during wet years (high SPEI). In these periods, excessive biomass production can lead to competitive exclusion. Grazing mitigates this by reducing shoot biomass, thereby preventing dominant species from shading out subordinate ones and maintaining overall richness.

Conclusion

This research highlights that in water-constrained ecosystems, climate variability—specifically the timing of rainfall—is the primary driver of plant diversity. Grazing serves as a crucial management tool that can regulate the negative effects of excessive biomass in wet years and enhance the protective "shelter effect" of dominant grasses. For sustainable grassland management, grazing intensity should be adaptively adjusted in response to real-time climate variability to maximize biodiversity conservation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Livestock presence impacts plant biodiversity (species richness) in grassland ecosystems, yet extent and direction of grazing impacts on biodiversity vary greatly across inter-annual periods. In this study, an 8-year (2014-2021) grazing gradient experiment with sheep was conducted in a semi-arid grassland to investigate the impact of grazing under different precipitation variability on biodiversity. The results suggest no direct impact of grazing on species richness in semi-arid <i>Stipa</i> grassland. However, increased grazing indirectly enhanced species richness by elevating community dominance (increasing the sheltering effect of <i>Stipa</i> grass). Importantly, intensified grazing also regulates excessive community biomass resulting from increased inter-annual wetness (SPEI), amplifying the positive influence of annual humidity index on species richness. Lastly, we emphasize that, in water-constrained grassland ecosystems, intra-annual precipitation variability (PCI) was the most crucial factor driving species richness. Therefore, the water-heat synchrony during the growing season may alleviate physiological constraints on plants, significantly enhancing species richness as a result of multifactorial interactions. Our study provides strong evidence for how to regulate grazing intensity to increase biodiversity under future variable climate patterns. We suggest adapting grazing intensity according to local climate variability to achieve grassland biodiversity conservation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2024precipitation,
  author = {Yantao Wu and Hao Li and Jiahe Cui and Ying Han and Hangyu Li and Bailing Miao and Yongkang Tang and Zhiyong Li and Jinghui Zhang and Lixin Wang and Cunzhu Liang},
  title = {{Precipitation variation: a key factor regulating plant diversity in semi-arid livestock grazing lands}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2024.1294895},
}
Figure