Precarity and Solidarity: Preliminary Results on a Study of Queer and Disabled Fiction Writers' Experiences with Generative AI

Carolyn Elizabeth Lamb, Daniel G. Brown, Maura R. GrossmanIJCAI 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the experiences of queer and disabled fiction writers with generative AI (genAI), revealing that these marginalized groups are more pessimistic about genAI's impact on their industry due to exacerbated precarity. The research highlights how writers are employing solidarity and self-protection strategies to safeguard their livelihoods against the perceived threats of genAI.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid advancement and integration of generative AI (genAI) into creative industries, particularly writing, raise significant questions about its impact on professional writers. While genAI promises efficiency, its implications for the livelihoods, creative integrity, and economic stability of writers are not fully understood. This paper specifically addresses the experiences of queer and disabled fiction writers, a demographic that may face heightened precarity within the already unstable publishing industry. The authors aim to understand how genAI exacerbates existing challenges for these writers, their reasons for opposing its use, and the collective strategies they employ to protect their profession.

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining quantitative survey data with qualitative analysis.

  • Quantitative: Descriptive statistics were used for survey questions, including Likert-scale items assessing ease of making money, gaining publisher attention, and reaching readers, both for the past and future five years, and the perceived impact of genAI.
  • Qualitative: A grounded theory approach was used to analyze free-text responses from survey participants. This involved open coding and theoretical sampling to identify emergent themes and concepts. The researchers specifically focused on analyzing the responses of queer and disabled writers, oversampling them to gain deeper insights into their unique experiences.

Datasets

The study collected data from a survey of 137 professional fiction writers. The authors intentionally oversampled queer and disabled writers, resulting in 54 individuals in this group, with the remaining 75 forming a control group. The demographics of the surveyed writers were compared to data from the 2023 Author's Guild survey on writer income to assess representativeness. No new datasets were introduced or created for this study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Precarity as a Central Concept: The experiences and attitudes of queer and disabled writers towards genAI are deeply rooted in the concept of "precarity," referring to their already unstable and insecure working conditions in the publishing industry.
  • GenAI Exacerbates Existing Precarity: Rather than offering new opportunities, genAI is seen as intensifying existing challenges like competition, lack of control, and financial instability, particularly for marginalized writers.
  • "Soul" as a Marker of Value: Writers distinguish between human-created art and genAI output based on the concept of "soul," which represents intentionality, personal expression, and conscious communication. GenAI is perceived as lacking this essential human element, making it fundamentally "soulless" and counterfeit.
  • Solidarity as a Defense Mechanism: The opposition to genAI is not solely individualistic but also a conscious strategy of solidarity and self-protection among a vulnerable population. Writers are actively engaging in collective actions to safeguard their industry.
  • Marginalization Amplifies Pessimism: Queer and disabled writers exhibit significantly higher levels of pessimism regarding genAI's impact compared to other writers, likely due to their existing heightened precarity and the potential for genAI to further marginalize them.

Key Results

  • Quantitative: Queer disabled writers reported significantly greater difficulty in making money and gaining publisher attention in both the past and future five years. They also perceived the impact of genAI in the next five years as more negative compared to the control group.
  • Qualitative:
    • Writers view genAI as unhelpful for their creative goals and ethically unacceptable, primarily due to concerns about copyright infringement and the concept of "soul."
    • The publishing industry is described as already precarious, with both traditional and self-publishing facing challenges. GenAI is seen as worsening these conditions, particularly through the influx of AI-generated content in self-publishing and potential AI integration into traditional publishing processes.
  • Writers are employing various strategies to resist genAI, including setting "genAI boundaries" (refusing to work with AI or publishers using AI), engaging in public backlash, and fostering solidarity with other creative professionals.
  • The rise of genAI has had a negative impact on the mental health of writers, exacerbating existing stress and anxiety.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that its sampling method overrepresented queer and disabled writers, which, while intentional for analysis, means the findings might not be representative of all fiction writers.
  • The qualitative analysis did not reach full saturation, meaning some minor new insights might still emerge.
  • The study primarily focuses on writers from the Global North and acknowledges that experiences in the Global South may differ.
  • The reliance on Bluesky for recruitment might skew responses towards those more active in online discourse.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors plan to complete the analysis of all 137 writers' data to provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • They aim to apply their findings to policy discussions regarding compensation for AI training data and opt-in/opt-out mechanisms.
  • A longitudinal study is proposed to track changes in writers' experiences and attitudes over time.
  • The authors emphasize that the concerns raised by creative workers regarding precarity and AI are not unique and should be considered for all workers facing similar challenges.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{lamb2025precarity,
  author = {Carolyn Elizabeth Lamb and Daniel G. Brown and Maura R. Grossman},
  title = {{Precarity and Solidarity: Preliminary Results on a Study of Queer and Disabled Fiction Writers' Experiences with Generative AI}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2025/1124},
}
Figure