Pre-service Teachers Learning to Teach English as a Foreign Language to Preschool Learners in Macau: A Longitudinal Study

Barry Lee Reynolds, Sylvia Liu, Xuan Van Ha, Xiaofang Zhang, Chen DingFrontiers in Psychology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Language teacher beliefs have received increasing research attention for the past few decades. However, little is known about the beliefs of pre-service teachers in the pre-primary English as a foreign language (EFL) education context. This qualitative case study extends this line of inquiry by investigating the trajectory of student teachers' beliefs about teaching English to pre-primary learners in Macau within a teacher education course. The participants included 60 pre-service teachers taking an English Language Activities course in their third year of a 4-year Bachelor of pre-primary education program. The data comprised written reflections collected at three points in time during the 16-week course: at the beginning of the course, mid-way through the course, and at the end of the course. The findings showed five broad themes, constituted from 15 subthemes, regarding (1) learners and learning, (2) teaching, (3) subject, (4) self, and (5) learning to teach. The major themes have been documented in the literature, but several subthemes were identified for the first time in the context of pre-primary EFL teacher education. More importantly, the findings revealed that some of the subthemes were newly shaped and several subthemes were reshaped as a consequence of taking the course. The findings were interpreted in relation to the content of the course, the experiential learning opportunities, the pre-service teachers' prior experiences of language learning and teaching, and the local language teaching and learning context. Implications for pre-service teacher education programs are discussed.

Introduction

A teacher’s classroom behavior is heavily dictated by their underlying beliefs, yet we know surprisingly little about how these beliefs form in the specific context of pre-primary English as a Foreign Language (EFL) education. In regions like Macau, where specialized training for early childhood English teachers is limited, understanding this "belief trajectory" is crucial. This study addresses a gap in the literature: while general teacher beliefs are well-studied, the specific transition of student teachers from "learners" to "practitioners" in the preschool EFL niche remains under-explored. The researchers sought to determine if a single 16-week teacher education course could effectively dismantle pre-existing misconceptions—such as the idea that teaching is merely "telling and memorizing"—and replace them with evidence-based pedagogical strategies.

Methodology

The researchers employed a qualitative longitudinal case study design, following 60 third-year Bachelor of Pre-primary Education students at a university in Macau. Data collection involved written reflections at three intervals: Week 1 (start), Week 9 (mid-way, following microteaching), and Week 16 (end).

The analysis utilized Qualitative Content Analysis (QCA) supported by NVivo 12. A two-cycle coding process was implemented: concept-driven coding based on existing literature and data-driven (in vivo) coding to capture new themes. To ensure rigor, two coders from different backgrounds (Early Childhood vs. English Education) achieved an inter-rater reliability score of >0.99. The primary dataset consisted of 180 anonymized reflection reports. Notably, the volume of reflection increased from 12,282 word tokens at Time 1 to 21,431 tokens at Time 3, suggesting deeper cognitive engagement as the course progressed.

Results and Analysis

The study identified 15 subthemes categorized under five broad themes: learners and learning, teaching, subject, self, and learning to teach.

Conceptual framework of pre-service pre-primary teachers' beliefs

The longitudinal data revealed significant shifts in participant beliefs over the 16-week period, particularly following the microteaching component in the middle of the semester.

Evolution of teacher beliefs across three time points

Key Shifts in Beliefs

  • Pedagogical Knowledge: Beliefs in this area became universal; 100% of participants expressed specific pedagogical beliefs by Time 3, compared to 68.33% at the start.
  • Assessment Awareness: At the start of the course, 0% of students mentioned assessment. By the end, 76.67% discussed age-appropriate assessment tools like picture-matching games.
  • Self-Evaluation: Similarly, beliefs regarding the importance of self-evaluation jumped from 0% to 56.67% by the end of the course, indicating a shift toward professional reflexivity.
  • The Microteaching Pivot: The mid-course microteaching sessions acted as a catalyst. Beliefs shifted from abstract theories to concrete, "trialed" classroom practices.
  • From "Subject" to "Tool": Initially, many students viewed English as a rigid academic subject. By the end, they increasingly viewed it as a "tool for communication," emphasizing fluency and engagement over rote memorization.
  • Emergence of Research Literacy: A surprising finding was the development of "epistemological beliefs informed by literature." By the end of the course, 66.67% of students explicitly linked their teaching philosophy to educational research they had read.

Discussion

The findings highlight a clear movement away from "transmissive" (teacher-centered) beliefs toward "constructivist" (child-centered) ones, focusing on games, storytelling, and nurturing a child's natural curiosity. The development of research literacy and self-evaluation suggests that the course successfully fostered a professional identity beyond basic instructional skills.

However, the study has limitations. It relies entirely on self-reported written reflections, which may not always align with actual classroom practice (the "belief-practice" gap). Additionally, the sample was limited to female students from a single institution in Macau, which may affect generalizability.

Conclusion

This longitudinal study demonstrates that targeted teacher education—specifically involving microteaching and reflection—can fundamentally reshape how educators perceive early childhood language acquisition. Future research should follow these teachers into their first few years of employment to see if these newly formed beliefs survive the "reality shock" of full-time teaching and triangulate reflection data with direct classroom observations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Language teacher beliefs have received increasing research attention for the past few decades. However, little is known about the beliefs of pre-service teachers in the pre-primary English as a foreign language (EFL) education context. This qualitative case study extends this line of inquiry by investigating the trajectory of student teachers' beliefs about teaching English to pre-primary learners in Macau within a teacher education course. The participants included 60 pre-service teachers taking an <i>English Language Activities</i> course in their third year of a 4-year Bachelor of pre-primary education program. The data comprised written reflections collected at three points in time during the 16-week course: at the beginning of the course, mid-way through the course, and at the end of the course. The findings showed five broad themes, constituted from 15 subthemes, regarding (1) learners and learning, (2) teaching, (3) subject, (4) self, and (5) learning to teach. The major themes have been documented in the literature, but several subthemes were identified for the first time in the context of pre-primary EFL teacher education. More importantly, the findings revealed that some of the subthemes were newly shaped and several subthemes were reshaped as a consequence of taking the course. The findings were interpreted in relation to the content of the course, the experiential learning opportunities, the pre-service teachers' prior experiences of language learning and teaching, and the local language teaching and learning context. Implications for pre-service teacher education programs are discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{reynolds2021pre,
  author = {Barry Lee Reynolds and Sylvia Liu and Xuan Van Ha and Xiaofang Zhang and Chen Ding},
  title = {{Pre-service Teachers Learning to Teach English as a Foreign Language to Preschool Learners in Macau: A Longitudinal Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2021.720660},
}
Figure