TL;DR
This paper introduces "Pre/Absence," a novel VR experience designed to foster cultural awareness and understanding of lost architectural heritage. By employing a "presence-absence dialectic" and spatiotemporal narratives, it moves beyond factual presentation to engage users in a deeper, more critical interpretation of heritage, significantly outperforming traditional methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Lost architectural heritage, by its very nature, presents a challenge for interpretation. Its physical absence means that understanding relies on fragmented records, leading to a flattening of complex cultural meanings into basic facts. Current interpretation methods often present this information linearly, overlooking the rich layers of history, societal context, and evolving interpretations that characterize such heritage. This lack of depth hinders the development of genuine cultural awareness and a profound understanding of its significance. The authors aim to address this by exploring how Virtual Reality (VR) can be used to create more nuanced and engaging narratives that capture both what remains (presence) and what is lost (absence) to foster deeper cultural understanding.
Methods
The core of this research is the "Pre/Absence" VR experience, designed around the presence-absence dialectic. This framework involves:
- Spatiotemporal Narrative Design: The VR experience unfolds across five scenes, chronologically moving through the history of Hanyuan Hall, from its archaeological excavation to its Tang Dynasty grandeur, its destruction, subsequent reinterpretations, and finally, a return to the present. This temporal layering allows users to experience the heritage's evolution.
- Presence-Absence Integration:
- Presencing Absence: This involves making the absent elements perceptible. Techniques include using AI-generated 3D models of historical figures and events, and employing point-cloud effects to highlight voids and contrasts.
- Interpreting Presence: This focuses on presenting remaining traces, such as historical archives and the reconstructed foundation, through direct presentation and 3D reconstructions.
- Augmenting Absence: This aims to evoke a strong contrast between past glory and present emptiness, using visual effects like point-cloud models to emphasize what is no longer there.
- Critical Narrative Framework: The VR experience incorporates multiple narrators and perspectives, creating a "narrative competition" that challenges dominant historical narratives and encourages critical reflection on how heritage meanings are constructed and contested.
- Embodied Interactions: Users are actively engaged through interactions like exploring environments, triggering narratives, and a final ritualistic act of writing on a digital scroll, positioning them as co-constructors of meaning.
Datasets
Not explicitly discussed as datasets for training AI models. The study utilizes:
- Official 3D reconstruction model of Hanyuan Hall: Provided by the heritage administration office, based on historical records and archaeological data.
- Historical archives: Including photos, written records, and surveying drawings related to Hanyuan Hall.
- AI-generated content: 3D models of historical figures and historical scenarios generated using tools like Tripo and Midjourney.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Presence-Absence as a Powerful Design Lens: The study demonstrates that the interplay between what is present and what is absent is not just a theoretical concept but a practical design principle that can significantly enhance engagement and understanding of lost heritage.
- VR's Unique Affordance for Temporal Depth: VR can effectively collapse spatiotemporal distances, allowing users to "walk into" history and experience the continuous evolution of heritage meanings across different eras, fostering a dynamic rather than static view.
- Beyond Factual Knowledge: The research highlights that while VR can improve factual knowledge, its true power lies in its ability to foster cultural awareness, emotional engagement, and critical reflection by presenting complex, multifaceted narratives.
- "Narrative Competition" Challenges Dominant Discourses: By juxtaposing diverse and sometimes contradictory narratives, the VR experience encourages users to question "authorized" historical accounts and recognize the ongoing renegotiation of heritage meanings.
- Embodied Interaction Fosters Agency: The participatory elements, particularly the final ritual, transform users from passive observers into active co-constructors of meaning, fostering a sense of responsibility for heritage preservation.
Key Results
- Enhanced Cultural Awareness: Participants using the "Pre/Absence" VR experience showed significantly greater improvements in cultural awareness scores compared to those who read a paper-based document (p = .001).
- Improved Knowledge Acquisition: Both groups showed improvement in knowledge tests, but the VR group's gains in cultural awareness were substantially higher, indicating that VR is more effective for deeper understanding.
- High Sense of Presence: Participants reported a high sense of presence in the VR environment, with strong scores in realism, possibility to act, and self-evaluation of performance, though interface quality was a minor limitation.
- Qualitative Feedback: Participants described the VR experience as enriching, providing contextualized insights, and fostering a deeper, more critical understanding of Hanyuan Hall's significance and its evolving meanings. They felt more connected to the heritage and its historical context.
Limitations and Future Work
- Small and Homogeneous Sample: The user study sample (N=28) consisted mainly of university students, limiting the generalizability of the findings. Future studies should include more diverse participants, particularly historians.
- Short-Term Evaluation: The study focused on immediate responses. Longitudinal studies are needed to assess the long-term impact of the VR experience on cultural awareness.
- Technical Refinements: The authors suggest improving the design quality, specifically the animations of NPCs and the overall fluency of the VR experience.
- Ethical Considerations: The authors acknowledge the need to balance emotional engagement with avoiding retraumatization and emotional manipulation, suggesting designers should give users control and offer multiple emotional entry points.
- Participatory Co-creation: Future HCI studies should actively involve local communities in co-creating narratives to avoid reproducing single, authorized versions of the past.
Summary updated