Practical Prescribed Tracking Control of n-DOF Robotic Manipulator with Uncertainties via Friction Compensation Approach

Chao Chen, Fuxin Du, Bin Chen, Detong Chen, Weikai He, Qiang Chen, Chengxi Zhang, Jin Wu, Jihe WangSymmetry 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel control strategy for robotic manipulators that precisely tracks desired trajectories while accounting for unknown system dynamics and friction. By combining a new type of observer with a friction compensation approach and prescribed performance bounds, the method ensures accurate and robust control, demonstrated through simulations and experiments on a six-DOF robot.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Controlling robotic manipulators to follow specific paths with high accuracy is a fundamental challenge. Real-world robots are subject to complex, often unknown, internal dynamics (like friction) and external disturbances. Existing control methods often struggle with these uncertainties, leading to performance degradation, chattering (unwanted oscillations), or requiring excessive computational resources and precise knowledge of the robot's model. Furthermore, achieving guaranteed performance bounds (e.g., ensuring tracking errors stay within a certain limit) while handling abrupt changes like friction mutations (which occur when a robot's movement direction reverses) is particularly difficult. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a practical, robust, and accurate control strategy that explicitly addresses these issues.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution lies in a composite control strategy that integrates three key components:

  • Continuously Differentiable Friction Model: Instead of using discontinuous friction models that can cause control instability, the authors employ a smooth, differentiable model. This model accurately captures various friction phenomena (Stribeck, Coulomb, viscous) and is easier to integrate into control designs. They also propose a practical method for identifying the parameters of this friction model.
  • Variable Gain Extended State Observer (VGFESO): This is a novel observer designed to estimate unknown system dynamics and unmeasured velocities. It's an improvement over traditional Extended State Observers (ESOs) because it uses time-varying gains. This feature helps to mitigate "peaking" issues (large initial estimation errors) and, crucially, allows it to better handle sudden friction changes without losing accuracy.
  • Prescribed Performance Control (PPC) with Independent Joint Control: The VGFESO is combined with a prescribed performance function (PPF). This PPF defines strict upper and lower bounds for the tracking error, ensuring that the robot's performance stays within desired limits. The control is designed independently for each joint, simplifying the implementation. The strategy relies solely on position measurements, which is a practical advantage.

The overall approach uses a backstepping method for controller design, progressively building the control law while ensuring stability. A tracking differentiator is also incorporated to estimate the derivative of the desired trajectory, further enhancing performance.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses:

  • Simulated Data: Generated from a two-link rigid robotic manipulator model with parameters provided in the paper.
  • Experimental Data: Collected from a real-world six-DOF collaborative robotic manipulator (Elfin-E03). The friction parameters for specific joints (2 and 3) were identified using experimental data and a Differential Evolution (DE) algorithm.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Friction is a major hurdle, and smooth models are key: The paper highlights that accurately modeling and compensating for friction, especially its abrupt changes, is critical for robust robotic control. Using a continuously differentiable friction model is a significant step towards stable and predictable control.
  • Time-varying gains in observers are powerful: The VGFESO's use of time-varying gains is a clever way to balance the need for fast estimation during disturbances with the avoidance of instability and large initial errors. This adaptive gain strategy is crucial for handling the dynamic nature of robotic systems.
  • Prescribed performance offers concrete guarantees: The integration of PPF provides a formal way to guarantee that tracking errors will always stay within predefined, acceptable bounds, which is highly desirable for safety-critical applications.
  • Position-only control is practical: Relying only on position measurements simplifies hardware requirements and implementation, making the proposed method more accessible for real-world deployment.

Key Results

The proposed PPC-VGFESO controller demonstrated superior performance compared to standard Active Disturbance Rejection Control (ADRC) and Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controllers in both simulations and experiments.

  • Simulation: The controller ensured tracking errors remained within the prescribed performance bounds, outperforming ADRC and PID, which exhibited larger errors and less robustness to disturbances. The VGFESO also showed significantly better disturbance estimation compared to a standard ESO.
  • Experiment (Six-DOF Robot):
    • Joint Space Tracking: The PPC-VGFESO achieved faster convergence and smaller steady-state errors than ADRC and PID, even under load changes and sinusoidal trajectories.
  • Cartesian Space Tracking: In various scenarios involving different speeds and a 1 kg load, the proposed method consistently achieved lower maximum and average end-effector position errors (e.g., for a 600 mm/s, 1 kg load case, the average error was 0.2725 mm, compared to 0.7481 mm for ADRC and 1.5230 mm for PID).
  • Actuator Saturation: The proposed method effectively avoided actuator saturation issues, unlike PID and ADRC, which could lead to motor damage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper acknowledges that while the proposed method avoids actuator saturation issues, it doesn't explicitly incorporate anti-saturation compensation techniques.
  • The experimental validation was primarily focused on joints 2 and 3, which are most affected by gravity and coupling, though the method is designed for n-DOF systems.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors plan to develop novel algorithms that incorporate anti-saturation compensation techniques to ensure robust performance even under actuator saturation conditions.
  • They suggest the method's broad applicability, hinting at its potential use in other electromechanical systems like biomimetic bat robots.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents a practical and straightforward control strategy for robotic manipulators with unknown dynamics to achieve prescribed tracking performance, which has implementation advantages compared with previous work. In particular, an improved extended state observer (ESO) synthesized with a continuously differentiable friction model and time-varying gains is presented to estimate system states and unknown dynamics. This ESO outperforms the conventional ones in dealing with friction mutations while avoiding peaking estimation values in the initial stage. By combining the prescribed performance function and the proposed ESO, an independent joint control scheme is proposed for a robotic manipulator to keep the tracking error within a predefined performance bound based only on position measurements. The effectiveness of the proposed control scheme is verified by comparative simulation and experimental results on a six-degrees-of-freedom robotic manipulator with active disturbance rejection controller and PID methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2024practical,
  author = {Chao Chen and Fuxin Du and Bin Chen and Detong Chen and Weikai He and Qiang Chen and Chengxi Zhang and Jin Wu and Jihe Wang},
  title = {{Practical Prescribed Tracking Control of n-DOF Robotic Manipulator with Uncertainties via Friction Compensation Approach}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/sym16040423},
}
Figure