Ppnet: A Two-Stage Neural Network for End-to-End Path Planning

Qinglong Meng, Chongkun Xia, Xueqian Wang, Songping Mai, Bin LiangSSRN 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces PPNet, a novel two-stage neural network for end-to-end path planning that significantly outperforms traditional sampling-based methods in terms of speed and success rate. It achieves this by first segmenting the navigable space and then generating waypoints, all within a single forward pass, and is trained on data generated by their proposed EDaGe-PP method.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Path planning, the task of finding a collision-free and low-cost route between a start and goal point, is crucial for applications like autonomous vehicles and robotics. While sampling-based methods like RRT offer probabilistic completeness (guaranteeing a solution if one exists as more samples are taken), they struggle to find near-optimal* solutions within strict time constraints (e.g., under 0.1 seconds). Existing learning-based methods can be fast but often require many iterations to improve path quality or may not generalize well to unseen environments. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing an end-to-end, fast, and reliable path planner that guarantees near-optimal solutions.

Methods

PPNet is a two-stage neural network designed to tackle path planning in an end-to-end fashion.

  • Stage 1: Space Segmentation (SpaceSegNet): This stage takes an image representing the path planning problem (including the environment, start, and goal) and outputs a "path space" mask. This mask highlights the regions where a valid path is likely to exist, considering clearance requirements. This is framed as a segmentation task.
  • Stage 2: Waypoint Generation (WaypointGenNet): This stage takes the path space mask from Stage 1 and generates a probability map indicating the likelihood of each point being a waypoint. Waypoints are then extracted from this map using a simple rule. This stage is implemented as a Transformer-based Autoencoder.

A key innovation is EDaGe-PP, a novel data generation method. It addresses limitations of existing methods by:

  • Generating continuous-curvature paths with analytical expressions, which are more suitable for neural network training than discrete waypoints.
  • Satisfying clearance requirements.
  • Significantly speeding up data generation (33x faster) and improving the success rate of trained models (2x improvement).

Datasets

The paper introduces a new dataset generated by their EDaGe-PP method. This dataset consists of images representing path planning problems, along with masks for the path space and waypoints. For training and evaluation, they used a dataset of 320,000 maps for SpaceSegNet and 4,000 maps for PPNet comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decomposition for End-to-End Learning: Breaking down the complex path planning problem into two distinct, learnable sub-problems (space segmentation and waypoint generation) is a powerful strategy for creating an end-to-end neural network solution.
  • Continuous Curvature is Key: Generating continuous-curvature paths with EDaGe-PP, rather than discrete waypoints, significantly improves the training efficiency and success rate of the PPNet model. This is a crucial insight for learning-based path planning.
  • NAT Encoder Superiority: For the space segmentation task, the Neighborhood Attention (NA) mechanism used in the NAT encoder proved superior to other vision transformers (ViT, Swin, DINAT) because its assumption of local attention aligns better with the spatial relationships relevant to path planning.
  • Speed vs. Optimality Trade-off: While traditional planners can achieve high path quality with enough time, PPNet demonstrates that near-optimal solutions can be found extremely quickly (milliseconds) by leveraging learned representations.

Key Results

  • PPNet can find a near-optimal path in 15.3ms, significantly faster than state-of-the-art sampling-based planners like RRT* (which took up to 60 seconds for a comparable solution).
  • PPNet achieved approximately 41% success rate improvement compared to representative learning-based methods when trained on EDaGe-PP generated data.
  • EDaGe-PP itself provides about 33x computation speed improvement and 2x success rate improvement for data generation compared to popular methods.
  • PPNet outperforms MPNetPath (a variant of MPNet) in computation time (up to 9x speedup), path cost, and success rate.
  • PPNet achieved a 94.47% success rate when trained on data generated by EDaGe-PP, compared to much lower rates for methods trained on data generated by RRT, IRRT, BIT, and ABIT.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D Limitation: The current PPNet is designed for 2D path planning scenarios.
  • Generalization to Higher Dimensions: The authors explicitly state that extending PPNet to 3D space planning is a significant future research direction.
  • EDaGe-PP for 3D: Extending the EDaGe-PP data generation method to 3D is also identified as challenging future work.
  • MPNetPath Success Rate: While PPNet excels, MPNetPath-EDaGe-PP showed a lower success rate due to RNN limitations in predicting long sequences and the higher number of waypoints in EDaGe-PP generated data. This suggests potential for further improvements in integrating sequence modeling with PPNet.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{meng2024ppnet,
  author = {Qinglong Meng and Chongkun Xia and Xueqian Wang and Songping Mai and Bin Liang},
  title = {{Ppnet: A Two-Stage Neural Network for End-to-End Path Planning}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.4757474},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure