Potentially Toxic Elements Accumulation and Health Risk Evaluation in Different Parts of Traditional Chinese Medicinal Materials

Jie Pan, Di Huang, Xue Ma, Di Zhu, Yueliang Lu, Chunhua Liu, Lin Zheng, Yongjun Li, Jia SunToxics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the accumulation of five potentially toxic elements (PTEs) – arsenic (As), mercury (Hg), lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), and copper (Cu) – in various parts of Traditional Chinese Medicinal Materials (TCMMs), including plant-derived (underground and aboveground) and animal-derived components. The research found distinct contamination patterns between plant and animal sources, with animal-derived materials showing higher PTE loads and requiring special attention for risk management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global use of Traditional Chinese Medicinal Materials (TCMMs) is rapidly increasing, raising concerns about their safety due to potential contamination by harmful substances, particularly potentially toxic elements (PTEs). While research has examined PTEs in TCMMs, there's a lack of systematic comparison across different plant parts (roots/rhizomes vs. stems/leaves/flowers/fruits/seeds) and a comprehensive evaluation including animal-derived decoction pieces. Furthermore, existing health risk assessments often overlook the randomness of contaminant distribution and human exposure, leading to uncertainty. This paper aims to fill these gaps by providing a detailed analysis of PTE contamination in various TCMM categories, identifying sources, and conducting a robust health risk assessment with uncertainty analysis.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Sample Collection: 422 batches of 59 TCMM types were collected, categorized into roots/rhizomes, stems/leaves/whole herbs/flowers/fruits/seeds, and animal-derived decoction pieces.
  • PTE Analysis: Inductively Coupled Plasma Atomic Emission Spectrometry (ICP-AES) and Atomic Fluorescence Spectrometry (AFS) were used to quantify As, Hg, Pb, Cd, and Cu concentrations.
  • Statistical Analysis:
    • Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA): Used to identify distinct contamination patterns and potential sources of PTEs across different material types.
  • Single-Factor Pollution Index (Pᵢ) and Nemerow Pollution Index (P<0xE2><0x82><0x99>): Applied to assess the levels of PTE contamination against established standards.
  • Health Risk Assessment:
    • Target Hazard Quotient (THQ) and Hazard Index (HI): Calculated to assess non-carcinogenic risks.
  • Carcinogenic Risk (CR): Evaluated for carcinogenic PTEs.
  • Monte Carlo Simulation: Employed to quantify uncertainties in the health risk assessment by incorporating probabilistic distributions of parameters.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: Used to identify key contributors to uncertainty in the risk estimates.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 422 batches of 59 types of commercially available TCMMs. These samples were categorized as follows:

  • Plant-derived:
    • Roots and rhizomes (underground parts): 177 batches
    • Stems, leaves, whole herbs, flowers, fruits, and seeds (aboveground parts): 170 batches
  • Animal-derived:
    • Animal-derived decoction pieces: 75 batches

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relied on existing sample collections.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Animal-derived materials are a significant concern: These materials consistently showed higher PTE concentrations and exceedance rates compared to plant-derived materials, suggesting a greater need for regulatory attention.
  • Distinct contamination profiles: PCA and HCA revealed that plant-derived materials (both underground and aboveground) share similar PTE source patterns, while animal-derived materials exhibit unique profiles. This highlights fundamental biological differences in metal uptake and metabolism.
  • Element-specific contamination: Key pollutants varied by material type. As and Hg were prominent in underground parts, Hg and Cu in aboveground parts, and all five PTEs were relevant in animal-derived materials.
  • Pollution indices vs. Health risks: A crucial finding is the potential discrepancy between high pollution index values and actual health risks. High PTE concentrations don't always translate to high health risks, as toxicity weighting and exposure dose play critical roles. This underscores the importance of a comprehensive risk assessment beyond simple contamination levels.
  • Uncertainty in risk assessment: Metal concentrations and daily intake were identified as the primary drivers of uncertainty in health risk estimations, emphasizing the need for accurate data and standardized dosing.

Key Results

  • PTE Concentrations:
    • Animal-derived decoction pieces: Showed the highest concentration ranges and exceedance rates for most PTEs, with exceedance rates ranging from 6.7% to 41.3%.
  • Aboveground parts: Had exceedance rates ranging from 0% to 8.8%.
  • Underground parts: Had the lowest exceedance rates, ranging from 0% to 2.3%.
  • Pollution Levels: 16 out of 422 samples were found to be contaminated based on the single-factor pollution index (Pᵢ > 1). Notably, Artemisiae Argyi Folium showed moderate pollution (PN > 3), and Pheretima exhibited heavy pollution (PN > 3).
  • Health Risk Assessment:
    • Non-carcinogenic risk (HI): All categories showed HI values < 1, with a 0% probability of HI > 1 in the Monte Carlo simulation, indicating low non-carcinogenic risks.
  • Carcinogenic risk (CR): The 95th percentile CR values were <1 × 10⁻⁴ for all categories. However, the probability of CR > 1 × 10⁻⁶ was significant for all categories, suggesting potential concern.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: Metal concentrations and daily intake were the most significant contributors to uncertainty in both HI and CR estimates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that while pollution indices are useful for identifying contamination, they don't fully capture the cumulative risk posed by multiple PTEs.
  • The health risk assessment, while incorporating uncertainty, relies on established reference doses (RfDs) and carcinogenic slope factors (CSFs), which can have inherent variability.
  • The study noted that some commonly used animal decoction pieces, like Cicadae Periostracum and Pheretima, still lack established regulatory standards.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors recommend establishing corresponding limit standards for all single-ingredient animal-derived medicinal materials, excluding those already covered.
  • Further research is needed to elucidate the specific mechanisms behind the distinct contamination patterns observed in animal-derived materials.
  • The findings highlight the need for strengthened source management and standardized dosing to further reduce potential health risks associated with TCMMs.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study systematically analyzed commercially available traditional Chinese medicines for As, Hg, Pb, Cd, and Cu, classifying them into roots and rhizomes (underground parts), stems and leaves, whole herbs, flowers, fruits and seeds (aboveground parts), and animal-derived decoction pieces. The concentration ranges of five elements in underground parts were 0~7.09, 0~0.29, 0~4.1, 0~1.1 and 0~49.2 mg/kg, with exceedance rates of 0-2.3%. Aboveground parts showed ranges of 0~1.54, 0~1.02, 0~13, 0~0.96 and 0~43.4 mg/kg, with exceedance rates of 0-8.8%. Animal-derived decoction pieces showed ranges of 0.07~27.18, 0~1, 0~55, 0~4.11 and 0.23~43.9 mg/kg, with exceedance rates of 6.7-41.3%. Principal component and cluster analyses indicated distinct contamination sources between animal-derived and plant-derived materials. The pollution index showed that animal-derived materials required special attention. Among plant-derived materials, <i>Notoginseng Radix et Rhizoma</i>, and <i>Artemisiae Argyi Folium</i> were also of concern. Health risk assessment indicated low non-carcinogenic risks across all categories (<i>HI</i> < 1), and uncertainty analysis showed a 0% probability of <i>HI</i> > 1. The 95th percentile carcinogenic risk for all categories was <1 × 10<sup>-4</sup>. Sensitivity analysis identified metal concentrations and daily intake as key uncertainty contributors. The findings underscore distinct contamination patterns between material types, highlighting the need for targeted control strategies, including strengthened source management and standardized dosing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pan2025potentially,
  author = {Jie Pan and Di Huang and Xue Ma and Di Zhu and Yueliang Lu and Chunhua Liu and Lin Zheng and Yongjun Li and Jia Sun},
  title = {{Potentially Toxic Elements Accumulation and Health Risk Evaluation in Different Parts of Traditional Chinese Medicinal Materials}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics14010040},
}
Figure