Potential False-Positive and False-Negative Results for COVID-19 IgG/IgM Antibody Testing After Heat-Inactivation

Jie Lin, Wei Dai, Weiwei Li, Li Xiao, Tao Luo, Yanju Guo, Yang Yang, Ying Han, Peiran Zhu, Qiuyue Wu, Bangshun He, Jian Wu, Xinyi XiaFrontiers in Medicine 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Objectives: With the worldwide spread of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), various antibody detection kits have been developed to test for SARS-CoV-2- specific IgG, IgM, and total antibody. However, the use of different testing methods under various heat-inactivation conditions might affect the COVID-19 detection results. Methods: Seven different antibody detection kits produced by four manufacturers for detection of SARS-CoV-2 IgG, IgM, and total antibody were tested at Wuhan Huoshenshan Hospital, China. Most of the kits used the indirect immunity, capture, and double-antigen sandwich methods. The effects of various heat-inactivation conditions on SARS-CoV-2-specific IgG, IgM, and total antibody detection were analyzed for the different test methods. Results: Using the indirect immunity method, values for SARS-CoV-2 IgG antibody significantly increased and those for IgM antibody decreased with increasing temperature of heat-inactivation using indirect immunity method. However, values for SARS-CoV-2 IgM and total antibody showed no change when the capture and double-antigen sandwich methods were used. The changes in IgG and IgM antibody values with the indirect immunity method indicated that heat-inactivation could affect COVID-19 detection results obtained using this method. In particular, 18 (22.2%) SARS-CoV-2 IgM positive samples were detected as negative with heat-inactivation at 65°C for 30 min, and one (25%) IgG negative sample was detected as positive after heat-inactivation at 56°C for 60 min and 60°C for 30 min. Conclusions: Heat-inactivation could increase SARS-CoV-2 IgG antibody values, and decrease IgM antibody values, causing potential false-positive or false-negative results for COVID-19 antibody detection using the indirect immunity method. Thus, before conducting antibody testing, the testing platforms should be evaluated in accordance with the relevant requirements to ensure accurate COVID-19 detection results.

Introduction

During the COVID-19 pandemic, laboratory safety was paramount. To protect laboratory personnel from highly infectious SARS-CoV-2, the Chinese Association of Laboratory Medicine recommended heat-inactivating serum samples—typically at 56°C for 30 minutes—before performing serological tests. However, antibodies (IgG and IgM) are proteins sensitive to thermal stress. This study investigates whether standard heat-inactivation protocols interfere with the accuracy of various commercial antibody detection kits, potentially leading to diagnostic errors.

Methodology and Assay Architectures

Researchers evaluated seven antibody detection kits from four manufacturers (A, B, C, and D) using clinical serum samples from patients at Wuhan Huoshenshan Hospital. The study focused on three primary assay architectures:

  1. Indirect Immunity Method: Utilizes a bead-bound antigen to capture target antibodies, which are then detected by a labeled secondary antibody.
  2. Capture Method: Employs anti-human IgM on a bead to capture all IgM in the sample, followed by a labeled antigen to identify specific SARS-CoV-2 IgM.
  3. Double-Antigen Sandwich Method: Uses two antigens (one bead-bound, one labeled) to "sandwich" the target antibody.
Schematic representation of the three antibody detection methods: Indirect immunity, Double-antigen sandwich, and Capture methods.

Serum samples were tested under a control condition (no heat) and various heat-inactivation protocols: 56°C (for 30, 45, and 60 mins), 60°C (30 mins), and 65°C (30 mins). Measurements were performed using Chemiluminescence Microparticle Immunoassay (CMIA) and Up-converting Phosphor Technology (UPT).

Key Findings: Architecture is Destiny

The study revealed that the impact of heat-inactivation is highly dependent on the assay's underlying architecture.

The Vulnerability of the Indirect Immunity Method

The indirect immunity method (Manufacturer A) showed significant susceptibility to heat interference.

  • IgG "Aggregation" Paradox: Measured IgG values unexpectedly increased with heat. For instance, average IgG values rose from 68.46 AU/mL (control) to over 160 AU/mL after heating at 56°C. The authors hypothesize that thermal polymerization (aggregation) of IgG molecules at higher temperatures may expose additional binding sites or increase non-specific binding, leading to false signal inflation.
  • IgM Fragility: IgM is a large, complex pentameric molecule. Heat treatment likely denatures its delicate structure, preventing effective binding to test antigens. This resulted in a significant drop in signal as temperature increased.

Stability of Other Methods

In contrast, kits utilizing the capture method or the double-antigen sandwich method (Manufacturers C and D) remained remarkably stable. No significant changes in antibody values were observed across all tested heat conditions, suggesting these architectures are more robust for use with heat-inactivated samples.

Clinical Impact: False Positives and Negatives

The distortion of results in the indirect method has serious clinical implications:

  • False Positives: In one cohort, an IgG-negative sample was incorrectly identified as positive after heating at 56°C for 60 minutes.
  • False Negatives: The effect on IgM was more pronounced. Approximately 22.2% (18/81) of IgM-positive samples were detected as negative after heat-inactivation at 65°C for 30 minutes.

Conclusion

While heat-inactivation is a vital safety measure, it can compromise diagnostic accuracy depending on the testing platform used. Specifically, the indirect immunity method is prone to producing false-positive IgG and false-negative IgM results due to protein aggregation and denaturation. Clinical laboratories must evaluate their specific testing platforms and validate inactivation protocols to ensure that biosecurity measures do not undermine the reliability of COVID-19 antibody detection.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Objectives:</b> With the worldwide spread of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), various antibody detection kits have been developed to test for SARS-CoV-2- specific IgG, IgM, and total antibody. However, the use of different testing methods under various heat-inactivation conditions might affect the COVID-19 detection results. <b>Methods:</b> Seven different antibody detection kits produced by four manufacturers for detection of SARS-CoV-2 IgG, IgM, and total antibody were tested at Wuhan Huoshenshan Hospital, China. Most of the kits used the indirect immunity, capture, and double-antigen sandwich methods. The effects of various heat-inactivation conditions on SARS-CoV-2-specific IgG, IgM, and total antibody detection were analyzed for the different test methods. <b>Results:</b> Using the indirect immunity method, values for SARS-CoV-2 IgG antibody significantly increased and those for IgM antibody decreased with increasing temperature of heat-inactivation using indirect immunity method. However, values for SARS-CoV-2 IgM and total antibody showed no change when the capture and double-antigen sandwich methods were used. The changes in IgG and IgM antibody values with the indirect immunity method indicated that heat-inactivation could affect COVID-19 detection results obtained using this method. In particular, 18 (22.2%) SARS-CoV-2 IgM positive samples were detected as negative with heat-inactivation at 65°C for 30 min, and one (25%) IgG negative sample was detected as positive after heat-inactivation at 56°C for 60 min and 60°C for 30 min. <b>Conclusions:</b> Heat-inactivation could increase SARS-CoV-2 IgG antibody values, and decrease IgM antibody values, causing potential false-positive or false-negative results for COVID-19 antibody detection using the indirect immunity method. Thus, before conducting antibody testing, the testing platforms should be evaluated in accordance with the relevant requirements to ensure accurate COVID-19 detection results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lin2021potential,
  author = {Jie Lin and Wei Dai and Weiwei Li and Li Xiao and Tao Luo and Yanju Guo and Yang Yang and Ying Han and Peiran Zhu and Qiuyue Wu and Bangshun He and Jian Wu and Xinyi Xia},
  title = {{Potential False-Positive and False-Negative Results for COVID-19 IgG/IgM Antibody Testing After Heat-Inactivation}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2020.589080},
}
Figure