Posture control characteristics of different age groups in China based on Bertec® balance advantage CDP/IVR—a cross-sectional study

Yaqi He, Pei Zhang, Qing Li, Zhengwu Peng, Jinpeng Gao, Yang Liu, Yang Fan, Ye Tian, Xianglin Lv, Jinghua QianFrontiers in Neurology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study establishes the first normative dataset for postural control in Chinese adults using advanced dynamic posturography. It reveals significant age-related declines in balance, particularly in integrating visual and vestibular information for older adults, highlighting the need for culturally specific clinical benchmarks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining balance, or postural control, is a complex motor function crucial for everyday activities and preventing falls, especially as we age. It relies on the seamless integration of sensory information from our visual, vestibular (inner ear), and somatosensory (touch, proprioception) systems. While research has extensively documented age-related declines in postural control in Western populations, there's a significant gap in understanding these changes within diverse cultural contexts like China. Differences in lifestyle, physical activity, and even cultural attitudes towards aging and fall prevention could influence how postural control degrades over time. Without population-specific normative data, clinicians risk misinterpreting balance assessments, potentially leading to inadequate fall risk evaluations and interventions for Chinese adults. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a normative dataset for Chinese adults and exploring cross-cultural differences.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study involving 48 healthy Chinese adults stratified into four age decades (18-35, 36-45, 46-60, and 61-75 years). Participants underwent three laboratory visits. The first two were for screening and familiarization with the testing procedures to minimize learning effects. The third visit involved formal testing using the Bertec® Balance Advantage CDP/IVR system. Two key tests were administered:

  • Sensory Organization Test (SOT): This test assesses how well individuals integrate sensory information under various conditions. Participants stand on a force platform while the visual surround and/or the platform itself move. Six different conditions are tested, ranging from stable visual and platform conditions to challenging scenarios where visual or somatosensory input is altered or removed. Key outcome measures include the Composite Score (CS), which represents overall balance, and sensory ratio scores (Visual, Vestibular, Somatosensory, and Preference) that quantify reliance on each sensory system.
  • Rhythmic Weight Shift Test (RWS): This test evaluates the ability to control and direct body sway at different speeds and directions. Participants are instructed to rhythmically shift their weight, and measures like Directional Control (DCL) and Movement Velocity (MVL) are recorded.

Statistical analysis involved one-way ANOVA with post-hoc tests to compare age groups and Spearman's rank correlation to assess the relationship between age and postural control measures. Exploratory comparisons with existing Danish normative data were also performed using one-sample t-tests.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 48 healthy Chinese adults. For comparative analysis, the researchers referenced published normative data from a Danish population (Eriksen & Hougaard, 2023). This comparative approach aims to highlight potential cross-cultural differences in postural control trajectories.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Age is a significant factor: The study unequivocally demonstrates that postural control deteriorates with age in the Chinese population. This is not a subtle change but a significant decline, particularly in more challenging balance tasks.
  • The "over 45" tipping point: A critical finding is that individuals over 45 years old show a diminished capacity to integrate visual and vestibular information. This suggests a potential shift in balance strategies and increased vulnerability as people enter middle age.
  • Sensory integration is key: The SOT results highlight that while basic balance (SOT 1-3) might be relatively preserved, more complex conditions requiring integration of multiple senses (SOT 4-6) reveal the most pronounced age-related declines. This points to the importance of how the brain processes and prioritizes sensory input.
  • Visual and vestibular systems are vulnerable: Declines were specifically noted in the Visual (VIS) and Vestibular (VEST) sensory ratio scores, indicating that the ability to effectively use these senses for balance is compromised with age.
  • Culturally specific benchmarks are essential: The comparison with Danish data suggests that Chinese adults, particularly younger ones, may exhibit different balance performance. This underscores the risk of applying Western norms to other populations and the need for culturally tailored assessments.

Key Results

  • Composite Score (CS) decline: A significant negative correlation was found between age and the Composite Score (CS) (rs = -0.532, p < 0.001).
  • Specific SOT condition declines: Age-related declines were particularly pronounced in SOT conditions 4, 5, and 6, which challenge visual and vestibular integration.
  • Sensory ratio score reductions: Significant age-related declines were observed in Visual (VIS) and Vestibular (VEST) scores.
  • RWS directional control impairment: Poorer directional control in both mediolateral and anteroposterior directions was observed in older age groups (C and D) during the RWS test.
  • Younger Chinese adults outperform older groups: Post-hoc analyses revealed that younger participants (Groups A and B) consistently demonstrated superior postural stability compared to middle-aged and older participants (Groups C and D). For example, Group A had significantly higher CS scores than Group C and D.
  • Cross-cultural differences: Exploratory comparisons indicated that younger Chinese adults (Groups A and B) had significantly higher SOT scores than their Danish counterparts, potentially due to protocol differences and lifestyle factors.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample size and age range: The study had a modest sample size (N=48), and the upper age limit of 72 years restricts generalizability to the oldest-old population.
  • Recruitment bias: Non-random recruitment might introduce selection bias.
  • Limited health screening: Detailed physical activity profiles and stricter health screening were not implemented, which could influence results.
  • Acclimatization for older adults: The acclimatization protocol might have been insufficient for older adults, potentially underestimating age-related differences.

Future work should focus on larger, more diverse cohorts, including older age groups, and incorporate more detailed lifestyle and health data. Standardizing acclimatization procedures and further investigating the impact of cultural factors on postural control are also crucial next steps. The established normative data provides a vital foundation for developing culturally sensitive fall prevention strategies for the Chinese population.

Summary updated

Abstract

Postural control demonstrated a significant age-related decline in this cohort. Notably, individuals over 45 years exhibited a diminished capacity to integrate visual and vestibular information for complex balance tasks and visually guided motor control. This study provides essential normative data for clinical assessment in the Chinese population and underscores the need for population-specific benchmarks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2025posture,
  author = {Yaqi He and Pei Zhang and Qing Li and Zhengwu Peng and Jinpeng Gao and Yang Liu and Yang Fan and Ye Tian and Xianglin Lv and Jinghua Qian},
  title = {{Posture control characteristics of different age groups in China based on Bertec® balance advantage CDP/IVR—a cross-sectional study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2025.1658938},
}
Figure