Abstract
This study investigated the impact of surgical intervention on cognitive functions in 58 patients with benign intracranial lesions, including meningiomas, pituitary adenomas, and vascular malformations. Using an extensive neuropsychological battery, patients were assessed preoperatively ($t_0$), immediately post-surgery ($t_1$), and at a three-month follow-up ($t_2$). Results indicated that the majority of patients maintained or improved their cognitive performance in attention, memory, and executive functions at both postoperative time points. Factors such as age and tumor volume did not significantly influence cognitive outcomes in meningioma patients. These findings suggest that surgery for benign lesions does not typically result in cognitive deterioration.
Introduction
A primary concern for patients undergoing brain surgery is the risk of permanent cognitive impairment. While the cognitive effects of surgery for malignant neuroepithelial tumors (like gliomas) are well-documented, there is a lack of detailed longitudinal data regarding benign intracranial lesions. These lesions, though often slow-growing, can compress critical brain structures. This study addresses whether the surgical procedure itself causes more cognitive harm than the benefit derived from lesion removal.
Methods
The researchers conducted a prospective single-center study involving 58 patients (mean age 51.6 years). The cohort included various pathologies, primarily meningiomas (n=23), pituitary adenomas (n=8), and vascular lesions (n=9).
Cognitive assessment involved:
- Screening: Mini-Mental Status Examination (MMSE).
- Neuropsychological Battery: Specialized tests for attention (TAP), memory (WMS, VLMT, Rey-Osterrieth), and executive functions (TMT-B, Stroop, RWT).
- Timeline: Assessments occurred preoperatively ($t_0$), immediately post-surgery ($t_1$, mean 7.6 days), and at follow-up ($t_2$, mean 99.5 days).
- Controls: Mood (BDI-II) and pain (HDI) were monitored to ensure cognitive results were independent of emotional state or physical discomfort.
Results
The study found high rates of cognitive stability or improvement following surgery. Immediately post-surgery ($t_1$), more than 50% of patients showed stable or improved conditions in 12 out of 14 attention subtests, 11 out of 13 memory subtests, and 6 out of 9 executive function subtests.
By the three-month follow-up ($t_2$), the results were even more encouraging, with 100% of memory subtests (13/13) and executive function subtests (9/9) showing stability or improvement in the majority of the cohort. Basic cognitive screening (MMSE) scores remained stable, with a median score of 29.0 both pre- and postoperatively.
Discussion
The data suggests that the "surgical fog" often feared by patients is minimal and transient for benign lesions. Even within a week of surgery, cognitive scores remained largely stable, indicating that surgical trauma and anesthesia do not necessarily lead to lasting deficits in this population.
In a subgroup analysis of meningioma patients, the researchers found that traditional risk factors—such as age, tumor volume, and preoperative Karnofsky Performance Status (KPS)—did not significantly predict cognitive deterioration. This suggests that the potential for cognitive recovery or maintenance is high regardless of these baseline factors.
However, the study faced limitations, most notably a high dropout rate at the three-month follow-up (only 24 of 58 patients returned). This attrition bias could potentially skew results toward more positive outcomes if patients experiencing cognitive difficulties were less likely to return for testing.
Conclusion
In contrast to malignant brain tumors, surgery for benign intracranial lesions appears to be cognitively safe. The majority of patients experience stable or improved cognitive function across attention, memory, and executive domains. While further multi-center studies with higher patient retention are needed, these results provide significant reassurance to patients facing surgery for non-malignant brain lesions.
Summary updated