Post-treatment Follow-up, Imaging, and Outcome Scores: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meeting on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle

Pim A. D. van Dijk, Christopher D. Murawski, Kenneth J. Hunt, Carol L. Andrews, Umile Giuseppe Longo, Graham McCollum, Helene Simpson, Carolyn M. Sofka, Ichiro Yoshimura, Jón Karlsson, Jakob Ackermann, Samuel B. Adams, Chayanin Angthong, Jorge Batista, O Baur, Steve Bayer, Christoph Becher, Gregory C. Berlet, Lorraine A. T. Boakye, Alexandra J. Brown, Roberto Buda, James Calder, Gian Luigi Canata, Dominic S. Carreira, Thomas O. Clanton, Jari Dahmen, Pieter D’Hooghe, Christopher W. DiGiovanni, Malcolm E. Dombrowski, Mark C. Drakos, Richard D. Ferkel, Paulo N. F. Ferrao, Lisa A. Fortier, Mark Glazebrook, Eric Giza, Mohamed Gomaa, Simon Görtz, Amgad M. Haleem, Kamran S. Hamid, László Hangody, Charles P. Hannon, Daniël Haverkamp, Jay Hertel, Beat Hintermann, MaCalus V. Hogan, Eoghan T. Hurley, Stephen R. Kearns, John G. Kennedy, Gino M. M. J. Kerkhoffs, Hak Jun Kim, Siu Wah Kong, Sameh A. Labib, Kaj T. A. Lambers, Jin Woo Lee, Keun Bae Lee, Jeffrey S. Ling, Alberto Marangon, Adam Mitchell, Peter N. Mittwede, Stefan Nehrer, Philipp Niemeyer, James A. Nunley, Martin O’Malley, David O. Osei-Hwedieh, Jochen Paul, Christopher J. Pearce, Hélder Pereira, Adam Popchak, Marcelo Pires Prado, Steven M. Raikin, Mikel L. Reilingh, Benjamin B. Rothrauff, Lew C. Schon, Yoshiharu Shimozono, Niall A. Smyth, Pietro Spennacchio, James W. Stone, Martin Sullivan, Masato Takao, Yasuhito Tanaka, David B. Thordarson, Rocky S. Tuan, Víctor Valderrábano, Christiaan J. A. van Bergen, C. Niek van Dijk, Francesca Vannini, Tanawat Vaseenon, Markus Walther, Martin Wiewiorski, Xiangyang Xu, Youichi Yasui, Hua Yinghui, Alastair Younger, Zijun ZhangFoot 2018 · DOI

Abstract

This international consensus derived from leaders in the field will assist clinicians with post-treatment follow-up, imaging, and outcome scores after management of a cartilage injury of the ankle in the general population. Moreover, healing, rehabilitation, and final outcomes can be optimized for the individual patient.

Introduction: The Need for Standardization in Ankle Cartilage Repair

Cartilage injuries in the ankle, specifically osteochondral lesions (OCLs), present significant management challenges for orthopedic surgeons. While surgical techniques have advanced, the post-operative phase has historically lacked a "gold standard" protocol. This inconsistency has led to two primary difficulties: a reliance on low-quality evidence (predominantly Level IV case series) and a fragmented landscape of outcome reporting. Over the last decade, researchers have utilized at least 25 different types of patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs), making it nearly impossible to compare the efficacy of different treatments across clinical studies. This paper summarizes the findings of the International Consensus Meeting on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle, providing a standardized framework for follow-up, imaging, and outcome assessment.

Methodology: The Delphi Process and Evidence Grading

To address these gaps, a panel of 75 international experts from 25 countries across six continents was convened. The group utilized the Delphi method—a structured, multi-round survey process designed to reach a reliable consensus. The experts were divided into 11 working groups to draft statements based on comprehensive literature reviews. Each statement was assigned a grade based on the strength of the supporting evidence, ranging from high-level meta-analyses to expert opinion.

Hierarchy of evidence levels used to grade the consensus statements.

The final consensus was reached during an in-person meeting in Pittsburgh, where "strong consensus" was defined as 75% to 99% agreement, and "unanimous" required 100% agreement. Most recommendations currently reside at Level C to E evidence, reflecting the urgent need for higher-quality prospective research in the field.

Key Clinical Insights: Redefining Success and the MRI "Lag"

One of the most significant takeaways from the consensus is the disconnect between clinical symptoms and imaging results. The panel highlighted the "MRI lag," noting that subchondral bone marrow edema (swelling within the bone) can persist on scans for up to two years post-surgery, even in patients who are asymptomatic and progressing well. Consequently, the group emphasized that success should not be measured by imaging alone but through five distinct pillars:

  1. Absence of pain
  2. Patient satisfaction
  3. Return to work
  4. Return to sports at pre-injury levels
  5. Measurable improvement in PROMs

Additionally, the panel identified "red flag" scenarios—such as lesions larger than 15mm or those located on the tibial plafond—that necessitate more intensive monitoring and longer follow-up periods due to a higher risk of joint degeneration.

Consensus Recommendations for Post-Operative Management

The working group successfully established 12 "strong consensus" statements to guide clinical practice. Key recommendations include:

  • Standardized Timing: Outcome data should be collected at 3, 6, 12, and 24 months post-operatively, followed by annual assessments to track long-term joint health.
  • Physical Examination: Post-operative evaluations must systematically document weight-bearing status, range of motion, joint effusion, and localized tenderness.
  • Imaging Protocols: Routine X-rays are essential when bone grafting or osteotomies are performed. However, advanced imaging like MRI should be reserved for symptomatic patients rather than used as a routine screening tool, given the potential for misleading findings like persistent asymptomatic edema.
  • Outcome Scores: The group recommends the use of validated scoring systems to ensure data can be compared globally.
The American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score is a primary recommended outcome measure.

While the AOFAS score remains a standard, the panel acknowledged that current PROMs often lack the specificity required for ankle cartilage repair, particularly regarding age and sex differences.

Limitations and Future Directions

The primary limitation of these guidelines is the current state of orthopedic literature; many recommendations are based on Level V evidence (expert opinion). To evolve the field, the consensus calls for the establishment of international databases utilizing these standardized follow-up intervals. Future work must focus on validating ankle-specific PROMs and refining our understanding of post-operative MRI findings to prevent the over-treatment of asymptomatic patients. By adopting these consensus statements, the global orthopedic community can begin to generate the high-level evidence necessary to optimize patient recovery.

Summary updated

Abstract

This international consensus derived from leaders in the field will assist clinicians with post-treatment follow-up, imaging, and outcome scores after management of a cartilage injury of the ankle in the general population. Moreover, healing, rehabilitation, and final outcomes can be optimized for the individual patient.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dijk2018post,
  author = {Pim A. D. van Dijk and Christopher D. Murawski and Kenneth J. Hunt and Carol L. Andrews and Umile Giuseppe Longo and Graham McCollum and Helene Simpson and Carolyn M. Sofka and Ichiro Yoshimura and Jón Karlsson and Jakob Ackermann and Samuel B. Adams and Chayanin Angthong and Jorge Batista and O Baur and Steve Bayer and Christoph Becher and Gregory C. Berlet and Lorraine A. T. Boakye and Alexandra J. Brown and Roberto Buda and James Calder and Gian Luigi Canata and Dominic S. Carreira and Thomas O. Clanton and Jari Dahmen and Pieter D’Hooghe and Christopher W. DiGiovanni and Malcolm E. Dombrowski and Mark C. Drakos and Richard D. Ferkel and Paulo N. F. Ferrao and Lisa A. Fortier and Mark Glazebrook and Eric Giza and Mohamed Gomaa and Simon Görtz and Amgad M. Haleem and Kamran S. Hamid and László Hangody and Charles P. Hannon and Daniël Haverkamp and Jay Hertel and Beat Hintermann and MaCalus V. Hogan and Eoghan T. Hurley and Stephen R. Kearns and John G. Kennedy and Gino M. M. J. Kerkhoffs and Hak Jun Kim and Siu Wah Kong and Sameh A. Labib and Kaj T. A. Lambers and Jin Woo Lee and Keun Bae Lee and Jeffrey S. Ling and Alberto Marangon and Adam Mitchell and Peter N. Mittwede and Stefan Nehrer and Philipp Niemeyer and James A. Nunley and Martin O’Malley and David O. Osei-Hwedieh and Jochen Paul and Christopher J. Pearce and Hélder Pereira and Adam Popchak and Marcelo Pires Prado and Steven M. Raikin and Mikel L. Reilingh and Benjamin B. Rothrauff and Lew C. Schon and Yoshiharu Shimozono and Niall A. Smyth and Pietro Spennacchio and James W. Stone and Martin Sullivan and Masato Takao and Yasuhito Tanaka and David B. Thordarson and Rocky S. Tuan and Víctor Valderrábano and Christiaan J. A. van Bergen and C. Niek van Dijk and Francesca Vannini and Tanawat Vaseenon and Markus Walther and Martin Wiewiorski and Xiangyang Xu and Youichi Yasui and Hua Yinghui and Alastair Younger and Zijun Zhang},
  title = {{Post-treatment Follow-up, Imaging, and Outcome Scores: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meeting on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle}},
  booktitle = {Foot},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1177/1071100718781861},
}
Figure