Post-training Load-Related Changes of Auditory Working Memory – An EEG Study

Helene Gudi-Mindermann, Johanna M. Rimmele, Patrick Bruns, Niels A Kloosterman, Tobias H. Donner, Andreas K. Engel, Brigitte RöderFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Working memory (WM) capacity is highly susceptible to training, yet the neural mechanisms underlying increased performance under high-load conditions remain unclear. This study investigated whether post-training efficiency in WM modulates neural processing during demanding tasks. Using electroencephalography (EEG) on 39 healthy adults, we compared source-space spectral power during low and high-load auditory WM tasks. Participants were divided into three groups: modality-specific auditory WM training, modality-irrelevant tactile WM training, and an active control. Results showed that auditory training significantly improved behavioral performance. EEG analysis revealed general load effects across all groups in theta, alpha, and beta bands. Notably, the auditory training group exhibited reduced beta-band power in the right medial temporal lobe during high-load conditions, suggesting more efficient maintenance of task-relevant stimuli through a "push-pull" mechanism of neural resource allocation.

Introduction

Working memory—the ability to temporarily hold and manipulate information—is a fundamental cognitive process. While training can expand WM capacity, the specific neural adaptations that facilitate this expansion are not fully understood. This study, published in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, aimed to distinguish between general neural responses to increased cognitive load and specific plasticity induced by training. A key challenge in such research is the subjectivity of "difficulty"; to address this, the researchers employed an adaptive $n$-back task to test each participant at their individual capacity limit.

Methods

The study recruited 39 healthy adults, categorized into three experimental groups:

  1. Auditory Training (AG): Modality-specific training using voice stimuli.
  2. Tactile Training (TG): Modality-irrelevant training using tactile stimulators.
  3. Active Control (CG): A non-adaptive, low-demand 1-back task.
Overview of the study protocol across pre-test, training, and post-test phases.

Participants performed an auditory $n$-back task requiring them to identify if a current speaker's voice matched one heard $n$ trials ago. Stimuli consisted of the pseudo-word "befa" recorded by ten different speakers.

Experimental trial structure and timing.

Neural activity was recorded using 94-channel EEG. The researchers utilized eLoreta source reconstruction to map spectral power (Theta, Alpha, Beta, and Gamma bands) to specific 3D brain regions, focusing on the maintenance phase of the WM task.

Key Insights and Results

Behavioral Performance

The Auditory Training group demonstrated superior behavioral gains, reaching significantly higher $n$-levels (mean $n \approx 11$) compared to the control group (mean $n \approx 7$). This suggests that WM plasticity is highly modality-specific.

General Load Signatures

Regardless of training, increased task difficulty triggered consistent neural signatures:

  • Frontal Theta Increase: Reflecting heightened top-down executive control.
  • Parietal/Central Decrease in Theta, Alpha, and Beta: Associated with the suppression of the Default Mode Network (DMN), effectively "quieting" internal distractions to focus on the task.

Training-Induced Efficiency

The most significant finding was the "Efficiency Hypothesis." During high-load conditions, the Auditory Training group showed reduced beta-band power in the right medial temporal lobe—a region specialized for voice processing. While increased effort typically correlates with increased activity, the trained group achieved better performance with less localized beta activity, indicating more efficient neural representation of task-relevant stimuli.

Discussion and Limitations

The study highlights a "push-pull" mechanism in WM maintenance: strengthening task-relevant focus while suppressing task-irrelevant background activity. However, some limitations persist. The primary group-specific interaction for beta power was initially a statistical trend ($p = 0.069$) before post-hoc confirmation, suggesting a need for larger sample sizes. Additionally, the use of blindfolds (to control for visual input) may limit the generalizability of these findings to sighted, eyes-open environments. Future research should explore how these modality-specific efficiency gains might be leveraged to improve general cognitive transfer.

Summary updated

Abstract

Working memory (WM) refers to the temporary retention and manipulation of information, and its capacity is highly susceptible to training. Yet, the neural mechanisms that allow for increased performance under demanding conditions are not fully understood. We expected that post-training efficiency in WM performance modulates neural processing during high load tasks. We tested this hypothesis, using electroencephalography (EEG) (<i>N</i> = 39), by comparing source space spectral power of healthy adults performing low and high load auditory WM tasks. Prior to the assessment, participants either underwent a modality-specific <i>auditory</i> WM training, or a modality-irrelevant <i>tactile</i> WM training, or were not trained (active control). After a modality-specific training participants showed higher behavioral performance, compared to the control. EEG data analysis revealed general effects of WM load, across all training groups, in the theta-, alpha-, and beta-frequency bands. With increased load theta-band power increased over frontal, and decreased over parietal areas. Centro-parietal alpha-band power and central beta-band power decreased with load. Interestingly, in the high load condition a tendency toward reduced beta-band power in the right medial temporal lobe was observed in the modality-specific WM training group compared to the modality-irrelevant and active control groups. Our finding that WM processing during the high load condition changed after modality-specific WM training, showing reduced beta-band activity in voice-selective regions, possibly indicates a more efficient maintenance of task-relevant stimuli. The general load effects suggest that WM performance at high load demands involves complementary mechanisms, combining a strengthening of task-relevant and a suppression of task-irrelevant processing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gudimindermann2020post,
  author = {Helene Gudi-Mindermann and Johanna M. Rimmele and Patrick Bruns and Niels A Kloosterman and Tobias H. Donner and Andreas K. Engel and Brigitte Röder},
  title = {{Post-training Load-Related Changes of Auditory Working Memory – An EEG Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2020.00072},
}
Figure