Abstract
Traditional scholarship on D.H. Lawrence has long focused on his pursuit of "star-equilibrium"—an ideal harmony between the male and female principles. However, a closer examination of The Rainbow reveals a profound post-modern tendency characterized by uncertainty and ambiguity. This paper argues that Lawrence’s narrative trajectory, moving from the relative stability of the first generation to the total fragmentation of the third, mirrors the shift from modernist search for meaning to post-modern indeterminacy. By analyzing the "paradoxical contradiction" between Lawrence’s phallus worship and his feminism, we can see how the novel embraces the "unknown" as a structural and philosophical necessity.
Introduction: Beyond the Search for Harmony
D.H. Lawrence is often categorized as a modernist deeply concerned with the restoration of vital, organic connections between individuals and the cosmos. His work is frequently read as a manifesto for sexual liberation and gender balance. However, as Xinyu Yang explores in "Post-modern Tendency: The Uncertainty in The Rainbow," the novel often betrays these stated goals. Instead of achieving a final, stable harmony, the text descends into a state of "factual imbalance." This uncertainty is not a narrative flaw but a precursor to post-modern thought, where fixed truths and stable identities are replaced by the "unforeseen" and the "ambiguous."
The Paradox of Phallus and Feminism
A central tension in Lawrence’s work is the conflict between his theoretical "phallus worship"—the advocacy for male spiritual leadership—and the actual strength of his female characters. In The Rainbow, Lawrence’s female protagonists often possess a vitality and independence that dwarfs their male counterparts. This creates a "paradoxical contradiction." While Lawrence’s essays might preach male authority, his narrative practice grants Ursula Brangwen a level of autonomy that leaves her male suitors, like Anton Skrebensky, spiritually and emotionally bankrupt. This internal contradiction reveals Lawrence’s own uncertainty regarding the "ideal" gender hierarchy, a hallmark of the post-modern refusal to settle on a single, authoritative perspective.
Generational Fragmentation
The structure of The Rainbow follows three generations of the Brangwen family, and this progression serves as a map of increasing uncertainty.
- Tom and Lydia: The first generation achieves a form of "wholeness." Though they remain somewhat mysterious to one another, they find a functional balance within the traditional rhythms of the Marsh Farm.
- Will and Anna: In the second generation, the balance begins to tilt. Anna’s "female superiority" emerges as she asserts her domestic and maternal power, leaving Will Brangwen in a state of "mechanical" subservience. The "star-equilibrium" is replaced by a struggle for dominance.
- Ursula and Anton: By the third generation, the search for harmony fails completely. Ursula, the "new woman," seeks a spiritual and intellectual fulfillment that Anton Skrebensky cannot provide. Anton is depicted as an "empty shell," a man of the "old civilization" who lacks a true, inner self. Their relationship ends not in union, but in "separation and isolation." This failure is further emphasized by Ursula’s brief relationship with Winifred Inger, which Lawrence depicts as a source of "spiritual shame," reinforcing the theme of the unresolved search.
The "Unknown" as a Post-modern Motif
Yang highlights Lawrence’s persistent use of the word "unknown." In a modernist context, the unknown is often a frontier to be explored and conquered. In The Rainbow, however, the "unknown" takes on a post-modern quality of "indeterminacy." Characters like Anton Skrebensky are defined by what they lack; he is "uncertain" and "agnostic," representing a void that cannot be filled by traditional marital structures. This embrace of the "unforeseen" suggests that Lawrence recognized the impossibility of returning to a pre-industrial, unified state of being.
Conclusion: The Open Ending
The novel concludes with Ursula’s vision of the rainbow—a symbol of hope and a "new architecture." Yet, this vision is notably solitary. Ursula remains alone, having rejected the unsatisfactory "patterns" of the past. This "open ending" is a quintessential post-modern trait. It leaves the future unresolved and the search for harmony ongoing, acknowledging that the "ideal" may be unfulfillable. Ultimately, The Rainbow is a testament to Lawrence’s "post-modern tendency," where the only certainty is the persistence of uncertainty itself.
Summary updated