Possible roles of phytochemicals with bioactive properties in the prevention of and recovery from COVID-19

Sachiko Koyama, Vonnie D. C. Shields, Thomas Heinbockel, Paule V. Joseph, Poonam Adhikari, Rishemjit Kaur, Ritesh Kumar, Rafieh Alizadeh, Surabhi Bhutani, Orietta Calcinoni, Carla Mucignat‐Caretta, Jingguo Chen, Keiland W Cooper, Subha R. Das, Paloma Rohlfs Domínguez, María Dolors Guárdia, Maria A. Klyuchnikova, Tatiana K. Laktionova, Eri Mori, Zeinab Namjoo, Ha Nguyen, Mehmet Hakan Özdener, Shima Parsa, Ayşe Elif Özdener-Poyraz, Daniel Jan Strub, Farzad Taghizadeh‐Hesary, Rumi Ueha, Vera V. VoznessenskayamedRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

A global survey of over 1,500 participants suggests that a diet rich in vegetables, herbs, spices, and fermented foods is significantly correlated with a lower risk of contracting COVID-19. Furthermore, in countries like India and Japan, high daily intake of these phytochemical-rich foods was associated with a significantly faster recovery time for those who did fall ill.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Throughout the pandemic, researchers observed massive geographical disparities in COVID-19 infection and mortality rates. While government strategies and genetics played a role, scientists began looking at lifestyle factors—specifically diet.

The authors of this study set out to investigate whether "phytochemicals"—bioactive compounds found in plants—could be a hidden variable in how different populations handled the virus. Phytochemicals are known to have anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and even antiviral properties. The core question was: Does the frequency of consuming specific food groups (like green vegetables or fermented drinks) correlate with a person’s likelihood of getting infected or their speed of recovery?

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study using a global online survey developed by the Global Consortium for Chemosensory Research (GCCR).

  • Reach: The survey was translated into 10 languages to capture a diverse international demographic.
  • Data Cleaning: To ensure high-quality data, the team implemented a "100-second rule," discarding responses from anyone who finished the survey too quickly to have actually read the questions. They also excluded participants under 18 or those who didn't disclose their COVID status.
  • Analysis: They used Chi-square tests to compare food consumption patterns across health statuses (Tested Positive, Not Tested but Suspected, and Did Not Get COVID) and utilized Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney U-tests to analyze recovery times.

Datasets

The study relied on a primary dataset generated specifically for this research:

  • The GCCR Phytochemicals Survey: Initially capturing 1,777 participants, the final analyzed dataset included 1,583 eligible participants.
  • Demographics: The data represented a wide range of ethnicities and locations, with significant clusters (over 100 participants each) from India, Iran, Italy, Japan, Russia, and Spain.
  • Benchmarks: While no external training datasets were used, the survey structure was adapted from the National Cancer Institute’s (NCI) validated Diet History Questionnaire (DHQ).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Vegetable Shield": The most striking finding was that people who avoided COVID-19 reported eating leaf vegetables, root vegetables, and fermented foods/beverages daily at a much higher rate than those who contracted the virus.
  • Spices and Recovery: Herbs and spices weren't just for flavor; daily consumption was strongly linked to shorter recovery periods. This supports the hypothesis that compounds like curcumin (from turmeric) or gingerol (from ginger) may interfere with viral replication or dampen the "cytokine storm" associated with severe cases.
  • Cultural Nuance in Recovery: Participants in Japan and India reported significantly shorter recovery times than those in other countries. The authors point to the high daily intake of vegetables and fermented foods (like miso in Japan or various fermented dishes in India) as a likely contributing factor.
  • Smell and Taste Vulnerability: The study reaffirmed that chemosensory dysfunction (loss of smell and taste) remains a primary marker of the virus, appearing significantly more often than "chemesthesis" (the ability to feel the "burn" of a chili or the "cool" of menthol).

Key Results

  • Infection Risk: There was a statistically significant correlation ($P < 0.001$) between daily vegetable/fermented food intake and a "Did Not Get COVID" status.
  • Recovery Speed: In India and Japan, contractors showed faster recovery. For example, the median recovery time in Japan was approximately 8.5 days, compared to 14–15 days in Italy or Russia.
  • Beverage Trends: While tea and coffee were the most consumed daily beverages globally, their link to preventing infection was less clear-cut than that of solid vegetables, though tea drinkers reported slightly milder symptoms.
  • Fermented Foods: This category showed one of the strongest discrepancies in the Chi-square tests ($χ²=62.945, P<0.001$), suggesting that gut health and probiotics might play a massive role in immune resilience against SARS-CoV-2.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors are transparent about several hurdles:

  1. Self-Reporting Bias: All data is based on participant memory and honesty regarding their diet and recovery.
  2. Correlation vs. Causation: People who eat more vegetables might also be more health-conscious in other ways (e.g., better masking, more social distancing), which could confound the results.
  3. Serving Sizes: The survey tracked frequency (daily vs. weekly) but not the exact quantity of food consumed.
  4. Viral Variants: The data was collected over a period where different variants (Original, Delta, Omicron) were dominant, which naturally affects recovery times.

Future Work: The researchers call for controlled experimental studies and animal models to isolate specific phytochemicals (like EGCG from tea or quercetin from fruits) to determine the exact dosage required for clinical efficacy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Purpose There have been large geographical differences in the infection and death rates of COVID-19. Foods and beverages containing high amounts of phytochemicals with bioactive properties were suggested to prevent contracting, to limit the severity of, and to facilitate recovery from COVID-19. The goal of our study was to determine the correlation of the type of foods/beverages people consumed and the risk reduction of contracting COVID-19 and the recovery from COVID-19. Methods We developed an online survey that asked the participants whether they contracted COVID-19, their symptoms, time to recover, and their frequency of eating various types of foods/beverages. The survey was first developed in English and then translated into 10 different languages. Results The participants who did not contract COVID-19 consumed vegetables, herbs/spices, and fermented foods/beverages significantly more than the participants who contracted COVID-19 and those who were not tested but became sick most likely from COVID-19. The geographic location of participants corresponded with the language of the survey, except for the English version, thus, nine out of the 10 language versions represented a country. Among the six countries (India, Iran, Italy, Japan, Russia, Spain) with over one hundred participants, we found that in India and Japan the people who contracted COVID-19 showed significantly shorter recovery time, and greater daily intake of vegetables, herbs/spices, and fermented foods/beverages was associated with faster recovery. Conclusion Our results suggest that phytochemical compounds included in the vegetables may have contributed in not only preventing contraction of COVID-19, but also accelerating their recovery. (249 words; EJN limit is 250 words)
BibTeX
@misc{koyama2024possible,
  author = {Sachiko Koyama and Vonnie D. C. Shields and Thomas Heinbockel and Paule V. Joseph and Poonam Adhikari and Rishemjit Kaur and Ritesh Kumar and Rafieh Alizadeh and Surabhi Bhutani and Orietta Calcinoni and Carla Mucignat‐Caretta and Jingguo Chen and Keiland W Cooper and Subha R. Das and Paloma Rohlfs Domínguez and María Dolors Guárdia and Maria A. Klyuchnikova and Tatiana K. Laktionova and Eri Mori and Zeinab Namjoo and Ha Nguyen and Mehmet Hakan Özdener and Shima Parsa and Ayşe Elif Özdener-Poyraz and Daniel Jan Strub and Farzad Taghizadeh‐Hesary and Rumi Ueha and Vera V. Voznessenskaya},
  title = {{Possible roles of phytochemicals with bioactive properties in the prevention of and recovery from COVID-19}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.01.29.24301882},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure