Abstract
Partial decay widths of the $X(3940)$ are evaluated in the $^3P_0$ quark model, assuming a charmonium scenario for its structure. In the study all model parameters are predetermined by other reactions. The work reveals that it is difficult to accommodate the $X(3940)$ with any $c\bar c$ meson state in the picture of the potential quark model plus the $^3P_0$ quark dynamics.
Introduction
In subatomic physics, "charmonium" refers to a meson composed of a charm quark and a charm antiquark ($c\bar{c}$). While many states in this spectrum are well-understood, the discovery of "XYZ" states in the 2000s by experiments like Belle and BaBar introduced significant challenges to standard classifications. The $X(3940)$ is one such mystery. Observed decaying into $D^*\bar{D}$ but notably absent in $D\bar{D}$ or $\omega J/\psi$ channels, its identity remains a subject of intense theoretical debate. This study investigates whether the $X(3940)$ can be identified with known excited charmonium states by calculating its partial decay widths.
Methodology
The researchers utilized the $^3P_0$ quark model, a non-perturbative framework describing meson decay through the creation of a quark-antiquark pair from the vacuum with quantum numbers $J^{PC} = 0^{++}$. A key strength of this analysis is the use of predetermined model parameters. Rather than adjusting variables to fit the $X(3940)$ data, the authors fixed the wave function size parameters and coupling strength ($\lambda$) using established data from other particles, such as the $\psi(3770)$ and $D$ mesons. This approach ensures that the resulting predictions are rigorous and physically constrained.
Results and Discussion
The primary objective was to match the experimental mass ($3.943$ GeV) and decay width ($\approx 37$ MeV) of the $X(3940) \to D^*\bar{D}$ channel with theoretical candidates. Selection rules immediately rule out several states: the absence of $D\bar{D}$ decay is a critical clue, as certain symmetries prevent specific states from decaying into that channel.
As shown in the data, the popular interpretation of $X(3940)$ as the $3^1S_0$ (the $\eta_c(3S)$) state faces significant discrepancies. The model predicts a decay width of 104 MeV for $3^1S_0$, which is nearly three times larger than the experimental value of $37^{+26}_{-15} \pm 8$ MeV. Conversely, the $2^1P_1$ state (also known as the $h_c(2P)$) emerges as a strong candidate with a predicted width of 38.5 MeV, falling well within the experimental error bars. The $2^3P_1$ state remains a secondary possibility with a predicted width of 72.7 MeV.
Conclusion
While the $2^1P_1$ charmonium state provides a compelling match for the observed decay width of the $X(3940)$, the authors note that accommodating the particle perfectly within the standard potential quark model remains challenging. The use of simplified Gaussian wave functions may limit the precision of these results. Future investigations employing more complex potentials or Lattice QCD calculations will be essential to confirm the $2^1P_1$ assignment and further clarify the nature of the $X(3940)$ and related enhancements like the $X(3900)$.
Summary updated