Possible capture of keV sterile neutrino dark matter on radioactive β-decaying nuclei

Yufeng Li, Zhi‐zhong XingPhysics 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel method for directly detecting keV-scale sterile neutrinos, a leading candidate for warm dark matter, by observing their capture on radioactive nuclei. The authors demonstrate that the unique imprint of this capture on the electron energy spectrum could be distinguishable from background beta decays, offering a promising, albeit challenging, experimental avenue.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nature of dark matter remains one of the most significant mysteries in physics. While cold dark matter candidates are well-studied, there's a compelling case for warm dark matter (WDM) to address certain cosmological puzzles, such as the "small-scale crisis" in structure formation. keV-scale sterile neutrinos are prime candidates for WDM due to their potential mass range and production mechanisms in the early universe. However, directly detecting these elusive particles has been a major challenge. This paper tackles the problem of how to find experimental signatures of these keV sterile neutrinos, specifically focusing on their potential interaction with ordinary matter through a process that leaves a detectable trace.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in analyzing the unique signature produced when a keV sterile neutrino ($v_4$) is captured by a radioactive nucleus undergoing beta decay. The authors consider the process $v_4 + N \rightarrow N' + e^-$, where $N$ is a radioactive nucleus and $N'$ is the daughter nucleus. The key idea is that the sterile neutrino component of the electron neutrino ($v_e$) can participate in this capture, leading to the emission of an electron with a specific kinetic energy. This energy is determined by the Q-value of the beta decay ($Q_\beta$) and the mass of the sterile neutrino ($m_4$), resulting in a characteristic energy peak.

The authors develop a self-consistent parametrization for the mixing between active and sterile neutrinos, which is crucial for calculating the probabilities of these interactions. They then analyze the electron energy spectrum expected from this capture process and compare it to the dominant background: the beta decay of the target nucleus itself. To make their analysis more realistic, they incorporate the finite energy resolution of a detector and consider the effect of the finite half-lives of the radioactive isotopes.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it relies on:

  • Theoretical models: Standard Model electroweak theory and neutrino oscillation physics.
  • Astrophysical observations: Constraints on sterile neutrino masses and mixing angles derived from X-ray observations (e.g., from dwarf galaxies and the Galactic center) and Lyman-alpha forest data.
  • Experimental data: Existing measurements of beta decay Q-values, half-lives, and nuclear matrix elements for specific isotopes like tritium ($^3$H) and ruthenium-106 ($^{106}$Ru).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A "desert" for dark matter: The paper highlights the significant gap in the fermion mass spectrum between eV and MeV scales, suggesting it's a natural place for keV sterile neutrinos to reside.
  • Unique spectral signature: The capture of keV sterile neutrinos on radioactive nuclei produces a distinct peak in the electron energy spectrum, shifted from the beta decay endpoint by the sterile neutrino's mass. This provides a potential "smoking gun" signal.
  • Active-sterile mixing is key: The probability of this capture is directly proportional to the mixing parameters between active and sterile neutrinos, making these experiments sensitive probes of this fundamental aspect of neutrino physics.
  • Complementary probes: The authors emphasize that X-ray measurements and this proposed capture experiment probe different combinations of mixing parameters, making them complementary in fully characterizing sterile neutrinos.
  • Experimental feasibility: While challenging, the required energy resolution for detecting this signal is within reach of current or near-future beta decay experiments.

Key Results

The paper presents numerical analyses for two target nuclei: tritium ($^3$H) and ruthenium-106 ($^{106}$Ru).

  • Scenario A (Optimistic): For $m_4 = 2$ keV and $|V_{e4}|^2 \sim 5 \times 10^{-7}$, the capture rate is significant enough to be potentially observable, with a clear signal peak distinguishable from the beta decay background, especially with a resolution of $\Delta \sim 0.4$ keV.
  • Scenario B (More conservative): For $m_4 = 5$ keV and $|V_{e4}|^2 \sim 1 \times 10^{-9}$, the capture rate is much smaller, requiring higher precision and potentially larger isotope sources.
  • Half-life effect: The finite half-life of the target nuclei is found to be negligible for tritium but can reduce the capture rate for $^{106}$Ru by up to 30% near the signal peak, highlighting the importance of accounting for it in experimental planning.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tiny mixing angles: The primary challenge is the extremely small mixing angles between active and sterile neutrinos, which lead to very low capture rates, especially in more conservative scenarios.
  • Detector technology: Building a detector with the required sensitivity and precision, particularly for large isotope sources like a ton of $^{106}$Ru, presents significant engineering challenges. The metal property of $^{106}$Ru and its effect on electron energy loss also needs careful consideration.
  • Background rejection: While the spectral signature is distinct, further work is needed to fully quantify and mitigate other potential backgrounds, such as solar neutrino capture and neutrino-electron scattering.
  • Future work: The authors suggest a re-analysis of existing isotope sources used for cosmic neutrino background detection to optimize the choice of target nuclei for sterile neutrino detection. They also acknowledge that the experimental approach, while difficult, "should not be hopeless in the long run."

Summary updated

Abstract

There exists an observed “desert” spanning six orders of magnitude between O(0.5) eV and O(0.5) MeV in the fermion mass spectrum. We argue that it might accommodate one or more keV sterile neutrinos as a natural candidate for warm dark matter. To illustrate this point of view, we simply assume that there is one keV sterile neutrino ν4 and its flavor eigenstate νs weakly mixes with three active neutrinos. We clarify different active–sterile neutrino mixing factors for the radiative decay of ν4 and β decays in a self-consistent parametrization. A direct detection of this keV sterile neutrino dark matter in the laboratory is in principle possible since the ν4 component of νe can leave a distinct imprint on the electron energy spectrum when it is captured on radioactive β-decaying nuclei. We carry out an analysis of its signatures in the capture reactions νe+H3→He3+e− and νe+Ru106→Rh106+e− against the β-decay backgrounds, and conclude that this experimental approach might not be hopeless in the long run.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2010possible,
  author = {Yufeng Li and Zhi‐zhong Xing},
  title = {{Possible capture of keV sterile neutrino dark matter on radioactive β-decaying nuclei}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2010.11.015},
}
Figure