Abstract
Recently, evidence for positronium (Ps) in a Bloch state in self-assembled metal--organic frameworks (MOFs) has been reported. In this paper, we study Ps emission into vacuum from four different MOFs crystals: MOF-5, IRMOF-8, FMA and IRMOF-20. Our measurements of Ps yield and emission energy into vacuum provide definitive evidence of Ps delocalization. We determine with a different technique Ps diffusion lengths in agreement with the recently published results. Furthermore, we measure that a fraction of the Ps is emitted into vacuum with a distinctly smaller energy than what one would expect for Ps localized in the MOFs' cells. We show that a calculation assuming Ps delocalized in a Kronig--Penney potential reproduces the measured Ps emission energy.
Introduction
Positronium (Ps), a short-lived exotic atom composed of an electron and its antiparticle, the positron, serves as a unique probe for quantum mechanical phenomena due to its extremely low mass. In most solids, Ps typically becomes localized within lattice defects or undergoes rapid annihilation. However, recent studies have suggested that Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs)—highly porous, periodic crystalline structures—could host Ps in a delocalized "Bloch state," where its wavefunction is spread across the entire lattice. This paper presents definitive evidence for such delocalization by analyzing the kinetic energy of Ps atoms escaping from MOFs into a vacuum.
Experimental Methods and Modeling
The research team utilized the ETHZ slow positron beam to investigate four isoreticular MOFs: MOF-5, IRMOF-8, IRMOF-20, and ZnO₄(FMA)₃ (FMA). These materials share a similar cubic topology but feature different organic linkers, which vary the effective pore size and the distance between metal clusters.
Positrons were implanted at energies ranging from 1 to 20 keV. The kinetic energy of the resulting Ps atoms emitted into the vacuum was measured using Time-of-Flight (TOF) spectroscopy. To interpret these results, the researchers modeled the periodic MOF structure using a 1D Kronig-Penney potential. In this model, the metal clusters act as potential barriers of height $V_0$, while the pores represent potential wells of width $a$.
Results and Discussion
The most compelling evidence for delocalization came from the observation of Ps emission at energies lower than the theoretical ground-state energy for a particle confined within a single MOF cell. According to the principles of quantum confinement, smaller volumes necessitate higher ground-state energies. The detection of lower-energy components indicates that the Ps atoms are not trapped in individual "boxes" but are instead in a delocalized state that effectively "sees" a much larger volume.
The experimental data showed remarkable quantitative agreement with the Kronig-Penney model. For MOF-5, the measured emission energy of approximately 125 meV matched the calculated first-band energy. Additionally, the study confirmed exceptionally long diffusion lengths—up to 9.3 µm in FMA—which are characteristic of the high mobility associated with delocalized Bloch states. The transition of Ps from localized states to the delocalized state was also tracked by varying the implantation depth, revealing the dynamics of thermalization and tunneling through the organic linkers.
Conclusion
This study confirms that MOFs can act as tunable quantum laboratories, allowing for the precise control of atomic confinement. The successful application of the Kronig-Penney model demonstrates that Ps behaves as a delocalized wave within these porous architectures. Future work involving 3D potential modeling and the study of decoherence effects will further refine our understanding of these exotic states. Beyond fundamental physics, the ability of Ps to probe lattice interconnectivity suggests new avenues for characterizing advanced materials used in gas storage and catalysis.
Summary updated