Positron annihilation localization by nanoscale magnetization

Yaser H. Gholami, Hushan Yuan, Moses Q. Wilks, Lee Josephson, Georges El Fakhri, Marc D. Normandin, Zdenka KuncicScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

In positron emission tomography (PET), the finite range over which positrons travel before annihilating with an electron places a fundamental physical limit on spatial resolution. This "positron range" causes the detected annihilation photons to originate from a location distant from the tracer source, resulting in image blurring. This study demonstrates the localization of positron range through the strong nanoscale magnetization of superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs) in a PET-MRI system. Results show that positron annihilations localize within a region of interest by up to 60% more in the presence of SPIONs ([Fe] = 3 mM), improving spatial resolution by approximately 30%. Furthermore, evidence suggests that radiolabeled SPIONs significantly increase ortho-positronium formation, offering potential new avenues for cancer theranostics.

The Positron Range Problem

A primary challenge in PET imaging is the inherent physical distance a positron ($e^+$) travels after emission before it annihilates with an electron. This distance, known as the positron range, can reach several millimeters depending on the isotope (e.g., up to 17 mm for $^{82}$Rb). Because PET scanners detect the resulting 511 keV photon pair rather than the emission point of the tracer, this travel distance creates a "hard ceiling" for image resolution that cannot be overcome by detector improvements alone.

Mechanism of Magnetic Localization

To address this, researchers utilized the magnetic properties of superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs). When placed within the 3T external field of an MRI scanner, SPIONs become strongly magnetized, creating intense, localized 3D magnetic field gradients.

Schematic of positron localization by magnetized SPIONs within a PET-MRI environment.

These gradients act as nanoscale "magnetic cages." As a positron travels through these fields, it experiences a Lorentz force that compels it into a tight spiral path. This "corralling" effect keeps the positron significantly closer to the nanoparticle surface, effectively reducing the positron range and sharpening the resulting PET image. Importantly, the study confirmed this effect is magnetic rather than density-based, as the SPIONs added negligible mass density (~0.015%) to the medium.

Experimental Results and Quantification

The study employed a phantom model consisting of 10 vials with varying iron concentrations ([Fe]), ranging from 0 (water control) to 3 mM, labeled with the positron emitter $^{89}$Zr.

Phantom study setup and quantitative results showing the relationship between iron concentration and positron annihilation localization (PAL).

Key quantitative findings include:

  • Localization Enhancement: At 3 mM [Fe], positron annihilation localization (PAL) increased by 60% compared to the control. Even at clinically relevant doses (0.1 mM [Fe]), a significant PAL effect of ~40% was observed.
  • Resolution Gains: Spatial resolution, measured by Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM), improved by 30-40%. The FWHM sharpened from 4.79 mm in water to 2.89 mm at the highest SPION concentration.
  • Positronium Chemistry: Analysis of coincidence counts suggested a six-fold increase in the production of ortho-positronium (o-Ps) within the Fe$_3$O$_4$ crystal structure of the SPION cores.

Future Implications for Theranostics

The ability to localize charged particles at the nanoscale has profound implications for "theranostics" — the integration of diagnostic imaging and targeted therapy. If magnetic nanoparticles can restrict the range of positrons for better imaging, they may similarly localize the radiation dose from therapeutic alpha or beta emitters. This could allow for higher, more precise doses delivered directly to tumor cells while minimizing collateral damage to healthy surrounding tissue.

Future work will focus on translating these findings to in vivo environments and optimizing PET detector electronics to better capture the unique triple-gamma signature of ortho-positronium.

Summary updated

Abstract

In positron emission tomography (PET), the finite range over which positrons travel before annihilating with an electron places a fundamental physical limit on the spatial resolution of PET images. After annihilation, the photon pair detected by the PET instrumentation is emitted from a location that is different from the positron-emitting source, resulting in image blurring. Here, we report on the localization of positron range, and hence annihilation quanta, by strong nanoscale magnetization of superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs) in PET-MRI. We found that positron annihilations localize within a region of interest by up to 60% more when SPIONs are present (with [Fe] = 3 mM) compared to when they are not. The resulting full width at half maximum of the PET scans showed the spatial resolution improved by up to [Formula: see text] 30%. We also found evidence suggesting that the radiolabeled SPIONs produced up to a six-fold increase in ortho-positronium. These results may also have implications for emerging cancer theranostic strategies, where charged particles are used as therapeutic as well as diagnostic agents and improved dose localization within a tumor is a determinant of better treatment outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gholami2020positron,
  author = {Yaser H. Gholami and Hushan Yuan and Moses Q. Wilks and Lee Josephson and Georges El Fakhri and Marc D. Normandin and Zdenka Kuncic},
  title = {{Positron annihilation localization by nanoscale magnetization}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-76980-9},
}

Loading related content...

Figure