Positive RT-PCR Test Results in 420 Patients Recovered From COVID-19 in Wuhan: An Observational Study

Shaobin He, Jiaxing Tian, Xiaodong Li, Yana Zhou, Mingzhong Xiao, Ying Zhang, Xiaojun Min, Xiuyang Li, De Jin, Qing Zhang, Yujiao Zheng, Jia Ke, Qingwei Li, Junxiu Tao, Ping Song, Han Wang, Yi Lv, Qiyou Ding, Shuāng Táng, Jiaran Lin, Zhaoyuan Jiang, Zijun Zhang, Juexian Song, Fengmei Lian, Xiaolin TongFrontiers in Pharmacology 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This observational study investigated why some COVID-19 patients who had recovered and been discharged from the hospital later tested positive again for SARS-CoV-2 via RT-PCR. They found that a comprehensive intervention program, including Baduanjin exercise and traditional Chinese medicine, significantly reduced the recurrence rate of positive RT-PCR tests, suggesting it acts as a protective factor.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic presented a significant challenge in determining when patients were truly free of the virus. Even after meeting clinical discharge criteria (no symptoms, negative imaging, and two consecutive negative RT-PCR tests), some recovered patients continued to test positive. This phenomenon raised concerns about infectivity, the reliability of testing, and the overall understanding of viral clearance. The study aimed to explore the factors contributing to these recurrent positive RT-PCR results in discharged patients in Wuhan, China, a major epicenter of the initial outbreak.

Methods

The researchers conducted an observational study involving 420 recovered COVID-19 patients who were undergoing a mandatory 14-day quarantine period after hospital discharge. Data was collected from their medical records, including demographic information, comorbidities, symptoms, and the interventions they received during quarantine.

The key methodological aspects were:

  • Observational Design: The study observed patients as they were, without direct intervention from the researchers, to understand real-world outcomes.
  • Data Collection: Comprehensive data was gathered on a wide range of factors, from age and BMI to specific symptoms and the presence of comorbidities.
  • Intervention Groups: Patients were categorized into two groups: those who received a "comprehensive intervention" and those who did not. The comprehensive intervention included a combination of:
  • Baduanjin exercise (a form of Qigong)
    • Foot baths
    • Moxibustion with acupoint application
    • Chinese herbal medicine prescriptions (Tongzhi Granule and Wuhan Kangyi Decoction)
  • Statistical Analysis:
    • Descriptive statistics were used to characterize the patient population and the interventions.
  • Logistic regression analysis was employed to identify factors associated with recurrent positive RT-PCR test results. This allowed them to adjust for potential confounding variables like age, sex, and comorbidities.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from the medical records of 420 recovered COVID-19 patients from six rehabilitation stations in Wuhan, China. This data was collected between February 22, 2020, and March 10, 2020. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Comprehensive Intervention as a Protective Factor: The most striking finding is that patients who received the comprehensive intervention had a significantly lower rate of recurrent positive RT-PCR tests (2.8%) compared to those who did not (15.8%). This strongly suggests that these interventions play a protective role against viral RNA persistence.
  • Multifaceted Nature of Recurrence: The study identified age and comorbidities as risk factors for positive RT-PCR results, aligning with previous research. However, after accounting for these, the comprehensive intervention emerged as a significant protective factor.
  • Potential Mechanisms of Intervention: While not definitively proven, the authors hypothesize that the comprehensive interventions may work by strengthening the immune system, restoring metabolic balance, and promoting the elimination of residual viruses. This could lead to a more complete clearance of the virus from the body.
  • Importance of Post-Discharge Care: The study highlights the critical role of post-discharge care and rehabilitation in managing COVID-19 recovery, particularly in addressing the issue of persistent viral RNA.

Key Results

  • Recurrent Positive RT-PCR Rate: The overall recurrent positive RT-PCR rate among the 420 observed subjects was 5.7%.
  • Intervention Group Difference:
    • Comprehensive intervention group: 2.8% (9/325) positive RT-PCR results.
  • No intervention group: 15.8% (15/95) positive RT-PCR results.
  • Statistical Significance: Logistic regression analysis, after adjusting for age, sex, and comorbidity, showed that comprehensive intervention was significantly associated with a reduced risk of positive RT-PCR test results (P < 0.05).
  • Demographics: The median age of participants was 56 years, with 63.6% being over 50. Over half (50.7%) were female. Common comorbidities included hypertension (26.4%), hyperlipidemia (10.7%), and diabetes (10.5%).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: While 420 patients is a substantial number, the study's findings, particularly regarding specific intervention components, might benefit from larger sample sizes.
  • Observational Design: As an observational study, it cannot establish definitive causality. While the association between intervention and reduced positive tests is strong, other unmeasured factors could be at play.
  • Lack of Viral Antibody Testing: The study did not incorporate viral antibody testing, which could provide a more comprehensive picture of immune status and recovery.
  • Unspecified Mechanisms: The precise biological mechanisms by which the comprehensive interventions exert their protective effect require further exploration.

Future work suggested by the authors includes:

  • Further investigation into the specific targets and mechanisms of the comprehensive interventions.
  • Studies incorporating quantitative viral antibody detection to better assess patient recovery.
  • Larger-scale studies to confirm these findings and potentially explore the optimal combination and duration of interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Chictr.org.cn, identifier ChiCTR2000030747.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2020positive,
  author = {Shaobin He and Jiaxing Tian and Xiaodong Li and Yana Zhou and Mingzhong Xiao and Ying Zhang and Xiaojun Min and Xiuyang Li and De Jin and Qing Zhang and Yujiao Zheng and Jia Ke and Qingwei Li and Junxiu Tao and Ping Song and Han Wang and Yi Lv and Qiyou Ding and Shuāng Táng and Jiaran Lin and Zhaoyuan Jiang and Zijun Zhang and Juexian Song and Fengmei Lian and Xiaolin Tong},
  title = {{Positive RT-PCR Test Results in 420 Patients Recovered From COVID-19 in Wuhan: An Observational Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pharmacology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fphar.2020.549117},
}
Figure