Positive RT-PCR detected in patients recovered from COVID-19

Glorijoy Shi En Tan, Ying Ding, Lin Cui, Tze Minn Mak, Chee Keng Mok, Asok Kurup, Purnima Parthasarathy, Wanni Chia, Lin‐Fa Wang, Raymond Tp Lin, Yee‐Sin Leo, Shawn VasooAnnals 2021 · DOI

Introduction

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, clinicians observed a perplexing "flip-flop" phenomenon: patients who had clinically recovered and tested negative for SARS-CoV-2 twice would suddenly test positive again days or weeks later. This raised critical public health questions regarding whether these patients were still infectious, had been reinfected, or were experiencing viral reactivation. This study investigates these "re-positive" cases to determine if they represent ongoing contagiousness or the shedding of non-viable viral remnants.

Methods

The researchers conducted a clinical and laboratory evaluation of five "re-positive" patients in Singapore. The methodology aimed to distinguish between the presence of viral RNA and actual infectivity through several diagnostic layers:

  • RT-PCR Testing: Viral RNA detection and Cycle Threshold (Ct) values were recorded using the A*STAR Fortitude Kit and Roche Cobas systems.
  • Viral Culture: Nasopharyngeal swabs were inoculated into Vero E6 cells in a BSL-3 laboratory to attempt live virus isolation—the gold standard for determining infectivity.
  • Serological Analysis: Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assays (ELISA) were used to detect IgM and IgG antibodies against the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein's receptor-binding domain (RBD).
  • Surrogate Virus Neutralization Test (sVNT): This specialized assay measured the functional ability of patient antibodies to block viral binding to the ACE2 receptor.

Results

The study focused on five patients aged 23–44. The comprehensive clinical and laboratory findings for these individuals are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1: Clinical and laboratory characteristics of five patients with repeat positive SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR results.

Key findings from the analysis include:

  • Absence of Infectious Virus: Despite positive RT-PCR results, viral cultures for all five patients showed no growth after two serial passages. This strongly indicates that the patients were not shedding live, infectious virus.
  • High Cycle Threshold (Ct) Values: The mean Ct value at the time of repeat positive testing was 34.7 (range 32.95–38.63). These high values correlate with low viral loads and a lack of culturability, reinforcing the observation that a "Ct 30" threshold often marks the end of infectivity.
  • Robust Immune Response: 100% of the patients tested positive for neutralizing antibodies, with inhibition levels between 48% and 90% (well above the 30% positivity cutoff). This suggests a strong immune memory, making early reinfection highly unlikely.
  • Clinical Context: Symptoms reported during the second positive test were mild and often unrelated to COVID-19 (e.g., post-infectious cough). Furthermore, the mean duration between the repeat positive result and a subsequent negative result was only 4.8 days.

Discussion

The primary insight from this study is that RT-PCR detection of viral RNA does not equate to the presence of infectious virus. RT-PCR is highly sensitive to viral fragments (RNA), which can persist in the respiratory tract long after the virus has been neutralized by the immune system.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the findings support time-based de-isolation strategies, the study is limited by its small sample size of five patients. Additionally, the lack of genomic sequencing prevents a formal phylogenetic comparison between the first and second episodes, although high Ct values often make such sequencing technically difficult. As new variants emerge that may evade immunity, quantitative evaluation of neutralizing antibody titers and genetic sequencing will remain essential tools for distinguishing rare true reinfections from common RNA shedding.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{tan2021positive,
  author = {Glorijoy Shi En Tan and Ying Ding and Lin Cui and Tze Minn Mak and Chee Keng Mok and Asok Kurup and Purnima Parthasarathy and Wanni Chia and Lin‐Fa Wang and Raymond TP Lin and Yee‐Sin Leo and Shawn Vasoo},
  title = {{Positive RT-PCR detected in patients recovered from COVID-19}},
  journal = {Annals},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.47102/annals-acadmedsg.2020387},
}
Figure