Position: Constants are Critical in Regret Bounds for Reinforcement Learning

Simone Drago, Marco Mussi, Alberto Maria MetelliICML 2025 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper argues that the Reinforcement Learning (RL) community's focus on matching theoretical regret bounds up to multiplicative constants is misguided. By refining the analysis of existing algorithms like UCBVI, the authors demonstrate that optimizing these constants significantly improves empirical performance, leading to reduced exploration and faster learning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In theoretical Reinforcement Learning (RL), a common goal is to design algorithms whose "regret bounds" (a measure of how much worse they perform than an optimal policy) are asymptotically close to the theoretical lower bounds for a given problem. This is often expressed as matching the order of growth (e.g., $O(\sqrt{T})$) while ignoring constant factors and sometimes logarithmic terms. The authors contend that this focus on asymptotic behavior, while theoretically elegant, overlooks a crucial aspect: the actual performance of algorithms in practice. They argue that these "constants" and lower-order terms, often dismissed in theoretical analysis, play a significant role in an algorithm's efficiency by influencing the amount of exploration it performs. This disconnect can lead to algorithms that are theoretically sound but practically suboptimal, creating a gap between theory and practice.

Methods

The paper's core contribution lies in a refined theoretical analysis and empirical validation of existing RL algorithms, specifically focusing on finite-horizon tabular Markov Decision Processes (MDPs).

  • Refined Analysis of UCBVI: The authors take the well-known UCBVI (Upper Confidence Bound for Value Iteration) algorithm and re-analyze its regret bounds. They specifically focus on improving the "bonus terms" within the UCBVI framework. These bonus terms are crucial for balancing exploration (trying new actions) and exploitation (using known good actions). By deriving tighter bounds for these bonuses, they aim to reduce unnecessary exploration.
  • Bernstein-Freedman Bonus: They utilize the Bernstein-Freedman inequality to derive a more refined bonus term, aiming for a more accurate estimation of uncertainty.
  • Empirical Comparison: The improved UCBVI variant is compared against the original UCBVI and the state-of-the-art MVP (Model-based Value Prediction) algorithm. This comparison is conducted through simulations on various MDP environments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments are conducted on synthetically generated MDP environments with varying state spaces ($S$), action spaces ($A$), and episode lengths ($H$).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Constants Matter: The most significant insight is that multiplicative constants and lower-order terms in regret bounds are not just theoretical curiosities; they have a direct and substantial impact on an algorithm's empirical performance. Dismissing them can lead to algorithms that explore too much, wasting valuable interactions.
  • Exploration vs. Exploitation Trade-off: The paper highlights how the design of exploration bonuses directly influences the exploration-exploitation trade-off. Tighter bonuses lead to more judicious exploration, reducing unnecessary sampling.
  • Theory-Practice Gap: The authors argue that the current theoretical focus exacerbates the gap between researchers and practitioners. Algorithms that are theoretically "optimal" up to constants might perform poorly in practice due to these ignored factors.
  • UCBVI Improvement: The refined UCBVI algorithm, by optimizing its bonus terms, demonstrates significant empirical improvements, suggesting that even well-established algorithms can be enhanced by focusing on these "constants."

Key Results

  • Empirical Regret Reduction: The improved UCBVI algorithm (UCBVI-BF-I) achieved, on average, a 1.87x reduction in empirical regret compared to the original UCBVI.
  • Tighter Regret Bounds: The theoretical analysis resulted in improved regret upper bounds with smaller constant factors. For instance, the Chernoff-Hoeffding bonus was improved by a factor of 7/2, and the Bernstein-Freedman bonus by a factor of $\sqrt{2}$.
  • Performance Gap: In experiments with larger state and action spaces, the performance gap between the improved UCBVI and the original UCBVI widened, indicating that the benefits of tighter constants become more pronounced in more complex environments.
  • MVP Underperformance: The MVP algorithm, despite its theoretical sophistication (employing a doubling trick), consistently underperformed the UCBVI variants in the empirical evaluations, suggesting that its theoretical advantages did not translate to practical efficiency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tabular MDP Focus: The primary analysis and experimental validation are limited to finite-horizon tabular MDPs. The authors acknowledge that extending these findings to more complex settings, such as deep RL, is a significant challenge.
  • Novel Mathematical Tools: The authors suggest that new mathematical tools might be necessary to effectively analyze and improve algorithms in more complex RL settings.
  • Algorithm Design Philosophy: They advocate for a shift in algorithm design philosophy, encouraging researchers to consider not only upper bounds but also lower bounds on regret to better understand an algorithm's true performance limits.
  • Broader Impact: The authors believe that their findings have implications beyond tabular MDPs and could lead to better-performing algorithms in more complex RL scenarios, bridging the gap between theoretical guarantees and real-world performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mainstream research in theoretical RL is currently focused on designing online learning algorithms with regret bounds that match the corresponding regret lower bound up to multiplicative constants (and, sometimes, logarithmic terms). In this position paper, we constructively question this trend, arguing that algorithms should be designed to at least minimize the amount of unnecessary exploration, and we highlight the significant role constants play in algorithms' actual performances. This trend also exacerbates the misalignment between theoretical researchers and practitioners. As an emblematic example, we consider the case of regret minimization in finite-horizon tabular MDPs. Starting from the well-known UCBVI algorithm, we improve the bonus terms and the corresponding regret analysis. Additionally, we compare our version of UCBVI with both its original version and the state-of-the-art MVP algorithm. Our empirical validation successfully demonstrates how improving the multiplicative constants has significant positive effects on the actual empirical performances of the algorithm under analysis. This raises the question of whether ignoring constants when assessing whether algorithms match is the proper approach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{drago2025position,
  author = {Simone Drago and Marco Mussi and Alberto Maria Metelli},
  title = {{Position: Constants are Critical in Regret Bounds for Reinforcement Learning}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Machine Learning},
  year = {2025},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=3wEY0NB2pG},
}
Figure