Pore-Scale Flow Fields of the Viscosity-Lost Partially Hydrolyzed Polyacrylamide Solution Caused by Sulfide Ion

Xiaoluan Yu, Hao Niu, Hua Li, Chun’an Du, Zhiyong Song, Debin Kong, Weiyao ZhuEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how sulfide ions in brine degrade partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) solutions, leading to significant viscosity loss and altered flow behavior in porous media. By combining microscopic visualization and Micro-PIV, the researchers found that sulfide ions cause elastic loss, not just viscosity loss, which is the dominant factor driving severe viscous fingering and reduced oil recovery efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Enhanced oil recovery (EOR) often relies on polymer flooding, where partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) solutions are injected to improve sweep efficiency by reducing the mobility ratio between oil and water. However, the composition of reservoir brines, particularly the presence of ions like sulfide (S²⁻), can severely degrade HPAM, leading to a dramatic loss in viscosity and, consequently, reduced oil recovery. While it's known that sulfide ions cause viscosity loss, the precise pore-scale flow mechanisms responsible for the observed poor performance in the presence of sulfide remain unclear. This paper aims to elucidate these mechanisms by examining the flow behavior of HPAM solutions with and without sulfide ions at the pore scale.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Used to visualize the microstructural changes in HPAM solutions with and without sulfide ions. This helps understand how sulfide affects the physical structure of the polymer.
  • Rheological Measurements: Viscosity measurements were performed using a Brookfield viscometer across a range of shear rates and over time to quantify the viscosity loss induced by different sulfide concentrations.
  • Microscopic Visualization Seepage Experiment: A custom-built microfluidic model, mimicking natural sandstone pore structures, was used to simulate fluid flow.
  • Microscale Particle Image Velocimetry (Micro-PIV): This advanced technique was coupled with the seepage experiment to precisely measure the velocity fields of the fluid flow within the pore network. Fluorescent tracer particles were used to track fluid movement, and specialized software analyzed the particle displacements to generate detailed velocity maps.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a custom-made micromodel and prepared polymer solutions with varying sulfide concentrations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sulfide's Structural Impact: Sulfide ions don't just dilute the polymer; they fundamentally alter its structure. Instead of a uniform, three-dimensional network, the polymer forms loose, uneven floccules, leading to a significant loss in viscosity (over 70% with just 5 mg/L sulfide).
  • Beyond Viscosity Loss: While viscosity loss is evident, it alone cannot explain the severe viscous fingering observed. The study highlights that the elastic loss of the polymer, stemming from the disruption of its molecular structure and interactions, plays a more critical role in dictating flow behavior.
  • Eccentric and Bimodal Flow: At the pore scale, the flow field in the presence of sulfide exhibits unusual patterns:
  • Eccentric Radial Velocity: In the pore throats, the velocity distribution along the radial direction is not centered. This suggests that the polymer adsorbed on the pore walls is being broken through by the hydraulic shear forces, a consequence of the collapsed polymer structure.
  • Bimodal Axial Velocity: The velocity distribution along the axial direction in the throat shows two distinct peaks. This phenomenon, not observed in sulfide-free experiments, indicates energy conversions related to abrupt changes in flow geometry and suggests an earlier onset of non-Newtonian behavior at low shear rates due to sulfide.
  • Micro-PIV as a Powerful Tool: The study underscores the effectiveness of Micro-PIV in revealing complex pore-scale flow mechanisms that are not discernible through traditional methods.

Key Results

  • Viscosity Reduction: Sulfide ion concentrations from 0 to 10 mg/L led to increased viscosity loss. A 5 mg/L concentration resulted in over 80% viscosity loss and a high decline rate.
  • Shear Thinning: Higher sulfide concentrations (5 and 10 mg/L) induced earlier shear thinning characteristics compared to lower concentrations.
  • Increased Flow Velocity: Despite viscosity loss, the average flow velocity in the main stream of the microscopic seepage experiment increased significantly with sulfide compared to the sulfide-free case.
  • Severe Viscous Fingering: The ratio of average velocity between the mainstream and margin during post-water flooding with sulfide was approximately five times greater than that during primary water flooding, indicating severe viscous fingering and reduced sweep efficiency.
  • Radial Velocity Peak: In the throat during post-water flooding with sulfide, a high radial velocity peak (106.16 µm/s) was observed, indicating the polymer structure was broken through.
  • Axial Velocity Peaks: The axial velocity distribution in the throat showed two peaks (e.g., 84.20 µm/s and 108.08 µm/s), suggesting elastic energy transformations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study focused on a specific type of HPAM and a limited range of sulfide concentrations. The experiments were conducted in a synthetic micromodel, which may not perfectly replicate the complex heterogeneity of natural reservoirs. The authors acknowledge that while Micro-PIV is powerful, it provides a 2D view of a 3D phenomenon.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that understanding these sulfide-induced variations is crucial for developing sulfide-tolerant agents. Future research could explore a wider range of HPAM types, sulfide concentrations, and reservoir conditions. Investigating the long-term impact of sulfide on polymer stability and developing strategies to mitigate sulfide-induced degradation would be valuable. Further 3D pore-scale studies using advanced imaging techniques could provide a more comprehensive understanding.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rheology of a partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) solution plays an important role in its oil recovery during polymer flooding. However, multiple factors in brine, such as sulfide ions, cause a dramatic loss in the viscosity and oil recovery. To better understand the sulfide-induced viscosity loss and the consequent flow mechanisms in pore networks, the morphology of polymer solutions with and without sulfide ion was observed by scanning electron microscopy; and the variations of the pore scale flow fields were demonstrated by a microscopic visualization seepage experiment combined with Micro-PIV (Microscale Particle Image Velocimetry). The results showed that, with the presence of sulfide ion, the microstructure of the polymer changed from a uniform three-dimensional network structure to loose and uneven floccules, which resulted in viscosity loss (over 70% with 5-mg/L sulfide ion). Moreover, higher concentrations of sulfide ions (5 mg/L and 10 mg/L) resulted in earlier shear thinning characteristics than those with lower sulfide concentrations. Due to viscosity loss, the average flow velocity in the main stream of the microscopic seepage experiment increased more significantly than that without sulfide. However, the viscosity loss alone cannot independently explain the severe viscous fingering during the subsequent post-water flooding, which was about five times greater than that of the primary water flooding in terms of the velocity ratio between the mainstream and margin. A further pore-scale flow field analysis exhibited an eccentric and a bimodal velocity distribution in the throat along the radial and axial directions, respectively. The former distribution indicated that the adsorbed polymer on the pore wall was broken through by hydraulic shear due to the collapsed structure caused by sulfide ion. The latter suggested that another sulfide-induced impact was an earlier-occurring non-Newtonian characteristic with a low shear rate. Therefore, instead of viscosity loss, elastic loss is the dominant mechanism affecting the characteristics of the aggregate flow field under the action of sulfide. Microscopic flooding combined with Micro-PIV is a feasible and essential method to reveal pore scale flow mechanisms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2022pore,
  author = {Xiaoluan Yu and Hao Niu and Hua Li and Chun’an Du and Zhiyong Song and Debin Kong and Weiyao Zhu},
  title = {{Pore-Scale Flow Fields of the Viscosity-Lost Partially Hydrolyzed Polyacrylamide Solution Caused by Sulfide Ion}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15062048},
}
Figure