Population structure, biogeography and transmissibility of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Luca Freschi, Roger Vargas, Ashaque Husain, S. M. Mostofa Kamal, Alena Skrahina, Sabira Tahseen, Nazir Ismail, A. I. Barbova, Stefan Niemann, Daniela María Cirillo, Anna Dean, Matteo Zignol, Maha FarhatNature Communications 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a significantly more detailed map of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) genetic diversity, revealing 30 new sub-lineages and expanding our understanding of its global spread and evolutionary history. This enhanced resolution helps explain differences in transmissibility between Mtb lineages, suggesting that lineages 2 and 4 are more transmissible than lineages 1 and 3, which has implications for understanding disease dynamics and developing targeted interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the bacterium responsible for tuberculosis (TB), is a remarkably clonal pathogen that has co-evolved with humans for millennia. Despite this long history, our understanding of its genomic diversity and how it has spread across the globe (biogeography) has been incomplete. Previous classifications of Mtb lineages and sub-lineages, while useful, lacked the resolution to fully capture the nuances of its population structure, particularly for lineages like 1 and 3. This gap hinders our ability to fully grasp how different Mtb strains might vary in their transmissibility, virulence, or antibiotic resistance, which are crucial for effective public health strategies. The paper aims to address this by providing a more granular and accurate picture of Mtb's genetic landscape.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining phylogenetics and dimensionality reduction.

  • Phylogenetic Analysis: They constructed maximum-likelihood phylogenetic trees for each of the four major Mtb lineages (L1-L4) using whole-genome single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) data from nearly 10,000 isolates.
  • Sub-lineage Definition: To define new sub-lineages and internal groups, they used a combination of criteria:
  • Genetic Divergence (FST): Measuring the genetic differentiation between groups.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): A dimensionality reduction technique to visualize genetic relationships and identify distinct clusters.
  • Monophyly: Ensuring that a group of isolates shared a common ancestor and were distinct from other groups.
  • Bootstrap Support: Assessing the statistical confidence in the phylogenetic tree branches.
  • Hierarchical Naming System: A novel, systematic naming scheme was developed to reflect the hierarchical relationships within the Mtb phylogeny, allowing for precise identification of sub-lineages and internal groups.
  • SNP Barcode Development: They identified a set of 95 SNPs that could reliably and rapidly classify Mtb strains into the newly defined sub-lineages, creating a tool for faster identification.
  • Transmissibility Assessment: Terminal branch lengths in the phylogenetic trees were used as a proxy for transmissibility. Shorter branch lengths are hypothesized to indicate faster evolution and potentially higher transmissibility, possibly due to more efficient spread or adaptation.

Datasets

The study utilized several large datasets:

  • Primary Dataset: 9,584 clinical Mtb samples from 49 countries, including 4,939 pan-susceptible isolates used for phylogenetic tree construction and sub-lineage definition.
  • Validation Dataset: 4,645 independent, resistant isolates used to validate the newly defined sub-lineages.
  • Geographic Distribution Dataset: 17,432 Mtb isolates from 74 countries used to assess the geographic spread of sub-lineages.
  • Geographic Validation Dataset: 3,791 Mtb isolates from five countries, systematically sampled to represent the local TB patient population, used to confirm geographic findings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unveiling Hidden Diversity: The study significantly expands the known genetic diversity of Mtb, identifying 30 new genetically distinct clades (sub-lineages and internal groups). This suggests that our previous understanding of Mtb's population structure was an oversimplification.
  • Geographic Patterns Reflect History: The observed geographic distribution of sub-lineages provides strong evidence for Mtb's co-evolution with human populations. Some sub-lineages are geographically restricted, hinting at specialized adaptations to specific human groups or regions, while others are widespread "generalists."
  • Transmissibility Linked to Lineage: The phylogenetic analysis strongly suggests that Mtb lineages differ in their transmissibility. Lineages 2 and 4 appear to be more transmissible globally than lineages 1 and 3, as indicated by shorter terminal branch lengths in their phylogenetic trees. This is a crucial insight for understanding TB epidemiology.
  • A New Diagnostic Tool: The development of a 95-SNP barcode and associated software provides a practical and efficient tool for rapid sub-lineage identification, which can be invaluable for surveillance, outbreak investigation, and research.

Key Results

  • 30 New Clades: The study identified 30 new genetically distinct sub-lineages and internal groups across the four major Mtb lineages.
  • Geographic Restriction/Unrestriction: 20 groups showed consistent geographically restricted or unrestricted patterns, including three groups within Lineage 1.
  • Transmissibility Hierarchy: Terminal branch lengths indicated a transmissibility hierarchy: L4 > L2 > L3 > L1.
  • Median terminal branch lengths: L4 (6.2 × 10⁻⁵), L2 (8.2 × 10⁻⁵), L3 (10.2 × 10⁻⁵), L1 (17.5 × 10⁻⁵).
  • Expanded SNP Barcode: A new barcode of 95 SNPs was defined, enabling the rapid identification of 69 Mtb sub-lineages and 26 additional internal groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Human Ancestry and Contact Networks: The authors acknowledge that while geographic distribution is suggestive of co-evolution and differential adaptation, confirmation requires controlling for factors like human ancestry, migration patterns, and contact networks. This type of data was not available for this study.
  • Further Validation: While the new sub-lineages were validated, further research with more extensive and systematic pathogen whole-genome sequencing from under-represented regions (e.g., Sub-Saharan Africa) is needed to confirm observations, particularly for potential specialized lineages.
  • Generalist L1 Sub-lineage: The identification of a potential generalist sub-lineage within L1 (the most ancestral lineage) warrants further investigation and validation.
  • Drug Resistance and Virulence: While the study touches upon potential differences in virulence or antibiotic resistance, future work could directly link these newly defined sub-lineages to specific phenotypic traits.
  • Tool Generalizability: The developed SNP barcode and caller tool are presented as generalizable and can be adapted for other bacterial species, suggesting future applications beyond Mtb.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mycobacterium tuberculosis is a clonal pathogen proposed to have co-evolved with its human host for millennia, yet our understanding of its genomic diversity and biogeography remains incomplete. Here we use a combination of phylogenetics and dimensionality reduction to reevaluate the population structure of M. tuberculosis, providing an in-depth analysis of the ancient Indo-Oceanic Lineage 1 and the modern Central Asian Lineage 3, and expanding our understanding of Lineages 2 and 4. We assess sub-lineages using genomic sequences from 4939 pan-susceptible strains, and find 30 new genetically distinct clades that we validate in a dataset of 4645 independent isolates. We find a consistent geographically restricted or unrestricted pattern for 20 groups, including three groups of Lineage 1. The distribution of terminal branch lengths across the M. tuberculosis phylogeny supports the hypothesis of a higher transmissibility of Lineages 2 and 4, in comparison with Lineages 3 and 1, on a global scale. We define an expanded barcode of 95 single nucleotide substitutions that allows rapid identification of 69 M. tuberculosis sub-lineages and 26 additional internal groups. Our results paint a higher resolution picture of the M. tuberculosis phylogeny and biogeography.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{freschi2021population,
  author = {Luca Freschi and Roger Vargas and Ashaque Husain and S. M. Mostofa Kamal and Alena Skrahina and Sabira Tahseen and Nazir Ismail and A. I. Barbova and Stefan Niemann and Daniela María Cirillo and Anna Dean and Matteo Zignol and Maha Farhat},
  title = {{Population structure, biogeography and transmissibility of Mycobacterium tuberculosis}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-26248-1},
}
Figure