Population Structure and Genetic Diversity of Shanlan Landrace Rice for GWAS of Cooking and Eating Quality Traits

Lin Zhang, Bowen Deng, Yi Peng, Yan Gao, Yaqi Hu, Jinsong BaoInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study delves into the genetic makeup and cooking/eating quality of Shanlan landrace rice from Hainan, China. By resequencing genomes and performing genome-wide association studies (GWAS), researchers identified key genes like Waxy and SSIIa influencing rice quality and uncovered a rich diversity of Waxy alleles, highlighting Shanlan rice as a valuable resource for breeding premium quality rice varieties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rice is a global staple, and as demand grows, so does the need for both high yields and superior quality. While traditional rice breeding has focused on yield, there's an increasing emphasis on improving cooking and eating quality (CEQ). Shanlan landrace rice, cultivated by the Li ethnic group in Hainan, is a unique and valuable germplasm with a long history of adaptation. However, its genetic diversity and its specific contributions to CEQ traits remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to fill that gap by characterizing the population structure and genetic diversity of Shanlan rice and identifying the genetic basis of its CEQ traits through advanced genomic approaches.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Whole-Genome Resequencing: They resequenced the genomes of 84 Shanlan landrace rice accessions, along with three typical japonica and three typical indica rice cultivars, to identify genetic variations.
  • SNP and InDel Calling: High-quality single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and insertion/deletions (InDels) were identified from the resequencing data.
  • Population Structure Analysis: Techniques like Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and ADMIXTURE were used to understand the genetic relationships and group the rice accessions into distinct subpopulations.
  • Phenotypic Characterization: Various starch physicochemical properties related to CEQ, including apparent amylose content (AAC), pasting viscosity, texture, thermal properties, and retrogradation, were measured.
  • Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS): A fixed and random model circulating probability unification (FarmCPU) approach was used to identify marker-trait associations (MTAs) for the CEQ traits.
  • Candidate Gene Analysis: Genes located near significant MTAs were investigated, with a focus on known genes like Waxy (Wx) and SSIIa.
  • Nucleotide Diversity and Haplotype Analysis: The diversity of alleles within key genes was examined.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset comprising:

  • 84 Shanlan landrace rice accessions from Hainan Province, China.
  • 6 reference cultivars: 3 typical japonica (Nipponbare, Zhonghua 11, Tainung 67) and 3 typical indica (9311, Guangluai4, IR36) rice cultivars.

This dataset represents a unique collection of Shanlan landrace rice, which differs from previously studied germplasm collections.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shanlan Rice is Genetically Distinct: The population structure analysis revealed that most Shanlan landrace rice accessions fall into a distinct group (GJ2) that is different from modern japonica cultivars, suggesting they possess unique genetic characteristics.
  • Rich Allelic Diversity in Waxy: The study identified six different alleles of the Waxy (Wx) gene in Shanlan rice. This diversity is crucial because Wx is a major determinant of amylose content and thus impacts rice texture and cooking quality.
  • Key Genes for Quality Identified: The GWAS pinpointed significant associations with known genes like Waxy (Wx) for traits like apparent amylose content (AAC) and breakdown viscosity, and SSIIa for retrogradation and peak gelatinization temperature. This confirms their importance and highlights their role in Shanlan rice.
  • Shanlan Rice as a Breeding Resource: The wide genetic diversity observed, particularly in the Wx gene, positions Shanlan landrace rice as a valuable source of novel alleles for breeding new rice varieties with improved cooking and eating qualities.

Key Results

  • Genomic Variants: Over 11.2 million high-quality SNPs and 1.6 million InDels were identified across the 90 rice accessions.
  • Population Structure: The rice accessions were classified into three main groups: GJ1, GJ2, and XI (Xian/indica). GJ1 was a small group with only seven accessions, including typical japonica cultivars, indicating Shanlan rice's divergence from modern japonica.
  • Genetic Variation: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) showed that the first three principal components explained 60.7% of the genetic variation.
  • Phenotypic Diversity: Significant variations were observed in starch physicochemical properties across the different subpopulations, with the XI group exhibiting a broader range in AAC and viscosity parameters.
  • GWAS Findings: A total of 32 marker-trait associations (MTAs) were identified. The Waxy gene was significantly associated with AAC, breakdown viscosity, and gumminess. The SSIIa gene was linked to retrogradation and peak gelatinization temperature.
  • Wx Alleles: Six Wx alleles (wx, Wx<sup>a</sup>, Wx<sup>b</sup>, Wx<sup>in</sup>, Wx<sup>la/mw</sup>, Wx<sup>lv</sup>) were identified, with Wx<sup>la/mw</sup> being more prevalent in Shanlan rice than previously reported.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Origin of Shanlan Rice: While previous studies suggest a Guangdong origin, the current resequencing data raises questions about the evolution and origin of Shanlan rice, particularly the distinct GJ1 subpopulation. Further research is needed to clarify this.
  • Candidate Gene Validation: While several candidate genes were identified through GWAS, further functional validation through transgenic experiments is recommended to confirm their direct role in specific CEQ traits, especially for genes identified in the SSIIa region.
  • Environmental Factors: The study focused on genetic diversity. Future work could explore how environmental factors interact with these genetic variations to influence CEQ traits.
  • Breeding Applications: The identified favorable alleles and MTAs provide a strong foundation for marker-assisted selection and molecular breeding strategies to develop improved rice varieties.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Shanlan landrace rice in Hainan Province, China, is a unique upland rice germplasm that holds significant value as a genetic resource for rice breeding. However, its genetic diversity and its usefulness in rice breeding have not been fully explored. In this study, a total of eighty-four Shanlan rice, three typical japonica rice cultivars, and three typical indica rice cultivars were subjected to resequencing of their genomes. As a result, 11.2 million high-quality single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and 1.6 million insertion/deletions (InDels) were detected. Population structure analysis showed all the rice accessions could be divided into three main groups, i.e., Geng/<i>japonica</i> 1 (GJ1), GJ2, and Xian/<i>indica</i> (XI). However, the GJ1 group only had seven accessions including three typical japonica cultivars, indicating that most Shanlan landrace rice are different from the modern japonica rice. Principal component analysis (PCA) showed that the first three principal components explained 60.7% of the genetic variation. Wide genetic diversity in starch physicochemical parameters, such as apparent amylose content (AAC), pasting viscosity, texture properties, thermal properties, and retrogradation representing the cooking and eating quality was also revealed among all accessions. The genome-wide association study (GWAS) for these traits was conducted and identified 32 marker trait associations in the entire population. Notably, the well-known gene <i>Waxy</i> (<i>Wx</i>) was identified for AAC, breakdown viscosity, and gumminess of the gel texture, and <i>SSIIa</i> was identified for percentage of retrogradation and peak gelatinization temperature. Upon further analysis of nucleotide diversity in <i>Wx</i>, six different alleles, <i>wx</i>, <i>Wx<sup>a</sup></i>, <i>Wx<sup>b</sup></i>, <i>Wx<sup>in</sup></i>, <i>Wx<sup>la/mw</sup></i>, and <i>Wx<sup>lv</sup></i> in Shanlan landrace rice were identified, indicating rich gene resources in Shanlan rice for quality rice breeding. These findings are expected to contribute to the development of new rice with premium quality.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2024population,
  author = {Lin Zhang and Bowen Deng and Yi Peng and Yan Gao and Yaqi Hu and Jinsong Bao},
  title = {{Population Structure and Genetic Diversity of Shanlan Landrace Rice for GWAS of Cooking and Eating Quality Traits}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms25063469},
}
Figure