Population-level analyses identify host and environmental variables influencing the vaginal microbiome

Lang Qin, Tianyong Sun, Xiao Li, Shigang Zhao, Zheng Liu, Changlong Zhang, Congcong Jin, Yanqi Xu, Xuan Gao, Yongzhi Cao, Jiaojiao Wang, Ting Han, Lei Yan, Jialun Song, Fangfang Zhang, Feifei Liu, Yousheng Zhang, Yuzhen Huang, Yuping Song, Yanjun Liu, Jing Zhang, Xiuqing Zhang, Zhina Yao, Honglei Chen, Zhenzhen Zhang, Shengrui Zhao, Yuhan Feng, Yanan Zhang, Qian Yu, Fang Cao, Lijuan Zhao, Lei Xie, Ling Geng, Qiang Feng, Han Zhao, Zi‐Jiang ChenSignal 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzed the vaginal microbiomes of over 6,700 Chinese women, revealing that factors like age, bacterial vaginosis (BV), and lifestyle significantly shape its composition. They identified 13 distinct "Vagitypes" and found that certain Lactobacillus-dominant types are associated with higher live birth rates, suggesting a link between specific microbial communities and reproductive health outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The vaginal microbiome is crucial for women's reproductive health, but the complex interplay between host factors, environmental influences, and its composition has remained largely unclear. Previous research often focused on smaller cohorts or lacked comprehensive data on associated variables. This paper aims to provide a large-scale, population-level understanding of what drives vaginal microbiome diversity and composition, and how these microbial communities relate to reproductive health.

Methods

The researchers employed 16S rRNA sequencing to analyze the vaginal microbiome of 6,755 Chinese women. They collected extensive data on 81 matched host and environmental variables, categorized into eight groups (demographics, lifestyle, gynecological history, social factors, environmental data, clinical blood profile, female physiology, and vaginal dysbiosis). Statistical methods like Principal Coordinate Analysis (PCoA), multivariate association with linear models (MaAsLin), and network analysis (SparCC) were used to identify associations between variables and microbial composition. They also developed a classification system of 13 "Vagitypes" using Non-negative Matrix Factorization (NMF) and validated these classifications in independent cohorts. Mediation analyses were used to explore causal relationships between age, host variables, and the microbiome.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of vaginal swab samples from 6,755 Chinese women collected as part of the Vaginal Microbiome Health Project (VaMHP). This study also utilized publicly available 16S rRNA gene sequencing data from five independent populations (Belgium, Australia, Canada, South Africa, and South Korea) for validation of their identified "Vagitypes."

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Age as a Major Driver: Age is a significant factor, with a notable shift in vaginal microbiome composition occurring around age 45, marking a turning point in its dynamic succession.
  • BV's Dominant Role: Bacterial vaginosis (BV) emerged as the variable with the largest effect size on microbiome composition, highlighting its disruptive impact.
  • Beyond Genetics: The study emphasizes that it's not just host genetics but also lifestyle choices (exercise, sexual frequency), socioeconomic factors (education, income), and even environmental factors (sampling month, outdoor temperature) that significantly influence the vaginal microbiome.
  • "Vagitypes" for Precision: The identification of 13 distinct "Vagitypes" provides a more granular classification of vaginal microbial communities, moving beyond broader categories.
  • Microbiome and Reproductive Success: A strong link was found between specific Vagitypes and reproductive outcomes, particularly live birth rates, suggesting that microbial composition can be a predictor of fertility success.
  • Interactions Matter: Network analysis revealed complex interdependencies between microbial taxa, with certain species acting as "hubs" that significantly influence community structure.

Key Results

  • Four core vaginal microbial species were identified, accounting for 98.8% of the median abundance in the cohort.
  • Twenty-four variables were found to be significantly associated with vaginal microbiome composition, with BV having the largest effect size.
  • Age was a strong explanatory variable, with a distinct turning point around age 45.
  • Mediation analyses indicated that age's impact on the microbiome can be influenced by factors like parity and lifestyle.
  • Women with Lactobacillus iners- and Lactobacillus jensenii-dominated Vagitypes showed significantly higher live birth rates (53.40% and 59.09%) compared to those with Fannyhessea vaginae-dominated Vagitypes (21.43%).
  • The study successfully validated the identified Vagitypes across multiple international cohorts, demonstrating their generalizability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • 16S rRNA Sequencing: This method primarily captures bacterial composition and diversity, not other microorganisms like fungi or protozoa. Future shotgun metagenomics studies are recommended for a more complete picture.
  • Taxonomic Resolution: The V1-V2 region sequencing, while improving discrimination at the genus level, might underestimate the abundance of certain taxa like G. vaginalis and may not provide species-level accuracy for all.
  • Unidentified Factors: The identified variables explain only about 13.96% of the microbiome variability, suggesting that many other factors (e.g., detailed socioeconomic status, dietary habits, hygiene practices) are yet to be fully understood.
  • Cross-sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature limits the ability to establish definitive causal relationships. Longitudinal studies are needed to confirm these findings and explore dynamic changes over time.
  • Population Specificity: Findings are based on a Chinese population, and associations may not be directly extrapolatable to other ethnicities.

Future work should focus on longitudinal studies, multi-omic approaches, and validation in diverse populations to further elucidate the complex interactions within the vaginal microbiome and its impact on health. The development of microbiome-targeted interventions based on Vagitype classification is also a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

The vaginal microbiome is critical for the reproductive health of women, yet the differential impacts exerted by the host and by ambient environmental variables on the vaginal microbiome remain largely unknown. Here, we conducted a comprehensive cross-sectional study of the relationships between the vaginal microbiome and 81 matched host and environmental variables across 6755 Chinese women. By 16S rRNA sequencing, we identified four core vaginal microbiota with a prevalence of over 90% and a total median abundance of 98.8%. Twenty-four variables, including physiology, lifestyle behaviors, gynecologic history, social and environmental information, were found associated with the microbiome composition, of which bacterial vaginosis (BV) showed the largest effect size. Age was among the strongest explanatory variables and the vaginal microbiome dynamically succeeded with increasing age, especially with a composition turning point at the age of 45. Our mediation analyses indicated that the effects of age on the microbiome could be mediated by variables such as parity number and lifestyles. We further classified the vaginal microbiomes of the population into 13 "Vagitypes". Women with Lactobacillus iners- and Lactobacillus jensenii-dominated Vagitypes had significantly higher live birth rate than those with Vagitype dominated by Fannyhessea vaginae (53.40%, 59.09% vs 21.43%; OR [95% CI]: 3.62 [1.12-14.87], 5.39 [1.27-27.36]; P = 0.031, P = 0.021). This study provides a comprehensive overview of the associations between identified variables and the vaginal microbiome, representing an important step toward understanding of environment-microbe-host interactions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qin2025population,
  author = {Lang Qin and Tianyong Sun and Xiao Li and Shigang Zhao and Zheng Liu and Changlong Zhang and Congcong Jin and Yanqi Xu and Xuan Gao and Yongzhi Cao and Jiaojiao Wang and Ting Han and Lei Yan and Jialun Song and Fangfang Zhang and Feifei Liu and Yousheng Zhang and Yuzhen Huang and Yuping Song and Yanjun Liu and Jing Zhang and Xiuqing Zhang and Zhina Yao and Honglei Chen and Zhenzhen Zhang and Shengrui Zhao and Yuhan Feng and Yanan Zhang and Qian Yu and Fang Cao and Lijuan Zhao and Lei Xie and Ling Geng and Qiang Feng and Han Zhao and Zi‐Jiang Chen},
  title = {{Population-level analyses identify host and environmental variables influencing the vaginal microbiome}},
  booktitle = {Signal},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41392-025-02152-8},
}
Figure