Population Genetic Structure, Historical Effective Population Size, and Dairy Trait Selection Signatures in Chinese Red Steppe and Holstein Cattle

Peng Niu, Xiaopeng Li, Xueyan Wang, Huimin Qu, Hong Chen, Fei Huang, Kai Hu, Di Fang, Qinghua GaoAnimals 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study compares the genetic makeup of Chinese Red Steppe (CRS) and Holstein cattle to identify genetic differences and selection signatures related to milk production. By analyzing genome-wide data, researchers pinpointed key genes and metabolic pathways, like butanoate metabolism, that are crucial for milk fat synthesis and protein quality, offering valuable insights for improving CRS dairy traits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dairy cattle are vital for global food security, with Holstein cows being renowned for high milk yields. However, intensive breeding has led to reduced genetic diversity and adaptability in Holsteins, making them susceptible to environmental stressors. In contrast, Chinese Red Steppe (CRS) cattle, a composite breed, are well-adapted to local conditions and possess moderate milk production. The challenge lies in leveraging the genetic strengths of CRS for dairy improvement without sacrificing its valuable adaptive traits, while also understanding the genetic basis of high milk yield in Holsteins. This paper aims to bridge this gap by comparing the genetic structure, demographic history, and selection signatures of these two breeds to identify potential targets for enhancing dairy production in CRS.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze the genetic data:

  • Population Structure Analysis: Principal Component Analysis (PCA), Neighbor-Joining (NJ) phylogenetic trees, and sparse Non-negative Matrix Factorization (sNMF) were used to visualize and quantify the genetic relationships and substructure within and between the CRS and Holstein populations.
  • Historical Effective Population Size (Ne) and Divergence Time: The SMC++ software was utilized to reconstruct the historical Ne trajectories of both breeds and estimate the time of their divergence.
  • Selection Signature Detection: Two complementary methods were used:
  • Fixation Index (FST): This measures genetic differentiation between populations. Sliding window analyses were performed to identify regions with high FST values, indicating potential selection.
  • Cross-Population Composite Likelihood Ratio (XP-CLR): This method is designed to detect recent selective sweeps by analyzing allele frequency differences between populations.
  • Functional Annotation and Enrichment Analysis: Candidate genes identified through selection scans were annotated to understand their biological functions. Gene Ontology (GO) and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) enrichment analyses were performed to identify over-represented pathways and biological processes.

Datasets

The study utilized whole-genome SNP data from:

  • 61 Chinese Red Steppe (CRS) cattle: Genotype data available on Figshare (https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.21586182.v1).
  • 392 Holstein (HOL) cattle: Genotype data obtained from the Genome Variation Map (GVM) under accession number GVM000516.

All samples were aligned and annotated using the ARS-UCD1.2 reference bovine genome.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distinct Genetic Architectures: CRS and Holstein cattle exhibit clear genetic differentiation, with CRS showing high internal homogeneity and limited substructure, reflecting its local adaptation and breeding history. Holsteins, in contrast, display greater genetic diversity and more complex substructure, likely due to extensive crossbreeding and global gene flow.
  • Shared Ancestry and Divergence: Both breeds likely originated from a common ancestor and diverged approximately 3500 years ago (around 700 generations ago). This divergence timing aligns with cattle domestication and migration patterns.
  • Recent Population Declines: Both CRS and Holstein populations have experienced a significant decline in effective population size (Ne) in recent times. This trend is attributed to intensified breeding for production traits and highlights the need for genetic diversity conservation.
  • Targeted Selection for Dairy Traits: The study successfully identified genomic regions under selection, particularly those associated with milk production. The ACSM gene family, involved in butanoate metabolism, emerged as a strong candidate for driving differences in milk fat synthesis between the breeds.
  • Functional Pathways for Milk Production: Enrichment analyses revealed that pathways related to protein folding (e.g., proteasome function, response to unfolded protein) and butanoate metabolism are crucial for milk synthesis and quality. These pathways are essential for managing the cellular stress associated with high milk production.

Key Results

  • Genetic Differentiation: PCA showed that PC1 explained 57.48% of the total variance, clearly separating CRS and HOL.
  • Divergence Time: SMC++ analysis estimated the divergence time between CRS and HOL at approximately 3500 years ago.
  • Candidate Genes: A total of 767 candidate genes were identified through the combined FST and XP-CLR analyses.
  • Strongest Selection Signal: A cluster of ACSM family genes (ACSM2B, ACSM1, ACSM4, ACSM3) on chromosome 25 showed the most significant selection signal, implicating them in milk fat metabolism.
  • Enriched Pathways: GO analysis highlighted terms like "response to unfolded protein" and "proteasome core complex," while KEGG analysis pinpointed "Butyrate metabolism" as significantly enriched.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Functional Validation: While the study identifies candidate genes and pathways, further functional studies (e.g., expression profiling, gene knockout) are needed to validate their specific roles in milk production and adaptation.
  • Phenotype Association: Integrating phenotype data with the genomic findings would strengthen the association of identified genes with specific dairy traits.
  • Breeding Strategies: The findings provide a theoretical basis for precision breeding and the sustainable utilization of CRS. Future work could focus on incorporating these insights into genomic selection programs to improve milk production while preserving valuable adaptive characteristics.
  • Cross-Breed Complementarity: The study suggests potential for developing cross-breed complementary breeding strategies, which could leverage the strengths of both breeds.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study delineates the genetic divergence and demographic history of CRS and HOL, and pinpoints core genes and pathways-particularly those governing butanoate metabolism and protein quality control-underlying dairy traits. These findings furnish molecular markers and theoretical guidance for precision breeding and sustainable utilization of Chinese Red Steppe cattle.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{niu2025population,
  author = {Peng Niu and Xiaopeng Li and Xueyan Wang and Huimin Qu and Hong Chen and Fei Huang and Kai Hu and Di Fang and Qinghua Gao},
  title = {{Population Genetic Structure, Historical Effective Population Size, and Dairy Trait Selection Signatures in Chinese Red Steppe and Holstein Cattle}},
  booktitle = {Animals},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/ani15172516},
}
Figure