TL;DR
This paper investigates how to efficiently decompose polygons to speed up the computation of their Minkowski sums, a fundamental operation in fields like robotics and CAD. The authors find that simple triangulations are surprisingly inefficient, and that the optimal decomposition strategy for one polygon often depends on the other, leading them to propose a "mixed objective function" for simultaneous decomposition.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Minkowski sum of two sets, P and Q, is defined as {p+q | p ∈ P, q ∈ Q}. This operation is crucial in various applications, including robot motion planning, assembly planning, and computer-aided design. For polygonal sets, computing the Minkowski sum can be computationally expensive. A common preprocessing step is to decompose complex polygons into simpler convex subpolygons. However, the choice of decomposition method significantly impacts the efficiency of the subsequent Minkowski sum computation. This paper aims to systematically evaluate different polygon decomposition techniques and identify those that lead to the fastest Minkowski sum construction.
Methods
The authors explore and implement several polygon decomposition algorithms, categorizing them into those that use Steiner points (additional vertices) and those that do not. Key methods include:
- Triangulation:
- Greedy Triangulation: Recursively splits polygons by adding diagonals.
- Optimal Triangulation (Minimizing Max Degree/Sum of Degrees): Uses dynamic programming to find triangulations that minimize vertex degrees, aiming to reduce complexity in the resulting arrangement.
- Convex Decomposition without Steiner Points:
- Greedy Convex Decomposition: Similar to greedy triangulation but stops when no reflex vertices remain.
- Minimum Number of Convex Subpolygons (min-convex): An optimal algorithm that finds the decomposition with the fewest convex pieces.
- Convex Decomposition with Steiner Points:
- Slab Decomposition: Extends segments from reflex vertices to decompose the polygon into convex slabs.
- Angle Bisector Decomposition (AB): Extends internal angle bisectors from reflex vertices. This is a 2-approximation to optimal convex decomposition.
- KD Decomposition: Inspired by KD-trees, aims to reduce the "stabbing number" of the subdivision.
The paper also describes two algorithms for constructing the final Minkowski sum from the decomposed convex pieces: the Arrangement Algorithm and the Incremental Union Algorithm. The latter, while having a worse theoretical worst-case bound, often performs better in practice.
Datasets
The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it uses representative polygonal shapes for testing, including:
- Star-shaped polygons: Used to demonstrate the impact of decomposition on union time.
- Fork polygons: Used to illustrate cases where the Minkowski sum complexity can be high (Θ(m²n²)).
- Knife polygons: Used to investigate the interaction between the decomposition of two polygons.
- Random-looking polygons: Used in experiments to study the effect of scaling one polygon on the decomposition choice for the other.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Triangulations are generally inefficient: Despite being a common decomposition, triangulating polygons leads to poor performance in Minkowski sum computation due to the large number of resulting pieces and intersections.
- Decomposition choice is context-dependent: The optimal way to decompose one polygon (P) can depend on the shape and complexity of the other polygon (Q). This challenges approaches that decompose polygons independently.
- "Mixed objective function" is beneficial: The authors propose a procedure for simultaneously decomposing both polygons, optimizing a "mixed objective function" that considers properties of both. This aims to minimize the complexity of the resulting arrangement of sub-Minkowski sums.
- Heuristics can be very effective: While optimal decomposition algorithms exist, they can be computationally expensive. The paper shows that simple heuristics, especially for angle bisector methods, can yield significant improvements in Minkowski sum computation time with much lower decomposition overhead.
- Vertex degrees matter: The number and arrangement of high-degree vertices in a decomposition can negatively impact the performance of union algorithms.
Key Results
- Experimental results show that triangulation methods (naïve, min-max degree, min-Σd²) consistently lead to significantly slower Minkowski sum computation times compared to convex decomposition methods.
- The min-convex decomposition (minimizing the number of convex subpolygons) generally yields the best union computation times, although its decomposition cost can be high.
- Improved angle bisector (AB) decomposition heuristics (e.g., "small side AB") offer substantial speedups (up to 50% faster union time than standard AB) while remaining simple to implement.
- Experiments with "knife" and random polygons demonstrate that as the relative size of the input polygons changes, the preferred decomposition strategy for one polygon can shift, validating the need for a mixed objective function.
Limitations and Future Work
- Decomposition Cost: While some decomposition methods are fast, optimal methods like min-convex can be computationally expensive. The paper notes that improving the running time of these optimal algorithms is an ongoing challenge.
- Steiner Points: The paper discusses decomposition with Steiner points but notes that for minimum-length convex decomposition with Steiner points, a constant-factor approximation algorithm is still an open question.
- Simultaneous Decomposition: The paper suggests that simultaneously decomposing both polygons is a promising direction, but the implementation details and optimality of such approaches are not fully explored.
- Robustness vs. Speed: The authors mention that their implementation prioritizes robustness and exactness, which comes at a cost in speed compared to floating-point arithmetic. Further optimizations for speed are desirable.
Summary updated