Polycentric or monocentric, which kind of spatial structure is better for promoting the green economy? Evidence from Chinese urban agglomerations

Yue Huang, Ruiwen LiaoResearch 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether urban agglomerations—clusters of neighboring cities—should be organized around a single dominant hub (monocentric) or multiple balanced centers (polycentric) to best promote a "green economy." The researchers find that while polycentricity generally boosts economic and resource efficiency, there is a critical "sweet spot"; excessively polycentric structures can actually hinder progress, and monocentric structures remain surprisingly effective for centralized environmental protection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban agglomerations are the engines of modern development, particularly in China, where they account for over 75% of economic output. However, they also generate over 75% of the nation's pollution. Policymakers face a dilemma: how should these city clusters be structured to achieve a "multi-win" of economic growth, resource conservation, and environmental protection?

Existing research often looks at these factors in isolation—studying how city shape affects either GDP or air quality. This paper bridges that gap by integrating these dimensions into a single "green economy" framework. It specifically tackles the debate between monocentricity (one giant city dominating the cluster) and polycentricity (several large cities of similar size) to determine which spatial mode is most sustainable.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-staged econometric approach:

  1. Spatial Measurement: They use the Pareto exponent ($\beta$) to quantify the monocentric index. A value $>1$ indicates a monocentric structure, while $<1$ indicates a polycentric one.
  2. Green Economy Evaluation: They construct a comprehensive index using 19 indicators across three subsystems: Economic (e.g., GDP, labor productivity), Resources (e.g., water/electricity usage), and Environmental (e.g., waste treatment, $CO_2$ emissions).
  3. Projection Pursuit Model (PPM): To aggregate these 19 indicators, they use PPM, a technique that handles high-dimensional, non-normal data more accurately than standard methods like Principal Component Analysis (PCA).
  4. Dynamic Panel Threshold Model: Instead of assuming a simple linear relationship, they use a threshold model to identify if the impact of spatial structure changes once a certain "tipping point" is reached.

Datasets

The study analyzes data from 16 major Chinese urban agglomerations (including the Yangtze River Delta and Pearl River Delta) over a 15-year period (2003–2017). Data was sourced from:

  • The China City Statistical Yearbook (CCSY).
  • The EPS database (China Data).
  • Estimated $CO_2$ emission data based on established academic methodologies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Sweet Spot" (Threshold Effect): The relationship between city structure and the green economy is non-linear. The authors identified an optimal monocentric index range of 0.8436 to 0.9671. Within this window, the spatial structure provides the maximum benefit to the green economy.
  • The Polycentric Advantage for Growth: Moving toward a polycentric structure generally helps the Economic and Resource subsystems. It encourages synergy between cities and prevents the "drain" effect where one massive city sucks all resources from its neighbors.
  • The Monocentric Advantage for Pollution: Surprisingly, the Environmental subsystem benefits more from a monocentric trend. The authors suggest that dominant core cities often have better infrastructure for wastewater treatment and more stringent, centralized environmental regulations, making pollution control more efficient than in scattered, smaller cities.
  • The Risk of "Excessive Polycentricity": If a region becomes too fragmented (excessively polycentric), it loses the efficiency of scale, leading to a decline in green economy performance.

Key Results

  • Overall Progress: The average green economy score for Chinese urban agglomerations rose significantly from 0.4269 in 2003 to 1.0733 in 2017.
  • Subsystem Divergence: While economic and resource efficiency saw continuous improvement, the environmental subsystem showed only slight gains, indicating that pollution control remains the "weak link."
  • Current Status: Most Chinese urban agglomerations are not yet in the "optimal range." For example, the Yangtze River Delta is successfully moving toward polycentricity, while others like Guanzhong are becoming increasingly monocentric and moving away from the green economy ideal.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few hurdles:

  • Data Gaps: Certain high-value indicators, such as "green patents," had to be excluded due to inconsistent reporting in official databases.
  • Mechanism Clarity: While the paper establishes that these correlations exist, the specific socio-political mechanisms (e.g., how local government "promotion tournaments" influence city shape) require deeper qualitative study.
  • Dynamic Nature: The "meaning" of a green economy is constantly evolving; future models may need to incorporate newer metrics like digital economy integration or carbon neutrality milestones.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The green economy has gained worldwide attention, especially in the urban agglomerations where population and economic activities are highly concentrated. However, what kind of urban agglomeration spatial structure is more conducive to promoting the green economy? No clear conclusions have been made. Here, we study the impact of urban agglomeration spatial structure on the green economy, and also reveal how urban agglomeration spatial structure influences the three subsystems of green economy. We find that: (1) urban agglomeration spatial structural evolution is closely related to green economy, while in the research period, most urban agglomerations are not located in the optimal range of the spatial structure that drives the green economy. (2) Towards polycentric spatial structure is contributive to green economic growth, however, the excessively polycentric could not benefit green economy. (3) The evolution of urban agglomeration spatial structure exerts heterogenous impacts on the three subsystems when green economy is decomposed into economic subsystem, resources subsystem, and environmental subsystem. Towards polycentric is more conducive to the improvement of economic subsystem and resource subsystem, while, the tendency to monocentric drives the environmental subsystem development. (4) Lastly, our conclusions enlighten the urban agglomeration development planning and spatial mode for approaching a better performance in green economy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2021polycentric,
  author = {Yue Huang and Ruiwen Liao},
  title = {{Polycentric or monocentric, which kind of spatial structure is better for promoting the green economy? Evidence from Chinese urban agglomerations}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-314418/v1},
}
Figure